Album Review

Score 10
Written by Zach Duvall
Published on 9/19/2010
"Witness: march of the giants."

Few bands or artists of any media forge a legacy in which their fans can be one hundred and ten percent confident that new work will give them the thrills they are used to. To me, Enslaved is one such band. After ten albums shifting slowly from black metal to prog, they have maintained a constantly high level of quality and innovation. Even so, I felt myself becoming too comfortable with them, as if I was being lulled into an eventual No Prayer for the Dying- or Technical Ecstasy-type falter--some album that makes us finally and permanently question their immaculate creativity. This small but notable anxiousness is understandable, and I am not alone in having a few shorter fingernails as a result of anticipating their next Norwegian platter. After all, as their catalog becomes increasingly voluminous, and as they continue to experiment away from their blackened roots, it is only natural for us to assume that some misstep is bound to happen, right? Won't I eventually be disappointed by Enslaved just as I have been by all of my other heroes of mythical metal might?

Not a chance, at least not yet anyway. The evidence was clear from the onset of "Ethica Odini" and only amplified by the song's triumphant chorus: I was floored, and as the minutes passed I was only further engrained into the linoleum. Axioma Ethica Odini, the band's eleventh album, is larger than life itself. It is a towering colossus, guaranteed to not only find its way onto year-end lists, but likely to top them for numerous fans and critics. Only the ensuing adjectives referring to size and enormity do justice to this album's sheer mass and majesty. Everything--Ivar Bjørnson's riffs, the deft compositional touches, the production, the melodies, Grutle Kjellson's harsh vocals, Cato Bekkevold's stylistic-yet-classically-metal drumming--seems to be cranked all the way (pardon the reference) to eleven. It is an album for which the idiom "firing on all cylinders" is perfectly apt.

As with each step in Enslaved's career, Axioma Ethica Odini maintains the constant, if subtle evolution from recent albums. Remaining is the texture of Vertebrae, but with a much heavier delivery. Compared to Ruun and much of their recent work, it is more epic in scope--four songs at almost eight minutes and an album length of nearly an hour. The blackened roots remain, but the band also finds time to inject new styles into these prog landscapes, such as the doom/death which introduces "Giants." But the most strikingly fresh aspect is the clean vocal delivery, performed as usual by both Kjellson and keyboardist Herbrand Larsen. No longer reserved, the singing here contains much more emotion and inflection, adding to the album's quality at every turn and giving would-be ballad "Night Sight" a unique sensitive vibe hitherto untouched by the band.

One cannot say enough for the hard work and attention to detail that went into constructing these songs. Every track on Axioma Ethica Odini (outside of the tasteful and surprisingly necessary intermezzo "Axioma") is a compositional clinic and musical journey, immediate in quality but rich in rewards for the repeat listener. Little details emerge, such as how the chorus of "Giants" starts without vocals to increase anticipation, or how the layered and sorrowful crescendo of "Raidho" gains intensity and reaches its peak with the song's guitar solo finale (Ice Dale, we salute you). Closer "Lightening" is perhaps the best example of how the band builds a track while foreshadowing its climax. A section towards the beginning overflows with the sense of finality, but it is in how Enslaved returns to this idea over nearly eight thrilling minutes (including a wild bridge) that not only moves the song along but also ends the album in spectacular fashion. Only silence can properly follow.

Now... a special nod to THE RIFF, because Enslaved hath unleashed the proverbial hordes. The dissonant and mountainous chorus of "Waruun," the neck-jerking and evil-grin-inducing heaviness anchoring "Singular" (not to mention the bitchin' prog noodling), the galloping verses of "Raidho," and the harmonized rhythm chords in "The Beacon" are just a few examples of the torrential riff raining that floods this album. I could go on and on really, but there is no need, as each aspect of Axioma Ethica Odini is incredibly organic and free of pretentions, with every element ensuring that not a dull second exists. So while you listen, forget my ramblings and just take the album in, because every listener is bound to discover their own favorite moments. There are countless to choose from.

