Album Review

Score 10
Written by Konrad Kantor
Published on 11/22/2010
In 1994, the Norwegian band Ulver lit a fire with the release of their uniquely composed folk metal album, Bergtatt - Et Eeventyr I 5 Capitler. Although small, this flame burned uncharacteristically bright within the hearts of three individuals, namely Don Anderson, Jason Walton and John Haughm. These men may have never thought they would have been able to take this small fire and set the entire world ablaze with it; but sixteen years later, that is exactly what they have done.

Over the past decade, Agalloch has grown from having a small cult following into something truly iconic. Now, as 2010 nears its end, Agalloch has given us something that shall be remembered as one of the few pieces of music that transcended its own time and helped carry its listeners into a new decade of progression. Marrow of the Spirit is something so powerful and so incredibly emotional that the words of any language would do it no justice. Agalloch has not only managed to encapsulate all of their previous sounds into exactly one hour of playing time, but has also built upon them, making Marrow of the Spirit the group's most expansive, versatile and complete effort to date. Marrow of the Spirit contains the ebb and flow and rich buildup of Ashes Against the Grain, the dark, powerfully crafted atmosphere of Pale Folklore, the tragic melancholy of The Mantle; and it also successfully captures the beauty of nature's echoes most recently displayed on The White. If one thing has remained constant throughout all of Agalloch's creations it is this: the music has the power to rescue and aid the most restless of souls from the bowels of despair and hopelessness, and also the capability of dragging that same joyous spirit back down into the depths of sorrow from which it came.

One of the more pressing questions that arose prior to this release was whether all of the experimentation that took place on The White would somehow make its way onto the band's next full-length release. Although slight traces of the calm waves of the ocean or the nostalgic sound of one "trudging through the deep snow" are briefly prevalent in previous efforts, the intensified sounds of nature featured on The White were the foundation for that entire release. "They Escaped the Weight of Darkness," the opening track of Marrow of the Spirit, picks up right where The White left off, only this time the sound of a freshwater stream is accompanied by the lonely notes of Jackie Perez Gratz's (Grayceon) cello. Traces of the cello are to be found throughout the entire album, but none are as dominant as those occupying the album's brief but memorable opener.

The reverence of the opening track is short-lived, as a blitzkrieg of drums pound and blast their way "Into the Painted Grey." The addition of drummer Aesop Dekkar (Ludicra) has immediately proven itself to be a successful one, as no Agalloch song has ever sounded as fast-paced and intense as this. The quality of the album's production, although drastically different than anything the band has released since Pale Folklore, is absolutely perfect given the dark composition of the album. The amount of riffs contained within "Into the Painted Grey" is unprecedented. The overlapping guitar melodies intertwine beautifully with the more subtle bass and cello, making the track unforgettably triumphant. The changes in both melody and the song's pacing arrive, leave and return as naturally as the seasons.

"The Watcher's Monolith" sounds more like modern Agalloch than any other track on the album. Most noticeable are the riffs that are very reminiscent of Ashes Against the Grain's catchiest song, "Falling Snow." Although the structure of "The Watcher's Monolith" is completely original, there is an interesting sense of humility behind the notes of both of these songs that makes them quite comparable. Much like on Ashes Against the Grain, Agalloch has chosen an early moment in the album to allow the listener's spirit to be filled with happiness for a brief yet memorable moment. The depth of the track is best exemplified by its subtleties, which blossom more fully with each listen, and is proof that Agalloch builds each of its songs based on emotions from life's many experiences.

Nightfall. Brief snippets of Jeffrey Neblock's (Vindensang) piano follow the sound of crickets into Marrow of the Spirit's opus, "Black Lake Nidstång." Haughm's seething vocals seep through the crushingly heavy drone of the guitars. Depressing would be an understatement if one were to attempt to describe the feelings given off by this seventeen minute-long anthem. "Black Lake Nidstång" contains just about every genre of emotionally extreme music that has ever existed. Haughm's voice is enough to send one into an instant state of depression in the song's former half, especially when accompanied by the long, drawn-out, guitars.

