Album Review

Score 7.5
Written by Konrad Kantor
Published on 1/11/2012
Yes, the new Alcest is here, and at the rate of pissing off just about everyone (for the album either being scored too high or too low), I have placed Les Voyages De L'Ame directly in the better-than-average-but-still-not-memorable category. Since the band's inception, Alcest has strangely become one of the most polarizing bands in metal today. By now, most people probably have very strong opinions about the band -- opinions that are probably more necessary to address at this point rather than reiterate past words that writers have used to describe just what Alcest is all about.

First order of business: all you overprotective parents of black metal, could you kindly stop whining about this band? Never in my life would I have ever imagined such a large group of crybabies to come from a subculture as controversial as black metal. On the contrary, perhaps I just don't have very good hindsight. Traditional black metal fans, with their internal disdain for society aside, are nowhere near as problematic or dangerous to society as many of them appear or wish to be. "Shut the fuck up already and talk about the music, you stupid hipster" is something people are probably saying to themselves at this point in the review. That's fine, but you guys are the ones who sound like a bunch of pampered pussies for complaining so damn much, not me.

In short, Les Voyages De L'Ame, or Travels of the Soul for those who can't pronounce French and would like to prevent people from using the word lame in the same sentence as this album, sounds as characteristically "Alcest" as fans could ever hope for. All of the album's eight tracks are as etherial as Neige's past works, and contain production that is absolutely marvelous. Although most of Voyages is on the softer side, the album contains a small share of heavier moments as well, and falls directly between Écailles de Lune and Souvenirs d'un Autre Monde as far as extreme moments are concerned. Unlike the former full-lengths, this year's release lacks both the brevity and individuality needed to stand out among other efforts in Alcest's catalog.

The main problem with Voyages is that the songs mostly sound like they could be filler for Alcest's past works. That description is not meant to be all-inclusive, but merely a general observation that Neige hasn't really attempted to expand the sound of his most prized project this go-around. And perhaps he doesn't need to. After all, the man does have a habit of starting new bands and side-projects all the time. (Insert 5,000 Neige side-projects here.) But that doesn't change the fact that 50 minutes of black metal-infused shoegaze can be pretty fuckin' boring, to put it eloquently.

To me, Alcest has always been about telling a story. Just like a good story does when given the chance, the music will take any listener into Neige's awe-inspiring fantasy world filled with colors, warm feelings, confidence and even a few accents of melancholy. This years tale, although a tad bit redundant, is no less heartfelt than any of the others. All in all, Voyages contains some alluring tunes that are both introspectively soothing and emotionally captivating.



Black Waterpark's Avatar
Black Waterpark | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Does this remind anyone else (if only in spirit) of Novembre? Novembre had a much stronger death influence, and subsequently more powerful drumming. This album is my first listen - so far I am pleased!
Black Waterpark's Avatar
Black Waterpark | posted on 2/2012
I just read down the lash trail, it sounds like JX agrees
Grob's Avatar
Grob | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Perfect 10 for me, this album is simply magical.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
no, don't you dare putting away the Lantlos review... I will kill you with a spoon
frantic's Avatar
frantic | posted on 1/2012
me^^
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Who on Earth considers this album "black metal" ? : / Genres aside, Alcest is incredibly boring. Each album has about 4 minutes of worthwhile music, while the rest of it is simply fluff. One step away from being the suckiest bunch of suckers that ever did suck.
ManicAeon's Avatar
ManicAeon | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
I think this is a pretty fair assessment of the album. It hasn't hit me as hard as Écailles de lune, but it's got some solid tracks on it. 7.5 is certainly fair.
Frantic's Avatar
Frantic | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
some of this material is really good
mEtalvolution's Avatar
mEtalvolution | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Redundant as...Everything is useless---Nothing works at all---Nothing ever matters---Welcome to the fall...Welcome to the fall...Welcome to the fall...
raetamacue's Avatar
raetamacue  | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
This is a really fair review. Also, despite my intense love for Alcest, I laughed when I saw the link to this review reads: les voyages de lame.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
The reason why BM fans hate on this band... is because they started out as BM and moved into shoegaze.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
6.5 tops
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Great review. I also roll my eyes when people want to down this band for being soft or whatever. This is what they do and it's all I want from them. Although I could have used a little more harsh vocals on this one
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
I think the scores right. It's Alcest, and it wears out with the time. Not every song is necessary, it could have been an EP in my eyes. It's definitelly Neige's formula, and maybe even best executed so far, but overall the last two efforts had more edges and intersting sides in my eyes. This one gets very uniform with the time, turning into a kind of background sound after half the length, at least for me. Of course it's no Black Metal. There's nothing to discuss about.
jx's Avatar
jx | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Black metal? Really? This is Anathema-esque atmospheric rock with metallic tingles a-la later Novembre, with a dash of Opeth's mellower moments and even some October Rust goodness. These influences (at least for me) are too obvious to ignore, but rendered with enough emotion and subtlety to give this a character of its own. I may be also alone in believing that Neige's harsher BM side is now fully realized in no less awesome but entirely different Lantlos project.
Konradkantor's Avatar
Konradkantor  | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Definitely not BM, but for some reason black metal fans always hate on Alcest. Never meant to imply this band was anything close to BM, but also didn't want to get into genre semantics. Not sure who tagged this as black either... I will change this as soon I can.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
Yeah this is pretty much a rock album
klabautermann's Avatar
klabautermann | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
I really like Alcest and I'm not even sure if we can still call this Black Metal. Good read, Konrad, though the last paragraph made it seem like the score should be a little higher.
big_red01027's Avatar
big_red01027 | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
I think it's obvious that there's a gigantic gulf of difference between you and the "crybaby pussy" BM fans you're calling out here. Maybe it's just me, though.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2012 | Reply
...is better than scales and secret