Album Review

Score 9.2
Written by Michael Wuensch
Published on 2/21/2011
There's a lot to love about the San Francisco/Bay Area, but if I had to choose one element that tops the list, I'd go with that region's inclination for stubborn open-mindedness that stretches across nearly every facet of day-to-day life, including its enterprising music scene. The adventurous "anything goes" mindset maintained by so many of the musicians at play is readily supported by an equally progressive fan-base and a wealth of available venues for performances, thus resulting in one of our country's most vibrant, diverse scenes that consistently forges projects that obliterate conventional genre boundaries. And while I'd agree it can be tedious continually trying to label and further tag every innovative "sub-genre" that blazes down the chute, it's something I've gotten used to during an age when people mostly rely on hyperlinked tags in blog margins and sites like Last.fm to help point them in the direction of new music worthy of investigation.

That said, welcome to the greatly anticipated third release from San Francisco's post-progressive-sludgy-chamber-whoosa-whatcha-muh-metal power trio, Grayceon: a band that burned into the arena in 2007 with a pioneering debut that hammered more than a few metal fans and critics to the wall and suitably cast the project under oodles of listeners' microscopes. And while just one spin of All We Destroy will likely continue to paint a baffling picture for those who somehow weren't ensorcelled by the band's brand of epic cello/guitar/drum yarn, those of us who've long-since consumed and lovingly digested the debut and its excellent 2008 follow-up will notice quite a number of shifts with record number three.

The single largest deflection this time around, apart from the fact that there's only one tune (among six) that stretches well past the 10-minute mark, has to do with the amount of vocal emphasis placed throughout. While certainly a commendable element on previous works, the amiably textured male/female vocal layering mostly took a backseat when compared to the delicate interplay between Jackie's satiny-smooth cello, Max's finger-picked guitar style and Zack's often manic drumming. And while all those elements are still undoubtedly present in spades once again, All We Destroy ups the ante in terms of unearthing new vocal terrain…for Jackie. 

That's another shift for 2011: Max folds in his accompanying voice very sparingly on this record, leaving the rest of the new waters -- of the turbulent variety, mostly -- to be explored solely by Jackie. And really, this adds yet another compelling element to the trio's already innovative sound. Jackie screeches in Ludicran fashion throughout All We Destroy, opening an entirely new angle of rancor that previous records never touched. But as is the case with Grayceon, balance is the key element to the formula, so while Jackie's cord-shredding provokes spots on nearly every tune, there are plenty of stretches where her delicate voice takes the spotlight, also with rewarding results. Her stint with the moody AmberAsylum was enough to show she has a pretty voice, but the lullaby lilt of a tune like "Once A Shadow" is so pretty, soothing and calming, it could soften a crotchety one-eyed wolverine with a face full of porcupine quills into a squirming ball hoping for a belly-scratch within a scant minute.

There are some musical shifts on the record as well, but they're a little less in your face when balanced against the vocal deviations. The album's "Rime of the Ancient Mariner" strikes with the suitably epic 17-minute "We Can", which grandstands the band's ability to ebb and flow seamlessly between turbulent measures and stretches of melodious cool-breezing with every bit of the same passion and talent you'd hear from a celebrated orchestra, but there's a new "focus," for lack of a better term, that allows the remaining tunes to achieve nearly the same level of saga in a surprisingly short amount of time, by Grayceon standards. Closer "War's End" is the only tune to spend its entire 7-minutes driving the album home on a pleasantly mellow note, with the rest of the selections doing a fine job of bending the band's hallmark mid-paced sludge within a windstorm that can strike angrily, heavily or surprisingly calmly at any given moment, and at times with each instrument filling a completely different role. On a personal note, I absolutely love it when Max and Jackie play sweetly and serenely while Zack flails like his armpit hair is on fire, and the ol' wish gets granted more than a few times throughout these tunes.