Looking back at Ashes Against the Grain, the one thing that many questioned was the conclusion of the "Our Fortress is Burning..." trilogy. Referring to that specific track, John Haughm said, "This was the first piece of the trilogy to be written. Chris approached me with this drone thing he was working on and I absolutely loved it. It had to be on the album somehow. So I used it as inspiration to build the rest of the trilogy. Most people seem to think we put it on the album as filler but it is actually quite the opposite. Without "The Grain", the entire "Fortress" trilogy wouldn't exist."

Whether Agalloch could take this newly acquired technique (which helped inspire what might be the greatest climax in the history of heavy metal) and incorporate it into further songs remained to be seen...until now. About halfway through "Black Lake Nidstång," a similar drone technique is used to help pull the listener out of the depressing state they were previously dwelling in, as the guitars coincide perfectly with a bubbly, electronic melody. The transition is subtle, yet perfectly executed.

"Ghosts of the Midwinter Fires" starts off very lightly -- a much needed turn of events after the emotionally draining state the listener will be in after being overcome by its predecessor. The 80's distortion effect used on the guitars is the song's most distinguishable quality, as the rest of the song's notes seem to follow the lead of the opening ones. As the song comes to it's close, sounds of the shore hint that there will be no more uplifting moments on Marrow of the Spirit. The album's concluding track, "To Drown," is no less powerful a climax than "Bloodbirds" and will leave the listener absolutely mesmerized.

On a much more personal level, I found this review nearly impossible to write. I would have done anything to avoid writing it when I originally found out about the release, but a colleague and friend of mine requested that I review the album after having a family emergency. Naturally, I was honored to be given the opportunity and acquiesced immediately, but I couldn't help but feel afraid that something would go wrong. Agalloch is my favorite band after all. What if they happen to read the review and are disappointed? What if my words are inadequate? What if I'm completely biased and give the album a score it doesn't deserve? In order to overcome my doubts, I just listened to the music. I listened until I could play the entire album through in my head. The more I listened, the more I came to the conclusion that Agalloch truly is the sound of some powerful deity that cannot be summed up into words. They embody the new decade of what metal should be about, and they are not embarrassed to show it. They embody what every fan of extreme music going into the next decade should represent: a love of nature and a patience to withstand the frailties of human nature. Because love is really the reason why we suffer, isn't it? At times when it would be so much more convenient not to care, this music, if anything, reminds us of who we are and of the power we possess as individuals. If that be the case, than Agalloch is a representation of what already exists inside of us.

"If this grand panorama before me is what you call God, then God is not dead" were words once proclaimed by John Haughm, as he spoke of the grandeur of one of the Earth's many landscapes. Today, I utter those very words in reference to Marrow of the Spirit.



Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2011 | Reply
I enjoyed the metal/neofolk of Pale Folklore and The Mantle (and The White ep) a great deal but the more straightforward post-rock style of Ashes and Marrow doesn't appeal to me.
thetrooper's Avatar
thetrooper | posted on 11/2011 | Reply
Kicks ass-easily their best. The Mantle and Ashes Against the Grain tie for second. Pale Folklore has some great ideas, but the execution is a little too sloppy for my liking.
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
Rob Liz | posted on 1/2011 That might be the most honest thing you've ever said. Of course you don't get it. You're musical taste is quite limited and not your own. Gee....if so many other people like it and you don't maybe it's you. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I always hope that, if i ever get some freak stalker following me around, at least they are intelligent. No such luck. I draw this dummy.
Brubaker's Avatar
Brubaker | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
I've given this some time now, and I'm thinking it somewhere around Pale Folklore for the coveted number 2 spot behind the Mantle in the Agalloch discography. Kind of similar in circumstances to Blood in Our Wells in Drudkh's discography, as I still can't seem to enjoy any of their respective releases more than Autumn Aurora. Hard for me to call MotS a 10 unless the Mantle gets a 10 +1, tho. Still a very respectable release and one they can be proud of.
evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 1/2011 | Reply
I bought this today really cheap in the Itunes Store. If your a fan of the band, you certainly get the CD or Vinyl. But I think 5 bucks is a fair enough price for everyone.
DeathHead's Avatar
DeathHead | posted on 1/2011 | Reply
I've been a big fan of Agalloch since they released The Mantle, and this one took longer than usual to grow on me. Now that I've spent some time with it, I'd say this is up there with The Mantle as their best work to date. "Marrow..." is their most complete album - it incorporates aspects of each of their previous recordings but still sounds completely original. I've seen a few comments about the drums being sloppy in places and I agree, but eventually I started to believe that the organic feel of the drums is a perfect fit for this material. Mechanical precision would likely detract from the feel they're going for. I think it'll be a long time before this leaves my rotation.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2011 | Reply
I downloaded the album to check it out and i thought it was boring, still i bought it when it came out based on the good reviews; now i can can say that i love it, great atmospheres, great guitar melodies....good songs. At first i thought that the drum sound and playing was too sloppy but it grew on me; it refreshing to listen to something that sounds alive and its real, even if its out of time sometimes; nowadays everything is perfect sounding protools trickery, and guitar wankery with no feeling or soul. Listen to it with headphones!!
jacksonlefteye's Avatar
jacksonlefteye | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
why i'm having trouble finding this album locally i don't know, and it's pissing me off thing about agalloch, they get glowing reviews, and every review has polarizing comments under it give em a listen, and if something about it grabs you on your first listen, guaranteed you'll love them after buying an album and giving it a fair shot in studying it and discovering its subtleties if not, then it's not that you "don't get it," you just simply aren't inclined to the agalloch style, no matter how much of an ulver fan you say you are Ashes came pretty close to the majesty and transcendence of The Mantle, but it's close to impossible to ever record another piece of music as good as the mantle
jacksonlefteye's Avatar
jacksonlefteye | posted on 12/2010
wow what a jumbled mess that turned out to be, looks like the 'ol enter/return key is pointless in the new lash format
GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
I don't get this band at all. I certainly don't get the hyperbole surrounding this band. This may be the most un-Metal release i have heard all year. Most of it sounds like The Cure with Steve Hackett on lead and BM vocalist. They seem like the shoegazing indie pop of Folk/Black Metal. I'll keep trying though.
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 12/2010
The Cure with Steve Hackett and black metal vocals would be pretty kick-ass, actually.
Rob Liz's Avatar
Rob Liz | posted on 1/2011
That might be the most honest thing you've ever said. Of course you don't get it. You're musical taste is quite limited and not your own. Gee....if so many other people like it and you don't maybe it's you.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
sucks
titmo71's Avatar
titmo71 | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
is very nice...and the drums are fine
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
Beautiful review. I've listened to the album only once through, so I haven't yet developed a full opinion, but I do know that while I came in somewhat skeptically, not thinking they could improve on what they've already done, I walked away proven totally wrong. Agalloch truly are incredible in the aspect alone of standing the test of time, but also the fact that they seem to slightly reinvent themselves over time... This album seems to be the grand outcome of all those years.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
I'm very on the fence about this album. I've listened to it all the way through a few times but for some reason it doesn't have the same effect Ashes or The Mantle had on me. What bothered me the most was the beginning of "Into The Painted Grey" It just didn't seem right. Black Lake Nidstång is a monster, and easily my favorite song. Overall I like the album, but I don't think it's as memorable as some of their others. I've been hearing a lot of "Album of the Year" talk about this and I would have to give it some serious thought. Nothing this year has impressed me that much so it has a chance.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
I agree with Cap also..."Black Lake Nidstång" IS a monster..possibly my fav song by them.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
