Album Review

Score 8.5
Written by Jordan Campbell
Published on 6/24/2008
Some six years ago, the release of Daylight Dies' debut album, No Reply, stirred much ado over the band's stylistic approach --more so than was made of the actual tunes that comprised the disc. This was hardly a criminal act, as the hype surrounding the viability of an American melodic death/doom act made for spicier copy than the discussion of the largely forgettable fare that was found on that album. Regardless, the band managed to leave an impression on a country that had yet to see Novembers Doom crash through their personal glass ceiling, and left a curious community lying in wait as to whether we could hang with the Brits and the Finns in the realm of creepy-dead sobriety.

And in wait we would lie...for four years. This great Carolinan (lack of) hope took their sweet-ass time before dropping 2006's Dismantling Devotion, but the wait proved worthwhile, as the band took a drastic leap in both quality and growth. Emerging wisened, weathered, and fortified with melodic chops that sliced with newfound impact, songs like "All We Had" and "Solitary Refinement" showcased the realization of their depressive potential. A scant two years later, after building their crushing live show around the meatiness of Dismantling's most immediate thumpers, Lost to the Living was expected to push their death metal aspect further to the forefront.

Expectations be damned. The band has taken a calculated turn towards even more maturation and depth, crafting an album that is cerebral, yet heartfelt; elegant, but visceral.

Daylight Dies, dare I say, have out-Opethed Opeth with this one. Not in structure, mind you-- Lost to the Living ambles on a straighter path than Akerfeldt's prog-pie crankwalks. But in mood, it trumps. The sound is progressive in its storytelling, a richly-layered journey from depths of mind to caverns of soul. Adhering to their textbook for the first few tracks --a stout and full-bodied deathroar doom with acute gothic sensibilites-- they improve upon their formula, but offer no surprises. 'Tis until the disc-splitting instrumental "And A Slow Surrender" splits a fork in the road and takes the album down a beautiful, beautiful path. The lead guitars on this track are tear-jerking, and indirectly function as a microcosm for the duality that this band projects for the remainder of the record. Contuinally toeing the line between a sound of truimph and a cry of anguish, the band spirals into sorrow on the emotive "Woke Up Lost", grinds into open wounds with the pounding grit of "The Morning Light" (which is sure to be a staple of their vaunted live act), and splays itself open to the strains of "At A Loss". That somber reflection --built upon a gloriously textured bass line-- is the undisputed highlight of this tome, Nathan Ellis straying from his knifetoothed roar long enough to ply his fantastic cleans, which are made all the more special by their sparse utilization. A chilling, chilling animal, this is.

All told? This is the best Daylight Dies album to date, an exponential improvement upon their foundation, and a dramatic strengthening of their identity. Outwardly classy, inwardly raw, Lost to the Living is an emotionally draining tour-de-force that commands unchallenged attention; Daylight Dies mold an experience, a trancedental grip that eclipses any-and-all trappings their subgenre harbors.  

Pure.



Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
Okay, so I went ahead and bought it myself. Such a great fucking album, "Last Alone" is absolutely beautiful. 5.5/5.5/5.5. Something freakish would have to happen to keep this outta' my Top 10 come the end of the year.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
Talk about BLEAK. Damn this album is good. They out-bleak most others. The atmosphere this album produces is phenomenal. Great review.
justinbean's Avatar
justinbean | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
cerebral is a good word for this album indeed. and sweet jesus - the production is stellar.
rhino's Avatar
rhino | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
awesome album, awesome review. top notch sir.
Razorhog's Avatar
Razorhog | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Fantastic review, fantastic album.
Irukandji's Avatar
Irukandji | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
This is so good. Great Doom metal to go up with Draconian and Isole for this year. And it's got even darker atmoshpere too. Though I hate dropping Opeth comparisons; though doom-like they are their own genre, imao. Very eloquent review.
Drew's Avatar
Drew | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Pre-ordered this awhile ago. Can't wait for it to come in the mail. This review has me totally psyched!
steve p's Avatar
steve p | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Deke I'll be it for you if you pay for my next car payment.
Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
I must own this. Somebody buy it for me. Not kidding.
Bradination's Avatar
Bradination | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
These guys are amazing. Seriously well written review.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
I always thought these guys were pretty good but hardly great--you've convinced me to give them another listen.
Matt's Avatar
Matt  | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
If I had to decide now, this would definitely be in my top 3 for the year.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Wooooo boy! This review has definitely got me pumped to listen to this sucker now. Can't wait to hear it!
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Great review Rev. Gotta check this out. Dismantling Devotion was amazing.
novairon's Avatar
novairon | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
great album
ethr's Avatar
ethr | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
nice review