Album Review

Score 8.3
Written by Michael Roberts
Published on 5/29/2009
It’s only been a year since Warbringer were earning accolades for War Without End and already these young thrashlings have knocked out the follow-up. With their debut, the band were lauded for being one of, if not the best of the current crop of Bay Area-worshipping acts bringing old school thrash kicking and screaming into the noughties. Waking Into Nightmares announces itself in a big way even before you’ve hit play. That killer Dan Seagrave cover art promises a distinct improvement - visually at least - over War Without End, and thankfully the music inside delivers on that promise. Bolstered by a crystal clear yet brutal sound courtesy of none other than Mr. Gary Holt, Waking Into Nightmares sees Warbringer improving on their already fearsome Slayer-versus-Exodus styling with a pleasing attention to detail and songwriting growth. I really can’t see this going down as anything other than an absolute storm with genre fans.

For all their obvious thrashiness, the thing that gives Warbringer that extra edge and kick is the presence of early death metal in their sound. The blastbeating on “Living In a Whirlwind” might be the most obvious nod to classic DM yet more subtle examples can be found throughout Waking Into Nightmares. John Kevill’s deep, Obituary-like vocals are nicely pulled off again, though it’s a shame they only appear on the one track, the lurching “Shadow from the Tomb”. Pick of the bunch would have to be “Scorched Earth” though, featuring as it does ferocious speed and energy, spot-on soloing, mosh-worthy grooves and a catchy refrain - easily one of Warbringer’s most accomplished songs to date. In fact the band have done their best to make every number here varied and interesting within the confines of eighties thrash, and are evidently aware of the need to break things up in order to prevent monotony from setting in. Cue the smart, elegant instrumental “Nightmare Anatomy” which brings a welcome change of mood while still peaking with a relatively heavy mid-section.

It would be far too easy to point out the derivative nature of bands like Warbringer as a thing to criticize, and the fact is Waking Into Nightmares satisfies all the criteria for a top metal album regardless of where its ideas originate from. In terms of production, performances, songwriting and presentation this is a significant step up from previous material. If Warbringer continue making music this fast, heavy and fun, then they can rip off their heroes as much as they please. And let’s face it; how many of the surviving thrash greats could still deliver an album as good as this?



Unknown Metalhead
m/usclehead | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Awesome thrash, probably the best thrash band around right now. The vocals are awesome.
Beak's Avatar
Beak | posted on 9/2009 | Reply
They put on a good live show.
Demented D's Avatar
Demented D | posted on 9/2009 | Reply
I really enjoyed their debut, and this one is even better. They have really matured as a band. If they've improved this much over an album, I can't wait to see what they bring to the table in the years to come. 7/10
gap's Avatar
gap | posted on 7/2009 | Reply
Great stuff. Slayer meets Exodus is apt.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
Slayer S O N G S
mr.exclusive's Avatar
mr.exclusive | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
This ablum rips!!!! Scorched earth is my fav track
crucifiedjesus's Avatar
crucifiedjesus | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
love this album one of my favorite releases so far this year
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
Slightly better than their debut, but that's not saying much. Sacrifice will show these retro thrashers how it's really done when they release their new album.
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
Good review, I'll be checking this one out.
Io's Avatar
Io | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
I'm honestly not even all that into thrash (Dark Angel notwithstanding), and I also agree that Warbringer are one of the best of the neo-thrashers, if not the best.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
Not big on these revival projects, but Warbringer's probably the best of the lot.
Matt McMadden's Avatar
Matt McMadden | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
I'm really enjoying this, but then again, I'm a huge thrash fan.
stncttr908's Avatar
stncttr908 | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
Amazing album. Took everything that kept War Without End from becoming a mainstay in my rotation and obliterated it. Beats out Kreator's latest effort as thrash album of the year so far for me.
deltawing's Avatar
deltawing | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
I didn't like the production on this one at all, I thought War Without End had the ideal new thrash production, therefore this album didn't click with me as much as it should've.
americannibal's Avatar
americannibal | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
I was a fan of War Without End, but I don't care for this album. Living In A Whirlwind slams, but the rest of the album is too predictible and premeditated, too mature. Honestly, it sounds tired, like 'old guy' thrash and I'm an old guy, so I can say that.
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 5/2009 | Reply
There`s an awful lot of dross in this new thrash revival but Warbringer are definately standing out as one of the good ones. This is a great album.