Album Review

Score 8
Written by Ramar Pittance
Published on 2/7/2012
The following is a portion of a list of grindcore acts described as "no nonsense," according to a quick Google search.

Wormrot
Misery Index
Napalm Death
Nasum
Rotten Sound
Extreme Noise Terror
Terrorizer

 
This list, while not comprehensive, tells us less about bands than it does about our expectations of grindcore. To label a grindcore act as "no nonsense" is to lionize their rejection of frivolity and pretension.

This makes sense. Grindcore rejects nonsense in much the same that it rejects just about everything -- compressing sound along each axis to create something impenetrable, utilitarian. It is a killing thing.

Right now, there are a couple of albums generating some buzz for testing the limits of grindcore's nonsense probation. One is Liberteer's Better to Die on Your Feet Than Live on Your Knees, an album that stacks nonsense -- in the form of turn of the century American Folk interludes -- on top of what you could probably get away with calling no-nonsense grindcore. It's daring in its own right, but it knows that it's weird. Liberteer recognizes the distinction between nonsense and no-nonsense, and plays on it in a way that's meant to affect the listener.

There's also Norway's Beaten to Death, a band that's so subversively weird because I honestly don't think they're aware of that distinction.

Xes and Strokes is a weird and infectiously melodic grindcore album. But, probably not in the way that you're used to thinking of weird and infectiously melodic grindcore albums. These guys aren't Birdflesh. Beaten to Death doesn't introduce unconventional instrumentation or melodic vocals to the mix, either. The songs mostly run in the 1:30 to 2:30 range, and the tempos swing between marches and blasts. The weirdest thing about Xes and Strokes, then, is that Beaten to Death seems to believe that this is how grindcore ought to sound.

What does it sound like? Think Lykaethea Aflame interpreting "Where the Slime Live" on Les Paul guitars, with the stipulation that there needs to be at least 20 seconds in every track where Dan Hoerner (Sunny Day Real Estate) could make a guest spot on vocals if he wanted to. And, again, the weirdest thing about Beaten to Death's take on that eye-rollingly convoluted brew of styles is that they execute it with a conviction which suggests that these sounds do belong together.

In terms of production, Beaten to Death's sound has even less to do with grindcore, sounding instead like the band snuck into the Foo Fighters' recording studio and decided to do some very, very cruel things to the instruments. The mix works, though, as Beaten to Death's songs need room to breathe.

On "Soulless Alarm," the band builds melodies from hazy arpeggios, casting them against rattling, martial grind passages. Bass is free to roam in its own register, and steers the song to crescendo when it finally swallows itself whole. Beaten to Death doesn't so much balance opposing forces and they reject the entire notion of opposition. Bright major chord progressions and post-rock melodies -- like those found on "A Word to the Wise" or "Groundhog Day" -- aren't so much introduced into tracks as they are booted into the fray and forced to fight for purchase. And while that might suggest a haphazard design, what it really makes for is an album that sounds almost uniform in urgency, no matter how sunny the sounds get.

While Beaten to Death will probably never be known as a no-nonsense band, Xes and Strokes succeeds in establishing its own eccentric standard -- a sound entirely their own. These are sounds that demand to be heard, because nobody else is making them.



