Album Review

Score 6.3
Written by Jim Brandon
Published on 11/9/2009
I think there’s something to be said for consistency, both good and bad, and The Project Hate is most definitely a consistent band. You can almost guarantee that each new album will sound remarkably similar to the previous one, there will be guest appearances en masse, it will more than likely be released on a different label than the one before it, and many critics will wet themselves over it while lamenting how criminally overlooked the band is. Surprise! Nothing’s changed, and it doesn’t really have to, but at this point I’m seriously beginning to think their creative wellspring of blasphemies is in serious need of a better filtration system.

Nobody wants The Project Hate to reinvent themselves, because they’re really not doing anything wrong on The Lustrate Process per se. The production is good, the actual performances are typically fantastic in the musicianship department, but there’s something very bloated and phoned-in about the songwriting that’s difficult to ignore. The nearly thirteen-minute leadoff track “Descend Into The Eternal Pits Of Possession” is everything you should expect from this band; a combination of Jonna Enckell’s gorgeous operatic vocals and Grave’s Jorgen Sandstrom’s explosive roars, some industrial techno beats, ripping guitar tones, and fiery Anti-Christian sentiment at the core. Business as usual, and that’s the entire problem.

One of my biggest pet peeves is how Hollywood designs its movie promos in such a way that once you see the trailer for a film, you’ve basically seen the whole damn thing, including the ending and every dramatic twist and turn along the way. That’s exactly what The Lustrate Process does here once the massive opening song finally finishes. Unlike Nile who, considering their band name, pretty much have no choice but to perform a very specific style of Egyptian death metal while doing their best to expand upon and refresh it, The Project Hate have just rerecorded their last three albums, and gave away the ending to everything within the first three minutes. There are no surprise twists and turns, no new flavors, and no new colors. They simply need a facelift, because there’s still something awfully beautiful hiding underneath all these saggy old mounds of flesh. This staleness makes it nearly impossible to even go into detail about the music, because it’s literally like describing a third or fourth remake of Dawn Of The Dead where the cast and setting changes, but the actions throughout remain concretely solidified in frustrating predictability.

Now if you’re a huge fan of the band, of course I’m sure you’ll find plenty here to entertain yourself, because you already know exactly what to expect. The song structures are epic and overflowing with God-hating venom, the contrasts between Enckell’s stunning cleans and various guest death belches (Martin Van Drunen being the most notable and memorable) are sure to please, and the ferocity of the more adrenaline-driven blast sections is still a strong weapon in their arsenal of textured, grandiose death metal. The closest thing to a surprise I can hear is a guest spot by the seemingly everywhere Christian Alvestam (who sounds great, as always), but beyond his contribution, it’s cut-and-paste city around these parts.

I take no pleasure in writing these things, mostly because I have a huge amount of respect and admiration for every member of this immensely capable outfit, but they keep serving up the exact same Shepherd’s Pie without switching up the filling or spices. Sacrificing such a prolific output, it would be great to see the band retreat for a few years with absolutely no activity, recharge their batteries, and release an album truly worthy of their great talents, because at this point they’re just spinning their wheels. If you love this band, buy the album, because you’ll get what you came for. If you only like The Project Hate, you might find yourself in the same irksome boat as I am by having to write about it (this isn’t my first review of them), because you could save yourself a lot of time and a little bit of money by just breaking out their not-very-old back catalog instead. May Lord K forgive me, but I think it’s time for this act to take a well deserved nap, and awake with a fresher outlook once they’ve gotten a proper bit of rest. Nighty-nite.



