Album Review

Score 9.2
Written by Chris McDonald
Published on 2/23/2009
Blut Aus Nord has taken the underground metal scene by veritable storm since the world heard The Work Which Transforms God in 2003, with each subsequent release garnering fevered anticipation and widely divided opinions from the outfit’s ever-increasing legion of appreciators. After the experiments in dissonant, industrial-themed ambience shown on The Work... and the even stranger MoRT, Blut Aus Nord attempted a “return to form” to marginally more traditional black metal with Odinist: The Destruction of Reason By Illumination last year. Some (including myself) welcomed the return to a more recognizable black metal style, while others were disappointed by the record’s short length and decreased emphasis on experimentation. Memoria Vetusta II: Dialogue With the Stars sees the outfit continue to draw from their past for inspiration…but not necessarily in the ways you might expect.

Blut Aus Nord has certainly come a long way since the first Memoria Vetusta album, Fathers of the Icy Age. That was back in 1996, and the outfit was just beginning to explore territories slightly beyond the largely standard, though still outstanding, epic black metal sound that served as their foundation. Now things have come full circle; in some ways, this album feels like a natural (if far more articulate) sequel to Fathers…, but this is still undoubtedly the sound of modern-day Blut Aus Nord, complete with the requisite programmed drums, glossy production, and Vindsval’s inimitable guitar-tone. Most of the songs even have two titles, seemingly referencing the two distinct period of the band’s history that have been united on this recording. But while Dialogue With The Stars borrows from all eras of the project’s discography, the end-result is a fresh step forward for the band, and opens up new dimensions to Blut Aus Nord’s sound that I never even thought were possible.

Let me start by saying that this album is nothing less than a feast of excellent riffs. Vindsval has unquestionably re-established himself as one of extreme metal’s most gifted sonic architects; the guitars churn forth intricate, heavily layered riffs and mesmerizing passages at an almost constant rate, and even the short interlude tracks glow with carefully constructed compositional touches. The shimmering, otherworldly guitar sound of the band’s last few albums is still utilized to great effect, as are the complex and ever changing programmed drum patterns. But the atmosphere of Dialogue With The Stars is far removed from the misanthropic lunacy conjured so chillingly on albums like MoRT. In fact, when you hear moments like the glorious opening riffs of “…the Meditant (Dialogue With The Stars)” or the ethereal aura of “The Formless Sphere (Beyond the Reason)”, its hard to believe this is the same band that wrote some of the coldest and most inaccessible black metal ever heard a mere few years back.

Most notably, Blut Aus Nord has never been this unrepentantly melodic. Despite the rather mechanical tone to the production, the material on Dialogue With The Stars is not only magnificent in scope, but genuinely moving thanks to the emotional fortitude of the riffs themselves. Songs like the aforementioned title track, “Antithesis of the Flesh” and the serpentine closer “Elevation” are structured around beautiful, uplifting melodic arrangements that really make you feel like you are soaring through the heavens. Even when a somewhat malevolent riff surfaces, such as in “Disciple’s Libration” or “The Cosmic Echoes of Non-Matter,” it sounds more mysterious and otherworldly than threatening. Numerous segments have an almost Middle-Eastern sound due to the eerie, spiraling lead guitar, and the ghostly keyboards add an epic grandeur to the riffs that contributes wonderfully to the breathtaking ambience of the record. While Dialogue... is lengthier than any prior Blut Aus Nord release, the genius of this album is just how easily you can find yourself completely lost in these songs, and how quickly you’ll want to return when the last track is over. This may be the most “listener-friendly” work the band has released thus far, but don’t mistake this for lack of depth. If anything, the enthralling nature of the melodies is merely the hook that pulls you in and entices you to truly explore the breadth of what has been created on this recording. 

The only element of Dialogue With The Stars that can perhaps be construed as lacking is the vocals. Vindsval’s mid-ranged growls are almost completely buried in the mix and are so inconsequential to the songs overall that you might as well call this an instrumental album. The disturbing vocalizations were a big part in crafting the mood of albums like TWWTG, but honestly, the musical side of things here is so incredibly gratifying that I doubt anyone will really notice the subdued vocals that much. Nevertheless, this is perhaps the only aspect of this album that could have been improved. The mix is also fairly dry and quite devoid of heaviness, but in the end it only serves the highlight the hypnotizing power of the amazing guitar and keyboard sounds.

