Album Review

Score 8
Written by Michael Roberts
Published on 10/31/2008
Beneath The Massacre’s first album Mechanics of Dysfunction was a technical marvel but a frustratingly sterile affair song-wise. I loved and hated it in equal measure. So now the follow-up Dystopia has landed and the good news is everything’s gone up a notch. The production is better, the vocals have improved and best of all the songs are definitely stronger. While I do feel this criminally talented band still sacrifices truly memorable songwriting on the altar of technicality, there’s no doubt Dystopia is Beneath The Massacre’s best release so far, and fanboys should be salivating at the prospect of hearing this.

The differences on Dystopia from previous efforts are subtle but noteworthy. The production is warmer and slightly more brutal. The growling of Elliot Desgagnes is a bit more ferocious this time around, and thankfully the guy sounds like he’s choking on a little less cotton wool than before. Otherwise it’s the same double-kicked, sweep-picked mayhem that has characterized BTM since day one. It’s just that on this album the compositions they form are not only more intense and brutal, but thankfully more interesting as well. And is that a touch of melody I hear on “The Wasteland” and “Never More”? Yes it is, and Dystopia is all the better for it.

Spin any one of the album's eleven tracks and you’re guaranteed to get your teeth kicked in. Some stick better than others though, such as opener “Condemned” with its brutal stop-start groove. “No Future” and the aforementioned “The Wasteland” are boosted by the inclusion of short sharp solos, while closing number “Procreating the Infection” stands out as one of Beneath The Massacre’s most well-crafted songs to date. The technicality is no less extreme but it’s balanced out by other elements, particularly the vocals which are at their most desperate and fierce here. Hopefully, it’s a sign of where BTM are headed with their songwriting.

Dystopia is a strong offering of brutal, technical death that sees Beneath The Massacre refining their sound and improving in all major areas. Although the band remains a little too cold and calculating for my tastes, I still have to give credit where it’s due – these guys have stepped up their game. While I wouldn’t count it among this year’s best death metal offerings, Dystopia is easily one of the heaviest.



chainsawd's Avatar
chainsawd | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
One of those bands I know I wouldn't like on paper, but interesting enough to keep up with in small doses for sure.
krustster's Avatar
krustster | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Good review! I had my doubts when the first minute or so of the first song was just "woodlywoodely" guitar nonsense but they have some really excellent grooving parts in there. A big improvement for sure. And it it just me or does the vocalist sound exactly like the guy from Through the Eyes of the Dead's latest?
Kenny's Avatar
Kenny | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I love Mechanics of Dysfunction, i love the sterility, i love the technicality, i love the machine like song writing - if memorable song writing means injecting melody then song writing can get fucked, i love the fact that these guys push mechanical technicality to the limits and if others find this annoying/boring/soulless then i guess this isn't the band for you, personally i hope that Beneath the Massacre continue to stretch the limits of technicality without regard for what the majority of metal heads consider 'good songwriting'
Matt's Avatar
Matt  | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I can only enjoy this in small doses before getting bored.
ABC44's Avatar
ABC44 | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I do enjoy this album more than their former albums. I have not given it much of a chance since I first listened to it fully, but I want to try to do that again. This is good stuff.
number9's Avatar
number9 | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
The musicianship in undeniable. but if you aren't writting good songs its just a waste. These guys have to work on that.
Io's Avatar
Io | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Good album, though some of the breakdowns are a bit pedestrian and typical. Still one of my favorite tech bands.
rat's Avatar
rat | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
the last album had a few really cool songs and a few monotonous ones. I'll check this fo sho...
Lacertine_Forest's Avatar
Lacertine_Forest | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
dougwhatyoudidisrape: Good record, better than Mechanics, but I think their first EP is still their best material. --- Couldn't have said it better myself.
Beak's Avatar
Beak | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
I'll check this out; the review has me interested.
Yersinia Pestyler's Avatar
Yersinia Pestyler | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
i'm in agreement here. tech for tech's sake has sort of played itself out IMO. BTM are still guilty of this BUT this album is just way more memorable.
stncttr908's Avatar
stncttr908 | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Best enjoyed in small doses!
dougwhatyoudidisrape's Avatar
dougwhatyoudidisrape | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Good record, better than Mechanics, but I think their first EP is still their best material.
Madrigal's Avatar
Madrigal | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Me like.
Haphazard's Avatar
Haphazard | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Words cannot explain where this band's music takes me to while listening. Pure & rare musical masters.
Klopek's Avatar
Klopek | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Sounds good, I've been juggling the decision whether to buy this. I think this review, especially with the "best material yet" comments is pushing me towards the "buy" option.
elpants's Avatar
elpants | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
mmmmmm, yes. Very good album. Worth picking up.