Album Review

Score 9.3
Written by Tim Pigeon
Published on 3/7/2004
It seems as if I’ve been waiting forever for Gone Forever to finally hit the stores. God Forbid’s previous album, Determination, hit me with all the force of a 20 lb. sledgehammer to the noggin. Their abrasive approach to metalcore struck a nerve to the extent that there is no question in my mind that it was my favorite album of 2001. Well three years have passed and God Forbid’s place in the metal world certainly has improved. They’ve embarked upon innumerable tours and generated enough buzz to land themselves a slot on the upcoming, metal-filled Ozzfest 2004.

Having been in attendance at a few of their recent concerts, I noticed a slight change in approach with the new songs that were previewed. This change is confirmed upon listening to the first track. Clean vocals have infiltrated this album, with the Coyle brothers contributing backing and chorus cleans that, at certain times, sounds like Jerry Cantrell. Big bad Byron still delivers plenty of throat-scarring screams, so the shift isn’t that drastic. The clean vocals in “Forcefed” (which sound like the GF of old) only serve as a harbinger of the new developments revealed upon the rest of the album. The songwriting is much more traditional and improved, although I’m sure not everyone will find that to be a positive thing. Gone Forever leans much more in the vein of American melodic death, with the metalcore influences being dramatically diminished, showing up in the occasional breakdown. This should see them squarely competing for, and sharing, the audience of bands like Shadows Fall, Darkest Hour, and Killswitch Engage. What works in God Forbid’s favor is the simple fact that they just surpass the aforementioned bands.

The linchpin of the GF machinery is the incredible guitar assault by the brothers Coyle. They seamlessly transition between hyper-melodic leads, fist-pumping rhythm riffs, and bonecrushing breakdowns. Bassist Jon Outcalt and drummer Corey Pierce ensure that when the band wants to bludgeon you, they will succeed. Combine all this with a superb production job that keeps the brilliant guitar tone from Determination, and you’ve got one hell of an album on your hands.

God Forbid fire an opening salvo with “Forcefed”. There’s nothing pretty about this song. The riffs and screams are desperate, while the closing breakdown is dragged out oh-so-perfectly. It’s one of the top five breakdowns ever, in my opinion. Next up is “Antihero”, which makes the point perfectly clear that the boys have progressed. This is a great song with gripping melodies and just a classic metal feel to it…that is, when they’re not breaking down on your ass. By now, I’m sure many of you have already heard “Better Days”, but for those that haven’t, it’s a fun track that’s as radio-friendly a song as you’ll ever hear from them, but don’t expect to hear this on your local station any time soon. “Washed Out World” features some venomous, thrashy riffage, and a nice early buildup that is sure to rile up the pits.

I could continue to give high praise to every other track on the album, but what’s the point? If you’re not convinced by now, you’re missing out on some excellent metal. While this isn’t quite the album I was expecting from God Forbid, it’s precisely what I wished that so many other bands would deliver. Gone Forever sees the band streamlining their sound, and then proceeding to play it better than all of the rest of the New Wave of American Metal scene. Impressive!