SymX's Avatar
SymX | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Oh I'm sorry, we don't visit metal review to read reviews about the music, we only come here to hear about "how some dude used to play in dark funeral" look's like I need to get my facts straight!
Karl J's Avatar
Karl J | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I gotta agree with DMJ and Lee - I count this as a mostly favorable review. I've never checked these guys out, but from the sound of it, I think I would like them.
Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Who do send the flowers to? I'm not sure they deliver directly to butts, and I want to get my facts straight before I sign the card.
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I'm pretty sure I care about that, but I may not have my facts right. (Thanks. I'll be here all week.)
asmo's Avatar
asmo | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
No one on metalreview cares about getting the facts right? Really?
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Haphazard, in his defence I think he was just citing grievances he has with other reviews of TPH aswell. But to be fair, the review didn't actually make it out to be a bad album. At all.
SymX's Avatar
SymX | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Going on metalreview and complaining about the reviewer "not getting his facts straight" kind of makes you look like a tard, because no one here really cares.
Haphazard's Avatar
Haphazard | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
"Operatic vocals, for one? But for fuck's sake. We have been around for 10 years and we never used operatic vocals. It's the same shit as with the common industrial tag or the fact that I used to be a Dark Funeral member (which I never was nor ever wanted to be). That's also impressive knowledge about our music and me." I guess I'm not seeing it in the review, but where does it state that you were in Dark Funeral? But then you say "the fact that I used to be a Dark Funeral member", then deny it...? What am I missing here? If these aren't female operatic vocals, then could you cite an example of what FOV really are, rather than the incorrect labeling of them as such in this review.
lee's Avatar
lee | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Ok, so what?
novairon's Avatar
novairon | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I said it before, but there is no way that this is a bad album because it's more of the same, it's just because it's not as good. Listen to any song off In Hora Mortis, then one off Lustrate Process. Then tell me it's more of the same.
lee's Avatar
lee | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I want to watch Lord K and Trez slap fight, that would be fun. I enjoyed the review, but have to agree that if the only thing you can find wrong is it sounds the same, then kind of a harsh score, although in my mind anything above a 6 is prob a good album. I might give it a shot, haven't heard anything with good fem vocals in a long time.
manicaeon's Avatar
manicaeon | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I just don't understand how Amon Amarth's Twilight of the Thunder God pulls a 10 and an 8.6, and this gets a 6.3 with most of the points being taken away for using the same formula. Lets show some consistency guys.
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Is it me, or do the scores on this one not match the review? If the musicianship on this alum is "typically fantastic", then what's with the 4/6? I think this albums more like 5/3.5/5. The songwriting only gets a 3.5 because they stuck to the same formula for too long.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Let me get this straight, Lord: you're going off about the reviewer "getting his fucken facts straight," but the only 'factual error' of any kind you can point to in the review is the description of the female vox as operatic? Descriptive qualifiers that you don't agree with aren't the same thing as factual errors, guy.
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Even as a big fan of HDCE and Armageddon March Eternal, it was a struggle for me to make it to the conclusion of any of these songs without hitting the skip button. Enckell sounds fantastic per usual, and the Martin Van Drunen guest spot was a grin-cracker; but other than that, this album is a chore to listen to. I agree with the review wholeheartedly.
manicaeon's Avatar
manicaeon | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I highly recommend that everyone gives this album a listen through. It is every bit as good as every other The Project Hate album, it takes everything they did right in those albums and meshes them together. Definitely some their most creative riffs ever. And I need to call bullshit on this album sounding the same as the rest of their albums, yeah, it's death metal, but it is definitely the biggest departure from their formula since Hate, Dominate, Congregate, Eliminate. Give it a listen, I'm guessing most of you won't have the same opinion of it as this reviewer.
The Lord's Avatar
The Lord | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Lemme just say that we will sound the same on the next album as well, haha... That's what we do. That is our concept. You won't see us free-jazzing our way thru the next recording, we won't suddenly start to play full-on nu-metal becoz someone think we need to re-invent ourselves. Not going to happen. It's really simple; if you do not like what we do on "TLP" you do not like TPH and you never will. And I am fine with that, as stated a million times before. But what pisses me off is when people actually can't get their fucken facts straight in the reviews they make... Operatic vocals, for one? But for fuck's sake. We have been around for 10 years and we never used operatic vocals. It's the same shit as with the common industrial tag or the fact that I used to be a Dark Funeral member (which I never was nor ever wanted to be). That's also impressive knowledge about our music and me. Think what the fuck you will about our music but please try to get your facts correct anyways. That is not asking too much. Unlike the superheroes at the Nile forum I don't think this guy is a fag and a idiot for not adoring what we do. I don't think his eventual bands (that I never heard) fucken suck becoz he doesn't like what we do. I simply don't fucken care about that bullshit - the guy doesn't find the album fantastic, tough shit for us, but I love the damn thing with all of my heart and find insane pride in listening to it. It's my life's work so far. And I have done it with the best guys around. That is really all that matters to me in the end. And I have my facts straight, always. Thanx for the review nonetheless.
ManicAeon's Avatar
ManicAeon | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
The Project Hate to me is like Amon Amarth, they're incredible consistent and they don't stray far from what they know works, and like Amon Amarth, that's perfectly fine. I loved this album just like everyone before it.
novairon's Avatar
novairon | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I fucking loved In Hora Mortis Nostræ, but this isn't nearly as good, so I mostly agree with the score, but I don't think it's because they need to change it up, it's just not as well written.