Album Review

Score 8.9
Written by Dan Staige
Published on 10/16/2003
Dissonance was indeed one of the first words that came to mind when I heard this for the first time. Breathing is Irrelevant is another complex monster of immense density from Willowtip. Here’s the summary for ya: Take Yattering, Meshuggah, Harakiri, and possibly Fear Factory’s absolute heaviest moments, genetically splice and breed them in a twisted lab experiment and you berth Ion Dissonance. The result is a musical mutation that somehow seems stronger than its multitude of parents. In terms of aggression there is no contest. ID’s Breathing keeps up w/ Meshuggah’s Chaosphere and actually taunts it in spots w/ moments of ridiculous technikillity and complexity. Not completely polymetric mind you, just off-the-fucking-wall cerebral blasters of riffs that take an eternity to absorb. Yattering has a contender for the crown of jazz-fuzed downtuned madness. “Binary, pt.2” just opens the door w/ crushing power chords only to turn into a soft jazz segment that is not only hilarious, it is misleading as to the content of the rest of the song. It’s just monster downtuned riff after riff, and all are fresh and thoroughly crushing. The “off-key” grind riffing is there. The rubbing combinations of notes that move up and down like a gopher on an open prairie, challenging you to no end and just plain insulting your intelligence by the time the album is done. ID don’t make a single mistake anywhere. The riffs are not repeated, nothing is recycled. Every song is just crazy as it gets brutal metal, mathematikill and unbelievably eerie in nature. “The Bud Dwyer Effect” is the epitome of devastation. Out of all the brutal songs I have heard, and trust me, I have heard many, this is the most powerful and well-crafted I have encountered. Just absolute manic starting and stopping truckfulls of the heaviest steel in disarrayed yet organized patterns. I’ve never said “Jesus Christ” louder or more frequently than I have w/ the many listens of this song. The drumwork goes from a standard beat supporting a few seconds of off-key craziness to an all out nuclear blast of extremely tight double-kick fury. You will need many listens to recognize how brilliantly these songs are put together. At first all I could use to help me distinguish song from song was the employment of the enormous chunky grooves ID use to anchor their songs to achieve immovably heavy status. But w/ attentive aural dissection you will find an endless feast for technikill metal cravers, as well as those searching for some of the most intense & powerful vox you can find in metal today. This is a HUGE debut of an album showcasing enormous power w/ precise attention to detail as well. With a good production that enhances the listening experience, I find this album inhabiting every cd player w/in a 100 ft. radius of where I happen to be. This is a band to watch. Ion Dissonance crushed my ass and will obliterate yours as well.



powerade's Avatar
powerade | posted on 7/2007 | Reply
i agree with satanic dogslaughter 100% i can't even handle converge
Unknown Metalhead
EternalQuestion | posted on 7/2007 | Reply
This album still holds up as being a good example of uber-crazy-brutal-spazztic-crazy (kind of how Calculating Infinity is). I spin it about once a week, and try to jam to it on my guitar. Sadly, they use an unorthodox tuning that I can't figure out, but I still attempt. It kind of saddens me that they've continued to tone it down as their albums have gone on, and their newest just seems like a bunch of breakdowns. Oh well, I still have "Breathing Is Irrelevant" to jog the mental map of guitar fretboard insanity. Also, they own live.
Unknown Metalhead
steve p is a fucking pussy | posted on 1/2007 | Reply
so much blood rushes down to my penis when i get an erection that i pass out
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 1/2007 | Reply
This is not brutal death but an amazing cd although not as good as Solace. Hopefully they will be just as good with the new vocalist.
Satanic Dogslaughter's Avatar
Satanic Dogslaughter | posted on 1/2007 | Reply
Good if I'm in the mood for it. Otherwise, waaaaaaay too esoteric. I love brutal death, but this shit is literally close to unlistenable. Incredible musicianship, but...songwriting anyone? No? Umm...ok. Shares the same problem BTBAM has IMO. 5/3.5/6
Unknown Metalhead
NIck | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I bought this CD becaudse of this review not too long ago, expecting it to have some meshyggah like qualities but different enough to make it worth it. I have listened to it a couple of times and can't figure out what is so, great about it. IN fact I can't listen to a single song all the way through. It is crap!!! or am I missing something. Their next album got great reviews to but, I WILL NOT BUY IT.
Unknown Metalhead
dan | posted on 5/2005 | Reply
this is a tremendous release by a tremendous band. extremely technical and chaotic. theyre like a more death metal dillinger escape plan. solid.
Unknown Metalhead
Michael J Cocks | posted on 2/2004 | Reply
Yeah, this one is fucking nuts and I agree, great production. Could do without the samples in between and the jazzy shit at the beginning like Dillinger. They throw the whalefucking grooves in there amongst the end/dillinger/robot fret tickling, which is fairly original I should say, to excellent effect. It will fuck you up for like 2 hours after you listen to it.
Unknown Metalhead
1/2 hazzard | posted on 10/2003 | Reply
Mutex...For some reason....I feel a special kinship w/ you.....It's an unexplainible feeling....Maybe our musikill tastes...we both like Staind....
Unknown Metalhead
Ancient Gay Ass | posted on 10/2003 | Reply
I have heard grumblings about how this year has not produced very many great records. Fuck that. This band, Psychroptic, Decrepit Birth, Wormed, Verminous...STAIND! Fucking marvellous year.
Unknown Metalhead
Dmoralize | posted on 10/2003 | Reply
I agree, this disc really kicked my ass when I first heard it. Definitely one of the years best. Such well defined chaos, it's crushing as hell. Great stuff.
Unknown Metalhead
KT | posted on 10/2003 | Reply
This cd blew me away-- so fuckin intense and the production is incredible-- up their for rookie album of the year