rattlehe@d's Avatar
rattlehe@d | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Im huge enemy of this NWOAHM or whatever(sorry if its not the correct acronym:>) but these guys seem to do what all other american bands do better. I also like mastodon but sorry i dont think they are NWOAHM. As for bands like killswitch and trivium ewww they are so bad for me. I mean ok they know how to play guitar drums etc but ok i know how to play the guitar too but tht doesnt mean i am a good musician cause my writing is sucky. Not as sucky as trivium's though:)
Unknown Metalhead
Dave Jay | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
Whether this is hardcore metal, thrash metal, or metalcore I really couldn't give a fuck. This is a really good METAL album. All 13 tracks are thoughtfully written and brilliantly executed. All band members are top of their game in this album. I rate this a 5/5/6
Unknown Metalhead
Danny | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Being better than killswitch isn't exactly hard, my two year old niece is more metal than killswitch
Unknown Metalhead
tomatoes | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
i want, aaaaahhhhhhhh, give it to me you french whores
Unknown Metalhead
ThMsqofARedDeath | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
i usually don't post on old reviews... to say this band is better than killswitch... whatever... better than shadows fall... who fucking cares... but better than darkest hour, definately not. i'm not the biggest fan of metal-core, but darkest hour have a little more originality and technical prowess. to me it just sounds like this band isn't even really trying,,,
Unknown Metalhead
rattle | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
Speci same opinio here too
Unknown Metalhead
Tim w/MR | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I'll be reviewing the new God Forbid next. I actually just got the CD this weekend.
Unknown Metalhead
aDAMN | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Constitution of Treason is bloody great! We need to see a fuckin review already.
M4Gg0T5's Avatar
M4Gg0T5 | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Gone Forever is pretty damn good and I heard stuff from the new album wich seems to be even better. God Forbid have release some pretty nice stuff and I respect their work BUT I hate the band itself. I don't like their attitude on stage. BTW dont pretend that our favorite band are Shadows Fall, Unearth lolol.. they are "ok" nothing more. I like metalcore and I don't give a shit about what style is the music.. If I like what I hear that's the only thing I want and GONE FOREVER is pretty intense.
Unknown Metalhead
\m/usclehead | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
All you guys that keep denying that most of our favorite American metal bands are metalcore need to wake up. God Forbid, Shadows Fall, Unearth, and all the other similar bands are basically metalcore bands. Not to say this is a bad thing, those are some of my favorite bands, but they are metalcore. Chugging guitars, hardcore shouts,ripped off swedish riffs, c'mon, admit it, they're metalcore, but it still fuckin rocks, so who cares?
Unknown Metalhead
aDAMN | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Who gives a fuck what category you wanna put this band in.....bottom line: they're really fuckin good.
Unknown Metalhead
Speci | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Shouted vocals with chuggy breakdowns, and semi-swedish guitar work=metalcore. The thing I can say for these guys is their vocal melodies don't suck, which, if your an American metalcore ban, is a feat in and of itself. Unfortunately, beyond that, I don't find them too interesting.
Unknown Metalhead
B-ricer | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I see this band more as melodic thrash.
Unknown Metalhead
Eddie | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
HOW THE FUCK IS THIS METALCORE. God damn I hate morons.
Unknown Metalhead
key to nothing | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
this launched them into metals elite.the Coyle brothers play with amazing precision
Unknown Metalhead
tom | posted on 12/2004 | Reply
these guys are good and so are a lot of metalcore bands. i hate when people say that all metalcore has emo vocals. they can fuck off
Unknown Metalhead
BlackRain | posted on 9/2004 | Reply
i have this album I like it, But each song has veryyy similiar guitar riffs....I dont notice much melody in the guitar but its good all together. The production on the bass drum could've been louder too I sometimes can barely hear it.
Unknown Metalhead
Dan | posted on 8/2004 | Reply
These guys went over the limit for metal music....this band is wat metalcore is all about.
Unknown Metalhead
alphaenemy | posted on 7/2004 | Reply
These guys really ARE better than Shadows Fall, KSE, Darkest Hour. I hate to say it with regards to Shadows Fall, because I will always cherish their next release, but God Forbid just write better music. Buy this album. Yeah, it's metalcore, but it still has it's own personality and power. The lead on "The Anti-hero" is worth the $10+.
Unknown Metalhead
jay | posted on 7/2004 | Reply
i went to ozzfest yesterday (1st time there) and got to see lead singer of g4b and he hooked me up with a sig. and i gave him some dap, he kicked ass out there, had the fans goin nuts, keep it up homie. i felt ya music
Unknown Metalhead
kev | posted on 6/2004 | Reply
its quality, go and buy it now.
Unknown Metalhead
Jim_Fear | posted on 4/2004 | Reply
This album is awesome ,best of 2004 yet.Mind you this is the first 04 album ive heard this year so yeah.
Unknown Metalhead
Emily | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
The c.d is fucking amazing. I can't wait until they come back to St.Pete. It's going to be some raw shit. They did a wonderful job. That Ty guy can go suck a dick. ~*Emily Hit me up on aim if you have any comments, lIlAntiHerolIl or Ill Nino Is Cool
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/MetalReview | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
I can't wait to see these guys live. This is some good shit! 5.5 5 5
Unknown Metalhead
ChaosTheory | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
This album does kick serious ass & I'm definitely addicted to it. The Coyle brothers continue to prove themselves as a guitar team to be reckoned with! Great review too! Personally, GF was always metal, without the 'core' to me!
Unknown Metalhead
drunken ghost | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
one of the best releases of the year.
Mettalmann's Avatar
Mettalmann | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
They removed it..that's why you don't see it. GOOD JOB metal review
Unknown Metalhead
Mactoolpower | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
good review i really dig this band i dont see any racial coments in your posts, though i dont consider this band better that killswitch engage
Unknown Metalhead
ERK | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
What are you talking about? I wasn't being racial. I was being honest.
METTALMANN's Avatar
METTALMANN | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
Hey what the hell is up with the racial comments? You know I read your opinions on here for a long time now, but what you wrote is uncalled for. If you don't like the music it has nothing to do with someones color!!
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/MetalReview | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
It's your call...
Unknown Metalhead
ERK | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
What should I review? Something I like or something I hate?
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/MetalReview | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
Hey Bro, when can we expect another masterful review? Your fans are all impatiently waiting...
Unknown Metalhead
davefons | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
Erk, the fact that you can cream yourself over shadows fall (a good band) but not recognize how solid God Forbid is(a clearly superior band), is a clear testament to both your poor taste, and close mindedness.
Unknown Metalhead
Slash | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
Breakdowns are gay as all hell.
Unknown Metalhead
JustinTime | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
Unearth - Endless
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
But you know who this sounds like? Gardenian on their Sindustries album. From your review only, I have not heard any God Forbid.
METTALMANN's Avatar
METTALMANN | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
I picked this up yesterday, and spun 3 times already. It is a great CD, and worthy of the praise it gets.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
I'm an unabashed God Forbid fan, I can't help but heap on the praise. But it's not as if it's not deserved with this album...
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 3/2004 | Reply
good album but I guess I would've rated it slightly lower; nice review Diesel.