The only question left unanswered is the ultimate one: is this masterpiece also Enslaved's masterstroke? Time will tell, but it shouldn't have to. Ranking their catalog has always been pointless and will remain thus. In a career in which every release is light years away from the ho-hum, all feel irreplaceable while spinning. So for the most part I will choose to leave that question unanswered. There is, however, something extra-special about Axioma Ethica Odini, as if it is the culmination of what this particular Enslaved lineup has been trying to accomplish for years. If this is so, and if they are only now hitting their stride as a unit, the competition is urged to throw in the towel now before they find themselves being permanently maimed.

As for that opening quote, it isn't just a lyric from the album, but a fitting metaphor for where the band has taken their career. They truly are giants. May they continue to march.



Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 2/2012 | Reply
Everytime the nail me to the wall...I can't believe how good they are!Not even one mediocre release over all these years!!!!!Hall of the fame band among other metal gods and this album the best I ve heard in the last 5 years!
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 7/2011 | Reply
Yeah! But Agalloch this and Agalloch that...
thetrooper's Avatar
thetrooper | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
goosebumps. that part in lightening that just keeps climbing.
Franticfredsik's Avatar
Franticfredsik | posted on 5/2011
I know what you mean,,, this album is my favourite album of all time, absolutely perfect! the only album I can give a 10
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
This is the best album I have ever heard.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
Love it, again. They do it to me every time.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
A great band, good album, but BORING and repetitive, I fail to hear anything new on this album. There is better Metal out there...
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 12/2010
Where? Name it....
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
Enslaved have never disappointed me. For me, this album has no weak points.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
If anything deserves a 10 its this.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
I don't know, my first impression was: post rock. I guess this mostly comes from the rather simple drum patterns.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
i cannot wait to hear this release after reading such an awesome review. I too hold Enslaved in the highest regard and they never seem to faulter. Perhaps this album will top the mighty ISA?
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
how is this progressive?? you guys are nuts. this album is monotone and repetitive.
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 10/2010
you guy, are nuts.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 10/2010
Can't agree more.
TheKnife's Avatar
TheKnife | posted on 11/2010
You guys suck
TheKnife's Avatar
TheKnife | posted on 11/2010
(not ex-inferis)
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
I think this is the best shit i've ever heard.
mst's Avatar
mst | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
Ethica Odini is exactly what I wanted to hear. Vertebrae was so smooth it was boring.
Gorgonid's Avatar
Gorgonid | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
This album is too good for words, but you did a damn good job, Zach.
DeathHead's Avatar
DeathHead | posted on 10/2010 | Reply
Well I'm quite a bit late to the Enslaved party as this is my first album of theirs, and now I wish I'd checked them out sooner. After spinning "Axioma" nonstop for the last three days, I can safely say that I'm pretty much totally addicted to it. This is progressive metal done right, from the songs, musicianship, production, everything. I agree with the review and most of the lashes. Must...get...more.... The feeling I got the first time I heard this was that same rare "holy shit" feeling that I've had when discovering some of my all time favorite bands. I will be picking up their back catalog quickly. I already have "Below the Lights" and "Isa" on order. I'm open to suggestions on where to go from there.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
I'm extremely pleased with the change in vocal style. I enjoyed Vertebrae for the music immensely, not so much the vocals. This time around I'm really enjoying both! Just me??
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Thanks to everyone for the good words on my review. This was a hugely personal one for me, as Enslaved is one of the bands that certainly got me into the "finer side" of metal. Says a lot about the album that I've actually been more addicted to it since finishing this write-up.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Great Album and def deserving of a 10.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
I have to say one thing, I've been following these dudes since 2000, I know, I'm late to the party, but I have every single album. Here's the point though, this is the only band that when a new album is about to be released, I NOT SCARED!!! I just know they will not disappoint, and again they haven't. I don't know what to say anymore, how can a band be this awesome?
TheKnife's Avatar
TheKnife | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Fuck, I just realized jamesspringle lead with the same line. I feel like a douche now.........Stupendous review!!
TheKnife's Avatar
TheKnife | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Spot on review. I could not agree more. This album is absolutly spectaculer from start to finish. The clean vocals are very surprising, not only in how much they are infused in the music, but also in how they fit so perfect. You could not have sumed up Bekkevold's performance better either. The best part is, through it all, you still know it's Enslaved.
evilhobbit's Avatar
