Album Review

Score 9
Written by Jordan Campbell
Published on 4/27/2011
Album number seven: Most bands limp to this landmark, bleeding and barely breathing, as their longtime fans silently beg for a mercy kill. Not Primordial

After hitting a stride with 2000's Spirit the Earth Aflame, this Irish collective went on to perfect their craft on their initial offerings for Metal Blade: the suffocatingly grey Gathering Wilderness, and the electrifying, inspiring To The Nameless Dead. Now, they've been charged with crafting a follow-up to consecutive career highlights. A daunting task, assuredly. Lesser acts would desperately grasp backwards, retracing steps in search of former glories. For Primordial, however, there is no glory. Only resilience. That resilience is the crucial element in which Redemption at the Puritan's Hand has been so indomitably cast. 

Stylistically, Redemption splits the difference between the aforementioned dual opuses. The barnstorming bile-burners of Nameless punctuate Redemption's first half, while Wilderness-style introspection encapsulates the latter. (A burly pair of pace-changers, "God's Old Snake" and "The Black Hundred," pock the album's midsection, failing to conjure much in the way of fireworks. These are rare unfocused moments, but the latter track steals some value with a subtle nod to The Ruins of Beverast and a circle-jigging coda.) Thus, it's a tale of two facets. Primordial is confidently exploring the strongest aspects of their repertoire, culminating in some of their most clearheaded and focused songcraft to date. 

Primordial is at their best when not only somber (as this perpetually-greyscaled group tends to be), but also seething. Their moments of clenched intensity not only allow drummer Simon O'Laoghaire to exert his will--a defining aspect of the band's lean-on-the-riff approach--but they bring out the best in A.A. Nemtheanga's soul-stirring roar. And that's really what we're buying the ticket for, is it not? To hear one of the few clean vocalists still standing practice his craft? His delivery on Redemption--wholly unique, horrifyingly impassioned, and ultimately inspiring--has never been more impressive. His lyrics and storytelling are the reasons why Primordial's name will remain spoken long after the empire is reduced to rubble.

Nemtheanga's turns of phrase bring typical tales of metallic solidarity and world-weary wandering into hallowed territory on "Bloodied Yet Unbowed." His tortured contemplation on the rhythmically brilliant "Lain With the Wolf" molds it into one the band's mightiest offerings. And his old-school rabblerousing on opener "No Grave Deep Enough" is enough to evict the dead from their slumber. 

Flipping the coin, when the band globs on the gloom, they're equally potent. "The Puritan's Hand," powered by Pól MacAmlaigh's thunderous rumblings, begins in markedly bleak fashion. As the pace quickens, Nemtheanga's furnace reaches a boil, and the track morphs into a driving anthem for the ages. Here, the band's subtly streamlined approach truly shines. Where past epics like "Sons of the Morrigan," "Gods to the Godless," and "Cities Carved in Stone" lacked nothing in terms of potency, their immediacy is comparatively tempered when constrasted with Redemption's near-dessicated purity. Primordial's latest conjured fog isn't as grossly oppressive as those of the past; crepuscular rays poke persistenly. These songs breathe

This cardiovascular fortitude makes Primordial the most vital heavy metal band on the planet today. By design, they are not slaves to convention or rigid aestheticism. No conventions of subgenre must be heeded, and there are no peers with which to compete. Their very existence is based on outright rejection of the traditional metallic ethos--thou shalt worship the riff!--in favor of lyrical potence and stark individualism, the latter of which should rightfully be the truest of our beloved genre's tenets. Thus, quite paradoxically, Primordial is a folk entity first, a metal band second--take a listen or twelve to "The Mouth of Judas"--and yet remain the closest thing heavy metal has to a standard-bearer in 2011. 

Seven albums, and no signs of slowing. No regrets. No remorse. All hail Primordial.



Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 7/2011 | Reply
Good review, but I have to disagree with saying 'Gods Old Snake' fails to conjure much in the way of fireworks. I think that's the best song on the album, hands down. But hey...like they say...opinions are like a**holes...
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
It's taken some time but this album makes me a convert. Still not the biggest fan of the singer but the music is great. The drumming is really fine. And i have my dose of partisans, rebels, hangmen, ghosts...
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
His vocals are really starting to grate, which isn't helped by how ridiculously high in the mix they are.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
Excellent review! As you clearly said: All hail Primordial!
DungeonKeeper's Avatar
DungeonKeeper | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
One of the most passionate and hard-working bands in heavy metal today. Deadly album!
ManicAeon's Avatar
ManicAeon | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
Finally got my hands on it, and oh what an album it is. These guys are almost tearjerking-ly emotional in their delivery. I don't think there has ever been a band that makes me feel more in tune with being alive (I don't know how else to describe the feeling) than Primordial. These guys can raise the dead their music is so mighty and powerful. This is metal.
thetrooper's Avatar
thetrooper | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
loved To the Nameless Dead. Gonna have to check this one out too.
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
This album is good at first spin, great after a few. Complex enough to discover juicy new tidbits each listen.
lee's Avatar
lee | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
Got To Nameless Dead based off of a review here but really not my thing outside of 2 or 3 songs, don't know why, maybe just not a fan of this style. I might give this a shot and see if it does something for me.
Besty's Avatar
Besty | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Looks like I better give this a listen then eh? Thanks for the review mate
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Well, I´ve heard the album.... It´s great, yes, but I personally prefer the overall result of "Gathering Wilderness" and "To The Nameless Dead". Still, songs like "No grave deep enough" and "The Mouth of Judas" KICK ASS very hard. Hail Primordial, see you in Hellfest 2011!!!!!!!!
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Enjoying this one very much and it's definitely one of my faves of this young year. Primordial has been on one hell of run since Storm Before Calm and it appears there is no stopping them at this point. Great, great band.
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Primordial might be MR's equivalent in the way my friends look at Tool....they can do no wrong. The blind worshiping will not allow you to look at the album in any other way but favorable. Not saying that about this album...but, it'll happen.
evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 4/2011
Bands I like very much can do very fast wrong for me due to my high expectations. From this records I was positivelly suprised. Especially after Blood Revolt which I didn't like at all.
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 4/2011
If this site was the only outlet singing Primordial's praises that might be true, but most critics see Primordial as a premiere and very consistent metal band. I might agree on Blood Revolt though, I really did not like that one and can't understand what some people saw in it.
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Might be my album of the year. Still early, I know, but this is the hardest a Primordial album has hit me on the first few listens.
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 4/2011
that kind of how i felt, although the last two are amazing, the gathering wilderness took me a bit to get into, seeing as it was a blind buy for me, the mags talked it up so much, I had to buy it, and boy am I glad I did. This one clicked instantly.
black_carnage's Avatar
black_carnage | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
can't wait to grab my hands on this one
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
great album, hasn't come out of the player yet
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Sounds good. Sign me up!
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Excellent review, Jordan. I keep hearing a lot of interesting rhythmic touches here that make me wonder if Alan's turn in Blood Revolt hasn't had some influence on this album.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
6/10
evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 4/2011
old score / new scoring system
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
Just give it a ten already
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
holy smokes, got all kinds of words in there. That was a tough read, but I think I agree with it... I think.
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
We want the review, we want the review! Album already purchased, sans review ;-)
evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
I prefer the layout of the last two albums, but the music speaks for itself.
evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 4/2011
A masterpiece, most of the time
ManicAeon's Avatar
ManicAeon | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
SCHWING!
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 4/2011 | Reply
YES.