Really, there's not much for me to blubber about, apart from the mix of the record taking Max's grittiness too far into the background here-and-there. I'd say If you've been a fan of the band through their first two records, round #3 will certainly give your stereo and headphones something richly rewarding to obsess over for the foreseeable future. Like a handful of other great power trios of our day, Grayceon has managed to rip up what's conventional, even by progressive music's standards, and they comfortably jet along a path solely on their own. Tag them however you'd like, the bottom line is that Grayceon creates some of the most compelling and rewardingly innovative music of our day, and All We Destroy nails the bullseye once again.



Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
Once again the Captain has made the burden of carrying my pocketbook just that much lighter.
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
"Silly to assume the role of Arbiter Of What Is And Is Not Properly Called Metal." Then who is the arbiter of what is metal. I guess you are, since you review this rock record at Metal Review.
dougwhatyoudidisrape's Avatar
dougwhatyoudidisrape | posted on 3/2011
Dear GDubya, please stop your terrible posting. Sincerely, everyone at MR
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 3/2011
hey dubya...let's hear YOUR band!!!! i bet it's soooooo fucking awesome!!!
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
Really!? So i am required to go complain about any other album i don't like because... Surely you folks have better reading comprehension than you are showing. I praise this site for it's mistakes in what is metal or good metal or great metal. I also made 3 points about the album which i really dislike, wandering pointless playing and tone and the vocals. And this is Metal Review, right? (Frankly, Earth also sucks)
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 3/2011
This is precisely my point: Totally fine to take issue with vocals, riffing, cello, whatever. Silly to assume the role of Arbiter Of What Is And Is Not Properly Called Metal.
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
This album doesn't even qualify as metal. It certainly is not GREAT, unless out of tune pseudo-operatic soprano cooing is Great or meandering endless Cello with lousy muffled sludgy repetitive guitar riffs is GrEaT. It doesn't surprise me. At other "METAL" sites, its Power Metal that is great, or Korn. At least here, Grayceon, Agalloch, and Burzum are great, but lots of real great metal is great, which i greatly appreciate. This album doesn't cut it as metal and certainly doesn't deserve the great metal accolades laid on it here.
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 3/2011
I guess I just don't put much stock in scene-policing. Disliking an album is one thing; disliking it because it doesn't tick all the metal boxes on one's list seems silly to me.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 3/2011
Yeah, seriously folks. If you're gonna be the purity police, go get mad about Earth or Clutch reviews. That or just shut the shit up.
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
Oh, are WE just capitalizing WHICHEVER words we FEEL like now? FUN. Which is to say, this album is great. Er, GREAT.
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
I hear they will open for Kansas and Yoyo Ma. A 9.2, on METAL Review. Amazing.
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 3/2011
Yo-Yo Ma > Kansas
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 3/2011
Most things > Kansas. Yo-Yo Ma > most things. Including Cephalic Carnage.
ManicAeon's Avatar
ManicAeon | posted on 3/2011
Hey, I like Kansas, and I love this album :(
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
Amazing album. Got it on release day!!! Loved #2 but this one is even better.
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
Sweet, gonna go order this one later. Once again I bow before the incredible band-signing might of Profound Lore.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
Love this band.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
Great review dude.Really looking forward to this.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
I can't wait to give this one a lesson. Seems like joining Giant Squid gave Jackie some confidence in trying different vocal styles. Loved the tracks they've released so far. I wouldn't be surprised if this makes some Top 10 lists by the end of year. Pure speculation at this point but I hardly expect them to drop the ball right now.
Danhammer Obstkrieg's Avatar
Danhammer Obstkrieg  | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
I'm about to lead a pilgrimage down to my mailbox to set up camp and wait for the mail carrier to deliver this one unto mine ears after this tasty review.
stoned to death's Avatar
stoned to death | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
Great review, Cap. I imagine it can't be too easy to review a band like Grayceon. Can't wait to get my hands on this. I have fond memories of when I caught them with Giant squid. Grayceon played first and I had the pleasure of meeting both bands, but especially remember talking to Max between and after sets. And then hanging out with him at the front of the stage during the Giant Squid show. And Jackie is one of the most sweetest and humble musicians I've ever met.