Album Review

Score 10
Written by Chris McDonald
Published on 9/23/2008
One of many classic Nuclear Blast releases to receive the “Reloaded” treatment, Meshuggah’s landmark sophomore effort is easily the best and most historically important of the bunch. More direct and focused than its predecessor Contradictions Collapse and more dynamic than the outfit’s subsequent forays into odd-time groove, Destroy Erase Improve sees the Swedes at what many (including myself) consider their creative zenith. It was during this period in the mid-90’s that the band began to truly define their now signature sound, and in the process changed the face of metal music across both the mainstream and underground scenes. Whatever you happen to think of Meshuggah, only a fool would deny the massive impact this band has had on the direction heavy metal has taken in the last decade or so, and if you listen to just about any modern metal outfit, from Dream Theatre to the most brutal death metal acts, chances are they’ve taken some sort of influence from this band and this record.

To say that this material is iconic would be an understatement; over the years, classic Destroy tracks like “Future Breed Machine”, “Soul Burn”, and “Suffer In Truth” have been embraced by many fans as definitive Meshuggah songs, and there isn’t a track among these ten that is anything less than fucking excellent. Say what you will about the way these guys write riffs, but everything about this album is simply superbly done; the perfect production highlighting each and every instrumental texture, the incredible musicianship, and the endless supply of hooks and memorable moments amidst the outfit’s stuttering mathematical assault. While not as mechanical and uncompromising as future efforts by the band, Destroy Erase Improve was one of the most original and intense records of its time when it was released, and its quality and influence still stands up today.

The album kicks off with what could easily be called the band’s signature song, the classic “Future Breed Machine.” With its mathy thrash opening, devastating bridge groove, and classic Fredrik Thordendal guitar solo, this track exemplifies everything that made old Meshuggah so fresh and exciting. I still get a thrill listening to this song and I’ve been listening to it for years. Things never dip in quality from this tremendous start either, with the catchy melodies of “Beneath,” the memorable stomp of “Soul Burn” (containing one of Thordendal’s craziest leads ever) and the complex gallop of “Transfixion” being just a few noteworthy moments. The brief moments of relief in emotional instrumental “Acrid Placidity” and the soothing industrial opening of “Terminal Illusion” are hugely effective at pacing the album; add the wide variety of different tempos and the band’s unique apocalyptic atmosphere, and you have what is without a doubt Meshuggah’s most cohesive and diverse work to date. There’s no filler here at all, just excellent material from start to finish.

As for the “Reloaded” part, Nuclear Blast has given us bonus tracks from the Self-Caged EP as well as the long-lost track “Aztec Two-Step”, initially released on the outstanding None EP but strangely left off when that EP was reissued with Contradictions Collapse. If you have yet to hear this song then you’re in for a treat, as it's a brutal track showing Meshuggah experimenting with a very unusual and industrial sound. Not really something you’d listen to all the time, but very interesting and intense. As for the Self-Caged EP, it’s hardly a necessity, as it merely contains demo tracks of four Destroy Erase Improve songs and a live version of the awesome “Gods of Rapture” (from the aforementioned None EP). I suppose hardcore fans will appreciate these tracks as the original EP is long out of print, but they certainly aren’t worth the splurge if you already own the other material on here.

So, we basically have a very nice reissue of one of the most influential metal albums of the 90’s, with some solid bonus material on the side. What more do you need than that? This reissue is obviously a great place to start if you’ve been looking to get into this band, and while there’s seemingly no consensus among fans as to what is Meshuggah’s greatest effort (Chaosphere and Catch 33 are also great albums), Destroy Erase Improve shows this hugely important outfit at arguably their most influential and inspired phase.



