Album Review

Score 8
Written by Erik Thomas
Published on 11/19/2008
I have to admit somthing...

I have never owned or even heard a Meshuggah album.

There. I said it.

So what better place to start than the 1991 debut (coupled with the 1994 EP None)?

So Nuclear Blast continues with their re-loaded versions of albums that are readily available (this album was already re-issued with the None EP in 1999), but for people new to some of these bands, they serve as nice introductions and for me a first listening of a much hyped band.

Admittedly in 1991 I was neck deep in Swedish death metal, so for whatever reason Meshuggah’s name and artwork never appealed to me, and now hearing them 17 years later, chances are it would not have appealed to me back in my relative metal youth, but now as a much more open minded, wiser metal head, I’m surprised and impressed at the sounds contained on Contradictions Collapse.

Ultimately, Contradictions Collapse is in fact, a technical thrash album-one that has a sort of Master of Puppets era Metallica meets Testament with a dash of Watchtower (and I hear some Exhorder cadences in here too, though that might just be me) feel that shows roots of the band's groovier, heftier sound, but certainly shows the band’s rougher, less polished but still technically stunning ability and compositions.

While certainly not as mind melding and progressive as the band's recent albums, Contradictions Collapse has a rough, primal back bone to its angular, choppy, progressive thrash with a complexity that’s hard to fathom if you are expecting simple balls out thrash. Tracks like opener “Paralyzing Ignorance,” very Metallica-ish “Erroneous Manipulation,” “Abnegating Cecity,” “Qualms of Reality,” Arabic infused “We’ll Never See the Day,” “Cadaverous Mastication” and such aren’t quite as cerebral as their titles would suggest. They are certainly superbly crafted, intellectual and experimental takes on thrash metal however, with Peter Nordin’s bass and Tomas Haake’s drums taking center stage with a choppy, unpredictable rhythm section. That being said, it lacks that classic, instant feel of the thrash of the day, but that could also be taken as a complement and that Meshuggah were ahead of their time.

On the four tracks that comprise the None EP, we see that the band’s starting to take shape as Mårten Hagström joins the already deft Fredrik Thordendal on guitar, allowing Jens Kidman to focus on just vocals (and sound less like James Hetfield/Chuck Billy-ish), and the sound of the four tracks appears to expand and grow in polish, complexity, groove and depth. “Humilitative” distinguishes the slight shift right away with some industrial throbbing, more polished vocals and huge mechanical riffage, then “Sickening” (a track that I was familiar with for some reason) heaves, twists and lurches with what appears to be the backbone of Meshuggah’s current signature sound. “Ritual” is surprisingly restrained and mellow before “Gods of Rapture” ends the release with a typically spacial warbling and thunderous polyrhythms.

Contradictions Collapse isn’t a real classic by any means, but it's probably an album you should at least own, even if you never listen to it, as it signals the early sound of one of metal’s most respected and revered acts. Now-what else should I get by these guys?



Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Nope, Tomas played drums on this album. He joined the band after their debut EP/demo.
Dandamaged's Avatar
Dandamaged | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Tomas Haarke didn't join until the Destroy erase improve album. I forget this guys name but he was awesome.
funeralthirst7's Avatar
funeralthirst7 | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
great album. the band was way ahead of their time when this came out. thankfully they were around to see that they were on to something.
Iron Maiden's Avatar
Iron Maiden | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I could never get into them either but i will try this one and see what happens.
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
For whatever reason I just don`t get Meshuggah at all. Find them really boring both live and on CD. Never heard this but from the review it sounds different to the later stuff I`m familiar with. Back in `91-`94 it was all thrash and death metal for me too...although there wasn`t much to thrash about to in those days!
steve p's Avatar
steve p | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Kidman has crazy ass lyrics because not only is Tomas Haake one of the best drummers ever but also one of the best lyricists. I really don't think its possible to go wrong with Meshuggah but Destroy Erase Improve or obZen should be next as DEI is a classic and obZen sounds like a mix between everything they have done from DEI to Catch 33.
I_KILL_YOU_LOL's Avatar
I_KILL_YOU_LOL | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Nigga, 3 words. Destroy.Erase.Improve.
Sunnportal's Avatar
Sunnportal | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Some of their best material i think.
Xero337's Avatar
Xero337 | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
catchy shit, best band to ever bless our existence not to mention if ya ever seen interviews with jens kidman, hes probably the most laid back metalhead ever with friggin crazy ass lyrics and shit.....not an epic release by meshuggah but a truly memorable one \m/
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I got this way back in the day after I got dei I think. Loved this band ever since I first heard them and theyre still my favorite metal band ever. Ever. I would recommend anything in their catalog.
RationalGaze's Avatar
RationalGaze | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
"Contradictions Collapse isn’t a real classic by any means, but it's probably an album you should at least own, even if you never listen to it, as it signals the early sound of one of metal’s most respected and revered acts. Now-what else should I get by these guys?" You're right on the money, great review! As far as suggestions go, I'd say listen to Destroy Erase Improve next, now there's a metal classic even if you're not a fanboy, same can be said of Chaosphere imo, they truly are one the most consistent bands in metal
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I consider myself a pretty big Meshuggah fan, but I don't care for CC all that much. It hasn't aged all that well, especially compared to DEI (an album that still sounds years ahead of everything else) but also compared to other tech thrash stuff from around the same time, I thinking Victims of Deception, Mental Vortex, Swallowed in Black type stuff. CC isn't bad, but I think it's damn near amazing what the band became, given these humble beginnings.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Great review Eric. I fucking love this album. Truly groundbreaking, and catchy as hell.
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
The "none ep" should get straight 6's. That ep is friggin' awesome. It's no secret, I "got" Meshuggah the minute I pushed play lo those many years ago...I love 'em today more than then. Meshuggah rules.
ethr's Avatar
ethr | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
"I have never owned or even heard a Meshuggah album." Wow that is a stunning statement! Never would have guessed that from the mighty ET! My personal fav is the I EP I played that thing over and over when it came out.
munson's Avatar
munson | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
For me, Meshuggah is a 'you-get-it-or-you-don't' sort of band. I just happen to get it, and love it. Out each of Meshuggah's efforts, though, I have to say this is one of my least favorites. Still a pretty good listen.
gothslayer's Avatar
gothslayer | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Never been a Mushuggah...dont know why. I am a big metal fan, but this band has never connected with me. I hate to say this...but this band seems like random noise to me. I would rather listen to something similar in technicality, like Control Denied, then these guys.
Las7's Avatar
Las7 | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
This is on my list; good production is a must