Album Review

Score 8.5
Written by Ross Main
Published on 10/19/2009
It was pretty much a year ago that Scar Symmetry announced the replacement for the departed vocal talents of Christian Älvestam. Many people saw the need to hire two new singers as an under-whelming compensation to the loss of Älvestam's two voices, which contributed much to the signature sound of the band. But this will be a decision that pays off, especially after the release of Dark Matter Dimensions.

Vocals are indeed the focal point of Scar Symmetry's fourth album, perhaps even more so than 2008's Holographic Universe. Rallying between the rampant raised-eyebrow growls of Roberth Karlson (Facebreaker ex-Edge of Sanity) and the soulful power-prog clarity of the lesser-know Lars Palmqvist (Last Temptation), the two newbies share an almost melodic death metal Sonny and Cher vibe. Imagine “I Got You Babe,” with savage roaring and space-tech vocabulary.

“Noumenon and Phenomenon” is one of the band's most infectious songs to date, playing on the tag team vocal dynamics strongly, with a huge pre-chorus and a huger chorus that would give a chart smash hit a run for its dirty money. Whilst monster melodies have always played an important part in previous albums, Dark Matter Dimensions' biggest critical bullseye will be the poppy nature of many of the choruses. It would be hard for Simon Cowell himself not to flick a greedy grin at some parts of “The Consciousness Eaters.” But as perfect as some of the lines would be for an awful Irish boy band to mime over a ballad backing-track from hell, Scar Symmetry have unsurprisingly decided to lay them over a wall of astronomical metal, backed into a corner by down-tuned blasphemy and cardiac kick drums, until they explode in tuneful triumph. Seriously, some of these tunes are brilliant and will warrant multiple re-repeats. “Non-Human Era” is a particularly engrossing cross section of aggression, cyber-groove and car-stereo karaoke.

The riff magic of the first two albums, disappointingly, stays relatively unattainable, as much of the guitar is left to support the main cast with chord progressions or the sporadic plectrummed rev of a malfunctioning mechanism. Search thoroughly enough though and you should discover enough lower-fret creativity, from the wandering riff in “Mechanical Soul Cybernetics” to the mean rhythm chops on the title track. On occasion, the whole affair does get wearingly Fear Factory, but there is no shortage of excitement when Per Nilsson and Jonas Kjellgren break their leashes, to bust out those sweeping leads.

The band's sound is still there in full glory, and the vocal expansions for Dark Matter Dimensions hasn't actually compromised that at all. Casual followers of the band will struggle to notice any change, whilst it will almost certainly procure a mixed reaction from the denser fan base. At this point, I can only encourage those who can't deal without Älvestam behind the microphone to stubbornly feed on the new Miseration album; or just do yourself a favor and wait to see these new songs in the flesh.

If live vocal arrangements were ever becoming a problem for Scar Symmetry - and they were - fear no more. With the necessary man power on stage, these unfolding tracks of all encompassing grandeur and vocal layerdom will reign supreme, becoming nothing short of an observed phenomenon.



evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
my first impression was that it sound like Sonic Syndicate so i put it back in the shelf...
SwiftMarcos's Avatar
SwiftMarcos | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I think that this new album SUCKS!!!!!!!! The band Fu*ked up by letting go of the vocalist Christian Älvestam.These new vocalists messed up the whole album.
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
"I even think the new vocalists are better in both respects." - I concur.
MetalFusion's Avatar
MetalFusion | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
I'm glad you gave this album the high score it deserved. Holographic Universe tried to be too progressive, and the whole album became too bloated and overly melodic. This album is far more focused, has better songwriting and contains plenty of catchy choruses. And the guitar work is still top-notch. I even think the new vocalists are better in both respects.
aarghon's Avatar
aarghon | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
What is funny about Scar symmetry is that they are following the same pattern than In flames and Soilwork... They are acclaimed at their beginning, and after that some of their fanbase who liked em at the beginning piss on them... Because they are too successful and too accessible. While In flames and Soilwork actually changed their product a lot to become more appealing, it is not the case with Scar symmetry. They are basically the same, even with the vocal change... While this album is not as exciting as pitch black progress or symmetric in design, lets be logical: scar symmetry are still a musically skilled band, and they cannot fall from elite to 3rd grade band in a single album, while maintaining the original recipe. EVen if this won't get a lot of spins, id be hardly pressed to deny the quality there. Not a 10, but a 8 in my book, totally agreed with ross.
Stalker's Avatar
Stalker | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Nothing by this band deserves more than the passing grade of 50. This is like giving Insomnium's last a 10. Boo
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
"melo hard accessible death teen oriented core metal" You should copyright that before someone snaps it up!
mst's Avatar
mst | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Lars Palmqvis is awful, just hearing him making me regrets my choice and checking this band. Larson should be ashamed also, first because his growling which were so vicious and in your face on the only Edge of Sanity is was on are completely tamed. And the music is a mix of melo hard accessible death teen oriented core metal having a very bad after taste. How melodic death metal has felt into mediocrity...
borden's Avatar
borden | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
wow. listened to this a few times now. gotta say it's really unfortunate that their old singer had to leave. The clean,sweeping vocals aren't nearly as good as in the past. not a bad listen though. Just not what it could of been.
groverXIII's Avatar
groverXIII | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
It took a few listens for this to really grow on me, and it's not quite 'Holographic Universe', but this is an excellent album. The new guys do an admirable job of taking over. Awesome stuff.
elpants's Avatar
elpants | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
I kinda like, not their strongest effort for sure, I feel as if this album was rushed so they could get some new material to play live that really takes advantage of two vocalists...Now where is that US headlining tour?
Dayeth's Avatar
Dayeth | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Matt McM: I actually meant the "riff magic" of Symmetric in Design and Pitch Black Progress, I don't think they're close enough to touching how good some of the stuff on those albums is. Probably could have been clearer there. Rocco: It's funny, what I've seen of Lars singing Scar Symmetry stuff, I've actually quite liked, but if you listen to his other band Last Temptation, he sounds pretty god awful.
Rocco's Avatar
Rocco | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
This wasn't bad. They will always be a casual listen for me when I'm in the mood for some poppy metal. Almost all of their riffs bore me. And I saw a live video a little while ago and the new singer sucks balls. He was really, really bad, even on the new material.
Matt McMadden's Avatar
Matt McMadden | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
In the beginning of the fourth paragraph you say, "The riff magic of the first two albums...". I'm guessing you meant songs? Otherwise, good review.
Randy's Avatar
Randy | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
DMJ, I would be inclined to agree, but the vocals take center stage on this album. Its kind of impossible not to notice them.
rattlehe@d's Avatar
rattlehe@d | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Looking forward to the album. From some samples i've heard in myspace it sounds good. Nice vocals but the clean used to be abit better. The guitarwork sounds abit better from holographic universe
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
I think it sounds great. People are too hung up on the singing.
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 9/2009 | Reply
I've listened to this twice all the way through, and I must say, it sucks. Not digging it at all. The death vox are pretty good, but egadddzzzz the choruses are just too sugary sweet for me. And, I like some of that stuff.