Inaphyt's Avatar
Inaphyt | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I've always hated messhuggah, boring and monotonous throughout, except the start of future breed. This shouldn't of been released again.
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
is the new textures gonna get reviewed soon? i've been enjoying that one a lot lately.
greigoroth's Avatar
greigoroth | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I have Chaosphere Reloaded in the CD player right now! It contains most of the tracks from True Human Design (although not the video). It was released in Europe a little while ago and will be released in the States on Tuesday.
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
so is chaosphere reloaded happening too? Does anyone know what extras that'll have?
ARRIVER's Avatar
ARRIVER | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
DEI kicks ass, no doubt. I would say, however, that Kidman's vocals improved with subsequent albums, so for me it ain't their best.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
No, you really don't need the bonus tracks in the long run.
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
plus he follows christ. first sign of idiocy right there. can somebody tell me if i really need these bonus tracks or not?
Bystander's Avatar
Bystander | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I completely agree with Chris McDonald? You win, universe. Nice review, mate.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
FollowChrist is clearly a gimmick. In any case, monumental album.
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
.. and this is why FollowChrist's opinion doesn't matter... at all.
Iron Maiden's Avatar
Iron Maiden | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Alright, I'm going to give Meshuggah one more try.
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
are the bonus tracks really worth buying this for tho?
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
ha ha korn? Really? that's weird that meshuggah ripped off their sound when the band formed a good 5 years before korn existed. very strange indeed. please shut the fuck up. anyway clearly a classic album 666 is righteously deserved
Power_of_Sire's Avatar
Power_of_Sire | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Followchrist Meshuggah has been around long before Korn and you have obviously never heard them if you think they sound alike. Good review this album is a classic.
Las7's Avatar
Las7 | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I'm torn if I like this or Catch 33 the most. Simply put monolith record, while also being the most excessive out of Meshuggah's discography.
funeralthirst7's Avatar
funeralthirst7 | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
has followchrist even listened to meshuggah ? ive been a fan of theirs for 10 years now and can not for the life of me recall anything they did that sounded like korn. and then to say they ripped off korn ? there are a lot of bands that did that and meshuggah is certainly not one of them.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Haha! FC is the funniest guy on here. Doesn't know a single thing about any kind of heavy metal, but he's on here slagging everything. Keep listening to Korn, little rock and roll ranger, sooner or later you'll graduate to the real thing. I don't know, I still prefer the batshit lunacy of Catch Thirtythree. Turned up loud enough, it could demolish buildings, it has such a dementedly heavy sound.
FollowChrist's Avatar
FollowChrist | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I'm not sure what the facination is with this band .they ripped off Korn's sound. And sound too much like them.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Yeah I always assumed that was the reason, but why not just put those tracks on a second disc as opposed to leaving the EP blatantly unfinished? I hate it when labels do that.
Mike's Avatar
Mike | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
If I remember correctly the running time for the Contradictions Collapse/None release was just shy of 80 minutes so I always assumed that they would have run out of space on the CD and had to cut something out and Aztec Two-Step was deemed to be the least worthy track for inclusion for whatever reason.
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
My roomate and I always argued over which was better..."chaosphere" or "dei"...I love them both, but prefer chaosphere. He loves this album and say it's the best. And me telling that story means fucking nothing...haha. Regardless..classic album.
dont panic's Avatar
dont panic | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
legandary album. really good review.
Bradination's Avatar
Bradination | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Totally disagree on this being their best but it's impact is unquestionable.
steve p's Avatar
steve p | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Man the influence this album and band has on my music listening cannot be put into words. This may not be my favorite Meshuggah album but it definitely gets the most plays because the songwriting is as catchy as hell and very accessible considering the technicality on display here. Great review Chris.
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
666? Meshuggah is overrated in general.
gordeth's Avatar
gordeth | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Great review. This has always been my favorite of theirs. "Aztec Two-Step" was actually the first Meshuggah song I ever heard when it was on a comp back in '93 and is the reason I got into them.
DeepsendRecords's Avatar
DeepsendRecords | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I was never a big fan of this album. Future Breed Machine is a great song, but I prefer the groove of Chaosphere. To me I can run through that album any day of the week, but I rarely go back to this one.
greigoroth's Avatar
greigoroth | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Nice review Chris. Just saw Meshuggah last night and they were awesome. I think this CD sounds just as relevant today as when it was released. The opening dissonance of Future Breed Machine still gets me bangning every time!
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Good review, sir. This is a killer record.
Sunnportal's Avatar
Sunnportal | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I enjoyed the review, but i think the perfect score of 6/6/6 is a bit high. The mechanical riffs and time changes just sound a little lifeless and dated these days. Although saying that i bought DEI about 6 years ago and haven't listened to it in a long time. I think i'll give it a spin tomorrow after reading this review though.
tiagon's Avatar
tiagon | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
is there any other Meshuggah album beside this one??? NOT EVER I know, I know. just had to say it ;) great review. perfect album.