this band has changed music for me as a whole
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
I've seen the name Agalloch before, but never listened to them. This review compelled me to download the album this morning. I'm on my third listen right now and I have to say that this album is just what I needed after months of listening to mostly tech death. I'll be picking up The Mantle tonight. Great atmosphere and a pretty deep listen.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
This is the best album of 2010 in my opinion--windrider
smegma666's Avatar
smegma666 | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
I sincerely sympathize with the emotional distress of the reviewer, as it must have led him to become totally unrealistic with regard to the merits of this outfit. This is nothing but a total rip-off of the aforementioned Ulver (and several other Norwegian bands) - absolutely nothing new here. The album bored me to death, but one good thing came off it: I gathered all my great norwegian and swedish black metal discs from my vault, and have delighted in reacquainting myself with some truly majestic music. Lastly: The snare drum is just as annoying as the sound on Lars Ulrich´s on Metallica´s "Saint Anger" - and that says a lot! Crap.
TheKnife's Avatar
TheKnife | posted on 12/2010
I kind of agree here. This album just doesn't do much for me, and I was disappointed after reading the review. There are a couple gripping moments, but overall, boring
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
This album is fantastic. I've not heard this band until now, and from what I'm reading, the other material is just as good if not better. The word "epic" is grossly overused these days, but I think it truly applies to this collection of tracks. I can't get enough of it, been listening to this album all day. It fits right in with the dark, cold, snowy weather that's quickly moving in to my region. "Black Lake Nidstång" in particular is an absolute masterpiece.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
As a longtime fan of this band, I have to say that I am somewhere in the middle of all the previous comments. Compositionally, I think this is a very strong album with some definite highlights: no obvious filler tracks, some welcome aggression to contrast the lighter points, etc. However, I sometimes get the feeling of a loss of focus in many spots on this album. As mentioned by some, while I have no problem with more minimal production jobs, the drums often seem messy, especially in the more aggressive sections. Additionally, in the more sustained heavy drumming sections, it seems like Aesop loses his focus on timing a little. Anderson also seems to lose focus in some of his guitar noodling, coming off more like a Sculptured sound - a dissonance that seems less purposeful and a bit more amateurish. Other than these nitpickings, I think the songwriting is great, and I feel that this was a very worthy chapter in Agalloch's career. But I do miss some of the beautiful vocal harmonics found in THE MANTLE and ASHES, as well as the focus that those albums had. Contrary to what I read from other reviewers, I think ASHES is their strongest album, with a definite weakening towards the tail end. But to my ears, that is where they truly mastered the sound that was well-developed on the MANTLE (see You Were But A Ghost..), but lacking a little something; and a sound that is still the basic foundation here (most apparent on Watcher's Monolith). Regardless, this is still one of the strongest albums of the year, and I only nitpick because Agalloch has elevated themselves to ridiculously-high standards in the world of metal.
Hammerhead's Avatar
Hammerhead | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
This is simply an astoundingly beautiful and well executed album. Perhaps their best album to date. I have listened to it five or six times and it just keeps getting better. I hear something new after each listen. It hearkens back to their older works yet feels fresh. One listen will not give you a real feel of what they are doing here. It is simply brilliant.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
this isnt really a review, its just a guy ranting on about how great this band is...
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010
its because they are fucking great..
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I thought Ashes was their best,maybe up until now that is..
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Just received my copy today. Very good album, I'm not disappointed but I think it doesn't live up to the greatness of the Mantle after 2-3 listens. Let's see if this album grows on me like their first two albums... Ashes was not bad but definitely their weakest.
black_carnage's Avatar
black_carnage | posted on 11/2010
damn forgot to login :P
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
This album is really awesome. It get better and better at every listening...
hooter's Avatar
hooter | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I second the 10. This album is still growing on me, much like Snakes for the Divine hasn't let go just yet - another release I hold as a candidate for best of 2010. I try to look at it as if I had never heard anything from the band's back catalogue but knew they were held to very high esteem. From that perspective it is hard to match the intense beauty of this album from start to finish - very few bands of this elite caliber can consistently do it. Sure, in retrospect, it isn't quite as good as the 9.8 "Mantle". But I see this one as a 9.6 in its own right. I'll just round them up for argument sake and call 'em 10's
lordperrin's Avatar
lordperrin | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Good, but nowhere near as focused or well-produced as The Mantle. Maybe a 9, but 10 is overkill. I enjoy the album, but many of the songs seem to be long just for the sake of being long. Too many mindless wandering droning sections that take the song nowhere. I had the same issue with the second half of Ashes.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010
Definitely, The fact that 4 of the songs are over 10 minutes long is a bit of overkill I think. One or two is ok, but that's just a bit much.
Captain's Avatar
