Album Review

Score 8.5
Written by Erik Thomas
Published on 11/3/2003
While Heaven Wept Ep•ic Pronunciation: 'e-pik Function: adjective Etymology: Latin epicus, from Greek epikos, from epos word, speech, poem -- more at VOICE Date: 1589. 1: of, relating to, or having the characteristics of an epic. 2 a: extending beyond the usual or ordinary especially in size or scope b: HEROIC. An epic may deal with such various subjects as myths, heroic legends, histories, edifying religious tales, animal stories, or philosophical or moral theories. Doom Pronunciation: 'düm Function: noun Etymology: Middle English, from Old English dOm; akin to Old High German tuom condition, state, Old English dOn to do Date: before 12th century 1: a law or ordinance especially in Anglo-Saxon England 2 a: JUDGMENT, DECISION; especially: a judicial condemnation or sentence b (1): JUDGMENT 3a (2): JUDGMENT DAY 1 3 a: DESTINY; especially: unhappy destiny b : DEATH, RUIN Synonym see FATE Heavy Metal Function: noun Date: 1974: energetic and highly amplified electronic rock music having a hard beat As much as I d like to leave my review at that, I feel I should at least expand on this fine, fine album. I should first preface this with the fact, I never really got into “classic” doom as such (Candlemass, Trouble, Solitude Aeternus, etc), preferring the rumbling girth of My Dying Bride and Paradise Lost. However, I do have in my CD collection one sore thumb of an album that I am proud of; Solstice “New Dark Age”. I didn’t think I’d ever find a band as good, that epic, that emotional-all with clean vocals. Well erstwhile readers I give you While Heaven Wept, new to me but with a considerable underground discography, "Of Empires Forlorn” is the utter epitome of epic, classic doom metal; soaring vocals cast over behemoth riffs, layered with harmonious and delicate synths. And while I am enamored with more guttural acts like Pantheist and Mourning Beloveth, “Of Empires Forlorn” has moved me with the same amount of oppressive sonic weight, albeit tinged with a ray of uplifting hope. While still not a huge fan of the essentially power metal vocals, the music on display here is often jaw droppingly good, both in scope and delivery, and the vocals actually suit the epic riffs perfectly. Between each song, there is an ocean themed sample that adds to the ambience of the album, but also made my bladder freakishly weak. That added nuance just really adds to the album's aura that makes you close your eyes, and just kind of ebb along with the blissful heaviness as it washes you away. As to be expected the songs are all lengthy exercises in metal poetry, with only the cover of Candlemass’s “Epistle #81” (I would have only known it is a cover by looking at the credits, as it blends seamlessly with the other songs) clocks in less than 4 minutes. After prolonged listening, While Heaven Wept are master craftsmen of the genre, and to me personally as a metal fan, that’s their only real downfall. While certainly appreciating rending tracks like the opener, “The Drowning Years”, and the rending “SoulSadness”, or even the almost tear inducing, instrumental album closer “From Empires to Oceans” (essentially an acoustic rendition of the superb title track), this still is an album I don’t see my self coming back to that often despite its brilliance. Maybe my phobia of clean vocals is the culprit, as to me the songs play like a collection of down tuned power metal ballads. And for some reason, Manowar’s slower, epic songs (“The Crown and the Ring”, “The Bridge of Death”) kept coming to mind. So when a slight more harsh vocal delivery surfaces during the massive title track, I got tingly for a brief moment, it’s that perfect musically. A truly moving album that shows While Heaven Wept are to be considered the epoch of their genre, especially for US bands. But even though my scores reflect my objective view and recognition of the obvious mastery on display, I must warn listeners expecting monstrous funeral doom that this plays more like traditional heavy metal/classic doom laced with agonizing beauty and solace.



Unknown Metalhead
wladimir | posted on 7/2007 | Reply
beautiful,amzing,doom forever................
Unknown Metalhead
davefons | posted on 12/2003 | Reply
This album is pretty enjoyable. Not a huge fan of synth keyboards, but, they work well enough. Even the vocals are damn good.
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
Well, it's a great listen, gets a tad boring towards the end...but i don't think "epic doom metal" categorizes is it very well, to me it seems more like "doom ballad," because the vocals (and some of the music) are very hair-bandish, but it's obviously a little more artistic and pathetically introspective, so that's where the "doom" part comes in; still though, great album
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
I'll check it out, i have "Judgement" and LOVE it, but i'm sure "Silent Enigma" is heavier Also, this cd won't show up in my mailbox for possibly another month, Amazon has to import this CD and the other 4 (yes, FIVE now lol) need to be shipped straight from the labels lol...i can't wait this long!! also, sorry to all you Evergrey fans about that little dumbass mistake, "In Search of Truth," now you can stop e-mailing me viruses
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
Hey, sorry I guess I did have a good happy hour yesterday...I was wondering why this was so good.....lol, just average for you now man (I am kidding Lyco).
Unknown Metalhead
Lustmord | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
yah The Silent Enigma is awesome. Second-im not Lyco... :)
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
Jackson, check out the Silent Enigma from Anathema (if you have already excuse the rant), it does for me what MDB could never do, like you I felt it just drowned on and on with nothing to fucking make my dick hard....you know what I mean? Anathema can do this and also Icon from PL can do this. Second, Lyco, awesome review bro.....truely your best man, I might check this out too.
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
is this in any way similar to "In Search of Time" by Evergrey? because all of the reviews i've read of that CD say the same thing: good doom metal with appropriated clean vocals
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 11/2003 | Reply
...was only gonna be 3 CD's: "Choirs of the Eye" by Kayo Dot, "Empiricism" by Borknagar, and "In Harmonia Universali" by Solefald; now i'm gonna buy 4 on my next paycheck thanks to Lustmord's review, this sounds like some VERY interesting stuff, just what i was looking for as far as doom metal is concerned i could never get into my dying bride because although i could see their talent, i could never appreciate it because the music never elevated in tempo or pitch, which i need for at least 2 minutes in a song without it putting me to sleep; that and i hate how the vocals were as slow as the music, but also guttural, just doesn't work for me