evilhobbit | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
this is gunna keep kicking my arse till ragnorock
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Goddamn epic! I can't say enough about the clean vocals on this one, they really stepped it up. Don't see anyone topping Enslaved this year.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Enslaved Are No longer following any style they ARE a style no footsteps to follow keep making your own you guys own!
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010
That's just it! You're right! THEY are the style! That's why they rule music.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Album of the year. By far!
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
I honestly think this is the best album I`ve heard for about 5 years...since Nevermore`s remarkable `This Godless Endeavor`. It`s fantastic.
julz's Avatar
julz | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
These dudes are just on another level! can't wait for my copy!!
Jishwa's Avatar
Jishwa | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Can't friggin' wait to hear this album.
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Solid review, Zach. Not quite a perfect album for me (yet?) but it's pretty god damn good. Mardraum and Monumension are my two faves by these guys and this will more than likely rank up there with those two. One of the more consistent yet always unique metal bands on the planet.
radar's Avatar
radar | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Linoleum doesn't have grains. Other than that, great review.
jamesspringle's Avatar
jamesspringle | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Spot on review, Zach! I've listened to this album front to back over and over and over since last night and your review nails everything I have felt about the album since I started listening to it. It's funny how earlier today I was wondering if you folks would be giving this album a perfect score, and I was right LOL. I'd say that the band is in top form here, but saying that would be a tad redundant. Album opener "Ethica Odini" hit me like a ton of bricks, and then the chorus came in and I was totally over for this album. As if that wasn't enough, the death/doom track "Giants" was MASSIVE, probably THE heaviest track the band has ever done. Is that really
jamesspringle's Avatar
jamesspringle | posted on 9/2010
(crap I hit submit by accident LOL) Is that really Grutle Kjellson hitting the lower registers on "Giants?" The tour they did with Opeth really made a lasting mark on the band, as if Grutle is channeling Mikael Akerfeldt. There's no sign of Grutle's trademark rasp anywhere on that song. For anyone still sitting on the fence about this one, take it from a long-time Enslaved fan: buy this album when it comes out and spin it a few times all the way through before you pass judgement on it. You won't be disappointed :)
Nephren-Ka's Avatar
Nephren-Ka | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
10? whaaaaat? Im definetely gonna listen to this new record now...I'll be back with the comment
Wanderer's Avatar
Wanderer | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Alright then, I shall give 'er an honest attempt.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Wanderer: yes. Very much so.
Wanderer's Avatar
Wanderer | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
So is this a good album to start with for modern Enslaved? Yes, i'm trying to get back into this band again.
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Played this 4 times since getting it late last night. Already pre-ordered of course...how this band manage to keep banging out such amazing albums is beyond me.
SilverInBlood's Avatar
SilverInBlood | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
A 10! Can hardly wait now....
PizzaClaus's Avatar
PizzaClaus | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Zach, your review has me super excited to get this.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
This will be in my next haul. This is must promise to myself.
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Remember when Enslaved came out with a proggy post rock album and we were all like "This is still awesome, but not all that black metal"? The new one COMPLETELY solves this gripe. This album is as heavy as almost anything they've done. I love this band. If the rating went to 11, I would give it that score.
Juho's Avatar
Juho  | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
I smell album of the year. A 10 for me, as well.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Great review Zach. This isn't quite a perfect 10 for me, but its close. Fantastic album and quite a surprising turn considering what they were doing on Vertebrae two years ago.
konradkantor's Avatar
konradkantor  | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
The greatness of this album/band is undeniable.
alexdresko's Avatar
alexdresko | posted on 9/2010
Totally agree. :)
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
There isn't a bad Enslaved album, but some are just beyond incredible, Below the Lights being one of them, if this is on that level or higher this will easily be my #1 album of the year, can't wait for it to be released.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Wow...a 10? Haven't seen that in a long time! Can't wait! Could it be better than below the lights?
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Love Enslaved...but, they'll never top "below the lights" imo.
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
Agreed El este
elpants's Avatar
elpants | posted on 9/2010 | Reply
I expect nothing less than spectacular from this release. From the 1 song and 30 second snippets of the others I have heard. I don't think I'll be disappointed.
Jishwa's Avatar
Jishwa | posted on 8/2010 | Reply
So this is really a new Enslaved album huh? *freaks out*
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 9/2010
Fantastic review, Zach. Looking forward to this!!!