Captain  | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I dig the raw production because it helps to further amplify the more aggressive measures of the record. And I think Aesop's heavy-handed drumming brings a welcomed heft to the Agalloch sound. I dig it and can't stop listening to this record right now. "Black Lake Nidstång" is a monster.
konradkantor's Avatar
konradkantor  | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
At first, I was expecting the album to have the production of "Ashes Against the Grain," and when I heard the first mp3 they released, I was disappointed and didn't know what to think. After a couple of listens...which I'm sure many here haven't attempted considering everyone lashed the day this album came out...I realized that the minimalistic approach to the drum production Wharwulf mentioned is what helped bring out the darkness of the rest of the album. Ashes was not a dark release by any means. I think doing the drums the way they did was a way for them to incorporate some of the Pale Folklore atmosphere into some of their newer styles. Love it or hate it, the drumming does not take away from the brilliance of the album. If anything, Dekkar only made the album less accessible and more organic. I think The Mantle, Ashes, and Marrow are all brilliant releases and I'd rather have Agalloch try new things each time than get three different versions of a record they'll never be able to improve upon.
hooter's Avatar
hooter | posted on 11/2010
People are being nit-pickers cause you gave it a ten. The more I listen to this album the more I don't give a fuck about the drums - or the vocals. Everything comes together in the end
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I can see how some would be turned off by the drum sound on this but I think the minimalistic approach to the production suits this album perfectly. It was obviously intentional and I'm gonna guess the group got the sound they were looking for. They've never been one for a crisper, cleaner production and quite honestly it wouldn't sound like Agalloch if it was too overly produced.
trevors's Avatar
trevors | posted on 11/2010
I felt the same way about the production. I knew it wasn't top-notch, but I thoroughly enjoyed the album anyway. No drum triggers were used, giving the recording a more muddy, yet authentic feel. No one would dare accuse this album of being over-produced. Into the Painted Grey... wow.
hooter's Avatar
hooter | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Got my copy in the mail today and after listening to it all night I can soundly say it has met my lofty expectations, but just barely. As has been mentioned the drumming sounds funny, most notably during the blasting black metal parts and the album definitely isn't as good as what I, and most people commenting feel, is Agalloch's crowning achievement, The Mantle. But even so this one will probably find a way into my top 5 of the year and at least be in the top 10. Phenomenal band, phenomenal release
crazygrayv8's Avatar
crazygrayv8 | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Big fan of Agalloch, esp. Ashes, so will def. be looking this one up...huge review, nicely worded too. Remains to be seen if the album can live up to the 'hype'! ;-)
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
People like this? Ever since the "The Mantle" this band has just gotten worse and worse. "Ashes..." had about one good song and I don't think this album has even that. That 17 minute "epic" is one of the most boring songs I've ever heard in my life.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Great Review! Agalloch is one of the best bands around
gordeth's Avatar
gordeth | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Nice puff piece.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
whoa. Dude is either really high or really into this album.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I'm a longtime fan myself and I couldn't disagree more with this review. I think there's parts of this album that are damn near unlistenable. The drumming is the first aspect of the new album that is in serious need of some explanation. That kick drum sounds like smashed ass, especially during the faster black metal parts. In general, I don't care for the drumming on this entire record including the tones they decided on throughout. Just because a great band records an album, doesn't mean it's without flaws or that it doesn't come up short. I'd have a lot more respect for someone actually pointing out the flaws while still saying that they enjoy the album then I would reading about how someone jocks the band merelly because they've been great in the past.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 11/2010
i agree on the drumming- its very odd. doesnt change the brilliance of the album to me though
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010
A very good album in many respects, but I have to agree with all the comments on the drumming. Not a big fan of this guy's work here or with Ludicra. Same ham-fisted approach with both bands, same punchy but toneless drum sound.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 1/2011
Agree that the Bass kick sounds like a wet boot slapped on a gym mat, and if that snare skin was any more loose it'd be hanging out on street corners in a miniskirt saying: "For you i geev good pryce, handsome!". But for me the biggest trouble is how literal the drums recording is. When listened on a decent set of speakers it becomes annoyingly apparent they were recorded in a small room - possibly with 70's decor and wooden panelling. For this reason I find it almost impossible feel lead down to that stream in the woods or through that icy mountain path as apparently I'm not allowed to leave that poxy little room the drums were recorded in!! Musically this album is great and I love the song structures too - No complaints there! Likewise I have no problem with a bit of grit in the recording - no shame in "kicking it oldskool"! But not when it's at the expense of the suspension of disbelief. Don't think this was worth the £10.99 to be honest. But the download is definitely worth the £1.85 that Play.com are charging. (if you live in the UK)
lee's Avatar