Once again, Blut Aus Nord have stepped boldly forward, changed the perceptions on what black metal can be, and released an amazing record in the process. Aside from being a crowing summation to all of the band’s previous outings, Memoria Vetusta II: Dialogue With The Stars is a riff-lover’s dream, an amazing display of musicianship and compositional aptitude, and above all, an incredibly rewarding and memorable listening experience. After hearing a work of this caliber, it is perhaps more difficult than ever to imagine where Blut Aus Nord could possibly go from here. But I for one can’t wait to find out.



Unknown Metalhead
Metal = Awesome | posted on 12/2010 | Reply
I heard of this album through a friend and immediately checked this site to read a review on it. Bought it. Listened. Blown away. This is the stuff that keeps putting the bar higher and higher. Everyone needs to listen to this.
DeathHead's Avatar
DeathHead | posted on 5/2010 | Reply
Wow. Phenomenal album! The review is spot on - there are great riffs and addictive melodies everywhere on this one. When it's over I can't wait to play it again from start to finish. I understand why this was voted the MR #1 album of 2009.
TheSlayerM's Avatar
TheSlayerM  | posted on 4/2009 | Reply
Amazing album. Exactly what Rev said.
stoned to death's Avatar
stoned to death | posted on 4/2009 | Reply
Albums like this make me wish I got into Black Metal sooner. I am blown away by this.
Loxodont's Avatar
Loxodont | posted on 3/2009 | Reply
Brilliance...puts most everything to shame.
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 3/2009 | Reply
This album is absolutely beautiful - a gorgeous guitar record, through and through. One of the few albums in recent memory that actually breaks my heart when it ends...when "Elevation" concludes, I find myself double-checking my iPod, as if to force more tracks out by sheer will.
mst's Avatar
mst | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
I have always confused this band's name with the name Axel Rudi Pell, so each time I saw their name, I said brrk in a disgust tone. With the score, the description and artwork of this album, I decide to dive into this music. And a very good epic music I found. Some songs really remind me of the mind setup that should have been required to do Opeth's Morningrise, minus the dual guitars and with a blackish metal tone. Very good, full of solos, complexity without pretense, in summary, excellent!
xray14's Avatar
xray14  | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
Even after reading Chris' excellent review I am surprised at just how enjoyable this album is. Outfuckingstanding.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
I like this, need to give it a few more listens. I'll always be an Ultima Thulee man though as far as BAN is concerned.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
This is the first Blut album I've been into since TWWTG. Definitely a return to form.
mighty battlepenis's Avatar
mighty battlepenis | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
Chud, I would imagine you get poorly produced Emperor from this release because you suffer from Asperger's Syndrome. Kindly step out of the gene pool.
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
BaN is one of the handful of black metal bands that I really dig. I need to pick this one up. Good review, Goblin.
Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
When people speak of "progression", this is one of the first bands that comes to mind. This album is sensational, it feels to me like the musical equivalent of TWWTG in morning light. Truly enthralling stuff. Chris freakin' nailed it, it's probably the most listenable album Blut Aus Nord has done. The bar is raised MIGHTY high for black metal so early in the year between this and the new Absu.
lee's Avatar
lee | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
First of all nice review, I enjoyed reading it. I love the Work but for some reason never cared to expand beyond that one album with this band, a lot times I think BM bands make one good album and that is all that is needed from them. It is a restrictive genre and unless you change so much you lose what you are, there is not a lot of reason behind multiple albums.
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
Nope- doesn't do it for me. Doesn't surprise me since I hated the last one. I hate the guitar and vocal sound. Drums and synth are well produced. I don't know why I prefer Nachtmystium so much over this, but something about this just sounds like poorly produced Emperor.
grymmbear's Avatar
grymmbear | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
Cannot wait for this album!