frantic's Avatar
frantic | 2 weeks ago | Reply
Seeing this band live in Oslo tonight. Finally a good band playing an under 18-show... Also playing is benea reach, and insense, the latter of which is actually really good. looking forward to a good night!
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Since when has Misery Index been no nonsense? I know they have a politcal message and all that, but they also have a sense of humor they splatter all over their albums. Which I don't mind at all.
Radar's Avatar
Radar | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
"There's also Norway's Beaten to Death, a band that's so subversively weird because I honestly don't think they're aware of that distinction." <- That one had me grinning. I'll have to check this one out.
Americannibal's Avatar
Americannibal | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Going off their photo, these guys look more like an Alton Brown-core band.
Mark's Avatar
Mark | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
No mention in the review or lashes about Brutal Truth? That's some essential grindcore right there.
Konradkantor's Avatar
Konradkantor  | posted on 2/2012
Last year's BT was nonsense, though.
frantic's Avatar
frantic | posted on 2/2012
fuck it wasn't. only control room
frantic's Avatar
frantic | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
I think the "sunny day real estate" vocals belong to Tommy from insense, whichs is an awesome band. Actually the only metalcore-ish band I listen to ever
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Hard to believe that the 2nd most douchiest, most hipsteriest, most face punchingly person in the bunch is the drummer of Tsjuder...At least I can finally rub it in my buddy's face that Tsjuder is a hipster band.
dave's Avatar
dave  | posted on 2/2012
Man, that will be awesome.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
Your a hipster, weak
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
your hipster week. Hipster week on Discovery Channel. This site seems to be very touchy on hipster comments. I see the word hipster getting thrown around everywhere.
konradkantor's Avatar
konradkantor  | posted on 2/2012
Apparently, the new thing is calling anyone who weighs less than 200 pounds and understands how to use a thesaurus a hipster.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
Thank YHWH I weigh more than 200 pounds. And I don't have a mustache. And I don't listen to any indie bands formed after 1992. I'd be scared of someone calling me a hipster. But I do have quite an extensive knowledge of metal. I believe that the current generation of "indie hipster" must have an extensive knowledge of metal. Of course, every few years you have to change which of these genres you must know. The last one I knew they studied was black metal. Before that stoner/doom. Before that was general 80s heavy metal. I've been seeing quite a few hipster lately wearing death metal shirts (particularly Disma for some reason)?
konradkantor's Avatar
konradkantor  | posted on 2/2012
Wish I could answer that, but I live in the 9th ward of New Orleans with a lot of black people so I have no idea. I hate hipsters though, so I find it ironic that I'm sometimes called one on this website. I think a lot of the "hipster" insults here come predominantly from deathcore fans that don't like hearing their genre is completely void of quality.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
You're called a hipster because of exactly that sort of comment - you believe you're more knowledgable, have better taste and listen to more sophisticated metal music than the majority of metal fans. Fact is you're just a young man who hasn't had enough life experience to warrant this type of attitude, hence you are without a doubt a hipster.
greigoroth's Avatar
greigoroth | posted on 2/2012
Thanks Anonymous! I used to like Konrad's reviews because they were well written, interesting and insightful. But you've conclusively proven that he's a hipster so I'm bailing on Metal Review. In fact fuck it, I'm bailing on the whole metal genre. You're all a bunch of hipsters. WITH NO LIFE EXPERIENCE!
konradkantor's Avatar
konradkantor  | posted on 2/2012
It's okay greigoroth, I'm quitting soon so that I can spend some time with indigenous Amazon tribes and Zulu warlords in order to gain the life experience needed in order to meet the approval of "anonymous IP address." Only then will I be able to say that DEATHCORE IS GAY without being called a hipster.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
Amazon tribes!? I was living with Amazon tribes back in 2005 before it was cool. Hipsters are above making fun of deathcore. They just scoff it and listen to Ruins of Bevarest or whatever other shitty arty hipster indie black metal is big. You can tell how hipstery the hipster is by his knowledge of black metal. And no, you can't have any knowledge of black metal without being a hipster. I'm sorry.
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Regardless of which of the two one prefers (I like both), it's hard to argue that ANb should be called "no nonsense." They've got nonsense a-plenty, which is (I assume) why many of us love them.
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 2/2012
BALLS. That was supposed to be a reply to the below thread.
Konradkantor's Avatar
Konradkantor  | posted on 2/2012
So much nonsense that they're no-nonsense. While we're at it, there's a good chance Terrorizer might disqualify itself from this elite list in the next month or so...
Radar's Avatar
Radar | posted on 2/2012
No-non-nonsense? I think we're be headed for Bogus Journey levels of recursion.
Konradkantor's Avatar
Konradkantor  | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Am I the only one who thinks Wormrot should be replaced by Agoraphobic Nosebleed or another band that's, you know, better?
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 2/2012
Given the option of listening to Wormrot or ANb, I'm picking Wormrot ten out of ten times.
dave's Avatar
dave  | posted on 2/2012
I like AnB--especially the Converge split--but I honestly have no idea what the hell they are.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 2/2012
I know this conversation would be better held elsewhere, but all ANb from Frozen Corpse forward kicks the shit out of Flashinthepanrot.
frantic's Avatar
frantic | posted on 2/2012
god, agoraphobic nosebleed is good
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 2/2012
Shit, that split with Converge is one of my all time favorites. AnB kills most other grindcore bands. Period. Including Wormrot.
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
When Sunny Day Real Estate is mentioned in a grindcore review, it immediately throws up "WTF??" flags. In other words, I need to check this out. Thanks for the great review.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
I used to know what grindcore is; I don't anymore. To me this sounds more like late 90s/early 00s metallic hardcore than anything else. Maybe I'm splitting semantical hairs, but Insect Warfare is grind, Gadget is grind, Nashgul is grind, this is most certainly not.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
Agreed, this is just another mediocre metalcore release
Dimensional Bleedthrough's Avatar
Dimensional Bleedthrough | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Man, that is one happy-looking grind band.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
I reviewed this for teeth last week- awesome cd
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012
Erik - I grabbed this the second I finished reading your review last week over at TOTD. Thanks for the heads up. Great cd. Ramar - This is, by far, one of the best cd reviews I've read in ages ( no offense, Erik). Hope to read more of your stuff in the future.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 2/2012
no offense taken- this is a killer review
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Beaten to Death's guitarists actually play Fender Telecasters—thus the single-coil twang of those melodic parts. Great review of an awesome album, Dave. I see what you meant about that intro.
Octomac's Avatar
Octomac | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Well, I usually just kind of pass on grindcore bands -- that brutal compression of sound and purpose you mentioned in the beginning of your review actually kind of acts as a barrier for me to have to overcome in order to enjoy them. After reading this, though, I'm very interested in checking these guys out. Sounds like they might have the missing element that's keeping me from enjoying the more "no-nonsense" bands the genre has to offer. Also: very well-written review!