lee | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Great review, it certainly has renewed interest in a band I haven't followed since the Mantle (basically because I don't think it could ever get any better then that album and don't like to be disappointed). Agalloch shows how you can make intelligent, thought provoking, personal Metal without coming of like a pretentious bunch of fucks. I wish more bands got this, especially in the whole post BM thing that goes on these days.
Number2's Avatar
Number2 | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I absolutely love this album. Agalloch continues to progress and yet they retain all of their original charm and style. How often do we see bands try and adjust only to alienate large portions of their fanbase? Agalloch is one of the few that build on what they do well by adding elements to their sound that amplify these strengths. This album begs to be listened to - at work, during my commute, on my patio with a cigar during last night's full moon.....anytime! Great job on the review, Konrad. I love that you mentioned the personal aspect of the Agalloch experience. I feel like I am lucky to "get" this band after reading some of the lashes. This album - more so than their others - allows me some space to get lost inside myself and as it plays thoughts bubble up to the surface, this album has become the soundtrack to my subconscious.
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I've enjoyed just about everything Agalloch has ever released... the albums, EPs, splits, pretty much all of it and I can easily say Marrow of the Spirit is their finest all around effort to date. Each prior release has at least one or two tracks I just don't like (sorry John, but the final track on Ashes is complete filler regardless of intent, and it gets skipped every single time). But this album has six truly perfect songs, and with the 'fall turning into winter season' upon us this couldn't have come out at a better time as far as I'm concerned. These cats are truly in a league of their own. Great review, Konrad.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
As perfect as mantle,even more progressive.It deserves a 10.
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I struggle with this band too. Can`t quite explain why, on paper they tick all the right boxes but I invariably find them incredibly tedious. I`ll give this another go but for the moment I`m at a loss to understand the hype.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Sigh, I just don't get this band at all.
Jishwa's Avatar
Jishwa | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I think after much time and patience with this album, I will probably agree with the score. Though the Mantle is a 10, so this one can't quite be. At least a 9 I'm sure, though I still need much more time with it.
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Hmm. Like Jonathan, I typically dislike when Agalloch tries to be overly "metal." The Mantle is--and forever will be--their best record, but even while professing my love for it, I have to admit that "I Am the Wooden Doors" sounds ridiculous. Oddly, though, I think the raw, aggressive opener on this one is the album's crowning achievement. I need to stew on this one for a while; initial impressions are overwhelmingly positive, and it's a definite step up from Ashes, which really only had two good songs. (Those two songs were phenomenal, though.)
jonathan's Avatar
jonathan | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I dunno, I just can't jump on the Agalloch bandwagon... their "black" metal parts sound faux, like they want to play black metal but don't really know how... and the vocals still suck, especially now with the embarassing "suicidal" yelping... I dunno. I liked the 'Black Lake' track a little, but only parts of it. To me, this wasn't as good as Ashes, which wasn't the near-perfect album to me that others thought it was.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
This album is good, but a 10? not even close...not even their best...maybe a 7.5
hooter's Avatar
hooter | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I was dying to hear this album before reading this. Now I feel like the 5-year old self I once was watching minutes go by on Christmas Eve bit by bit until Christmas morning finally arrived... and then I had to wait for everyone else to get up. Excellent review, great personal flourish at the end, perfect quote to close out with and an album that, if it meets my incredibly lofty expectations, is automatically slotted as album of the year. Cannot wait to get this one in the mail this week. Christmas is surely coming early this time around
DolphinDude31's Avatar
DolphinDude31 | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
The least surprising score of 2010. 2 listens in, I disagree with the score. I feel like many of the words spoken in the Paracletus review could also be applied here. But I see the greatness in the album...I just still see flaws as well. But that may very well change in time.
Twilight Frost's Avatar
Twilight Frost | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
This one is great.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
My ears must hear this!
Wanderer's Avatar
Wanderer | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I suppose this is a blind buy then. Will probably check out some samples first actually.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Anxious to hear the CD after reading this review!
p1ague's Avatar
p1ague | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I just bought this album yesterday. Haven't listened to it yet, but I'm really excited. Personally, I found 2010 has been one hell of a year as far as new band discoveries and debut releases go, but not a lot of follow-ups really stick out in my mind. Hopefully this is an exception...
asmo's Avatar
asmo | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Wow a 10. Not that I disagree really, in the running for album of the year as far as I'm concerned.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
That second-to-last paragraph really sums it up. A band everyone loves that is deeply personal to us all. Amazing album too, just starting to get acquainted with it.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
great review KK- great cd- as 'black' as theyve ever sounded.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
just perfect
ManicAeon's Avatar
ManicAeon | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
I am dying to hear this.