Album Review

Score 7
Written by Thomas Creager
Published on 8/29/2008
A Storm of Light is a post-metal/doom outfit, a genre I am innovatively labeling “post-doom”. I know, I’ve blazed a few trails in my day. Anyway, as you could probably guess, such a label can only indicate one thing: they have a major hard-on for atmosphere. The entire hour long experience is a crushing voyage into the dark, impenetrable depths of literary ambience. The guitars are a massive tide, constantly crashing against the listener’s ear. The vocalist’s throaty, bellowed voice echoes throughout like a foghorn, the only semblance of humanity in an environment entirely hostile to light or life. When listening to A Storm of Light the metaphors and imagery pops into one’s head effortlessly.

The middle of the album encapsulates the band’s formula at its finest. The varied complexity of “Mass” is engrossing, the riffs and chants of “Leaden Tide” are haunting, the lyrics of “Black Ocean” are absolutely infectious (try not to join in when “We will kill / for blood and money” is despondently sung your way), and the atmospherics on “Thunderhead” are eerie and powerful. Where And We Wept the Black Ocean Within stumbles, however, is the last three tracks. For fifteen minutes, the enveloping atmosphere A Storm of Light spent so much time creating loses steam until it comes to a complete stop. The closing song, “Iron Heart”, is dull compared to earlier moments. Rather disappointing.

The album also doesn’t have much staying power. Once the freshness and novelty of an hour’s worth of nautical dirges wore off, I would get halfway through the album and start itching to put something with a bit more substance, a bit more memorable, on.

All things considered, though, And We Wept the Black Ocean Within is enough to satisfy a temporary doom craving. It’s a fun ride, but ends sooner than you like, leaving you wandering in search of something new rather quickly.



FATAL_88's Avatar
FATAL_88 | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
Josh Graham is not a member of Neurosis, hes sort of an honoury member, he just does their artwork and their visuals. The tracks that I listenned to were pretty good.. sort of Ahab meets Neurosis kind of thing, some moments reminds me of Battle of Mice too. The vocals however are weak here since this is the first time that Josh does vocals on a record, but by all means its not that band and the athmosphere is haunting !! I think we can expect better things in the future.. I'm picking this one up..
The Great Cretaceous Bob's Avatar
The Great Cretaceous Bob | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
@ trezevant My thoughts exactly. Kind of like Warrel Dane's solo stuff. Except Dane is actually part of the band he's side-projecting from.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
uh, no, mst, it isn't. a side project is when you start another band to do something different from what you do in your main band, not where you start another band to do the exact same thing as your main band, but worse. I don't see Karl Sanders playing Nile C-sides in his side project. besides, even if Neurosis lists Josh Graham as a 'member,' he isn't. he does the fucking visuals for their live show. he's no more a member of Neurosis than the guy who runs lighting for Iggy and the Stooges is a member of Iggy and the Stooges.
mst's Avatar
mst | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
"I saw these guys open for Neurosis and it seemed like a bad joke. Gotta wonder what it's like to watch a band open for you and basically play a much crappier version of the exact same shit you play. I think there's some dude from the Neurosis orbit in this band too, which only makes it weirder." Isn't the definition of a side project for some...
WBM's Avatar
WBM | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
Oh no, has our beloved "isis-core", "post doom", "dirge-metal" genre hit the inevitable wall of self-parody? Have we finally had enough of over the top sea-chanties? I do love the sound of the drums, courtesy of a former Unsane band member.
Fecal Facial's Avatar
Fecal Facial | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
I also saw them open for Neurosis (and Converge). While I didn't think they were horrible by any means, they definitely didn't "kill it" like the two bands that followed them. But I think that can be partially attributed to the fact that they're a relatively new band. And there is indeed a member of Neurosis in the band: Josh Graham, who runs their visuals. He also used to play guitar in Red Sparowes.
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
This one isn't for me. If you enjoy Neurosis and Isis just relisten to the old albums. I found Storm of Light sort of boring. And isn't one of the members of this band the keyboard/sampler/visual dude from Neurosis?
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
I saw these guys open for Neurosis and it seemed like a bad joke. Gotta wonder what it's like to watch a band open for you and basically play a much crappier version of the exact same shit you play. I think there's some dude from the Neurosis orbit in this band too, which only makes it weirder.
jonathan's Avatar
jonathan | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
This is like a really boring Neurosis.
borden's Avatar
borden | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
I have to say, I think the review is spot on. An enjoyable listen. Not a lot of replay value. "It’s a fun ride, but ends sooner than you like, leaving you wandering in search of something new rather quickly." My sentiments exactly. Worth a spin though!
rid's Avatar
rid | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
Good review. Pretty much how I felt about it too.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 8/2008 | Reply
I plan one picking this one up eventually. I enjoyed what I've heard.
TheSlayerM's Avatar
TheSlayerM  | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
I'm seeing them live this summer. Very interested in the review!