Album Review

Score 7.6
Written by Sasha Horn
Published on 5/6/2008
I have a love/extremely tame dislike relationship with Kalmah. My judgment goes impaired whenever they release something new. I always thoroughly enjoy it though, despite the fact that these ears hear the same album written five times now in twice as many years. But I turn one blind eye to that and let the other take in the cover art (killer, again), and then just go with it. I can't fight it. Kalmah always wins. 

It's "keyboard heavy melodic death metal" for the newcomer; "keyboard heavy melodic death metal" for everyone really. There's not much more to it, and I mean that in the best possible way. Drawing comparisons the world abroad to Children Of Bodom to an unhealthy degree, Kalmah always seemed to me to have a bit more grit under their nails and more gravel in their mouths. Less thrashy, less flashy, and less cosmetic than Bodom, but with more depth, and definitely a more suitable soundtrack for battle scenes. It's a dirty mirrored reflection of typical keyboard-happy Finnish metal bands. It's been ten years now that they've been standing covered in their own filth and they still stand to offend more people. Impressive. Go back and work their entire back-catalog. Listen closely enough to what's underneath those blankets of synths, and you will hear an above average melodic take on death metal by anyone's standards. No keys are required. Enter the fluff that the keys do inject, with skill I might add (I've never taken well to this additive, but you gotta give credit where credit is due), and you get a slight victory-in-warfare metallic color blended in with all that flat-black that suddenly makes Kalmah songs suitable for excessive drinking and screaming along. Tastes great. Less filling. I don't mean like an all out drunken Finntroll-style campfire collection, just don't expect to hear dead people fucking and eating each other for these 44 minutes, far from it. And so yeah, once again all of those colors and feelings are on display here, vibrant and vulnerable, starting with the opener "For The Revolution" setting the tone for this conquest of the same name. A common strategy of theirs is to storm with menace right outta the gates, usually set up with a sick riff ("Holy Symphony of War", "Wings of Blackening", the aforementioned "For The Revolution") gluing together several seconds of a mid-paced head start to the built momentum of a full-swing barrage of blast-beating, layered guitars, and the "key" ingredient. This is just one battle command though. Another tactic is to cool things off, lay low, and re-assimilate. You can hear them mourning their fallen in the acoustic guitars and down-tempo of "Ready For Salvation", and then licking their wounds and gathering strength in the steady and driving pulse of "Dead Man's Shadow". This collective is a slightly more docile affair though, due in part to the production side of things. The drums feel very one-dimensional, with the snare getting the paper-thin treatment; lifeless. The toms could use a pulse as well. This is their main cross to bear on For The Revolution, aside from their Achilles heel in the form of songwriting that gets brought to light more so with each release, like how I'm finding this to be with every new spin, a slightly exhausted extension of the excellent Black Waltz. Which, if you paid close enough attention to the last six words of the previous sentence, is not a bad thing at all. However, I can't see this blemish coming into full view as long as it can live under the skin of their over qualified musicianship, with several guitar tablature sites on your world wide web holding testament enough to the strength and skill of the warriors leading this here '08 revolution. Alexi Laiho (guitarist; Children Of Bodom) styled guitar hi-jinx not included. This isn't nail-polished thrash 'n' roll fretboard hurdling. This is scathing down-home barn-burning, Oulu style. 

There's rhyme and reason here as always. Kalmah dragged the swamps for the old blueprint that's worked so well countless times now. Predictable? Yes. You don't have to dig deep to find their essence. I like that. My work weeks are looooong. Ask me if I feel like excavating come Saturday, and I'll tell you that I'd rather Kalmah.



Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 8/2010 | Reply
Spine/Spikefarm has no love for North America.
dupont's Avatar
dupont | posted on 8/2010 | Reply
I second that.... 12 Gauge???
MetalFusion's Avatar
MetalFusion | posted on 8/2010 | Reply
No review for 12 Gauge..?
dupont's Avatar
dupont | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
I can understand why some people might take this as a somewhat, bland offering from Kalmah. I wasn't initially blown away by their internet samples like I was with the Black Waltz and previous releases, but after purchasing this album I am, completely blown away by the finely tuned musicianship and songwriting. If you are a fan of these guys then you NEED to pull some change together for this one. 6/5.5/5.5
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I`ve always enjoyed this band but this is the first one I`ve *really* enjoyed. Not sure why, as said, it`s nothing new, but it just hit the spot for me.
Warhammer Battle Master's Avatar
Warhammer Battle Master | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I have every other album except Swamplord and I love them all, but after listening to one of the new tracks on their website, I just don't feel like I NEED this. They do play with a great formula, but it might be time to do some tweaking. That said, they are still a great band. I've always felt that they had a great deal more depth to them than Bodom, both in terms of their thematics and songwriting. Their riffs sure kick the shit out of the chug-fest that has been Laiho and co. lately.
Rheotaxis's Avatar
Rheotaxis | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I think this review was waaaaayyyy-suuuuupper-uuuuubeeerrr-overly-critical/nit-picky. and I have no idea what you're talking about here, "aside from their Achilles heel in the form of songwriting that gets brought to light more so with each release" This album, with a 4.5 songwriting rating, is their lowest...ever, on this site. (and I'm pretty sure all the others are 6.0's....weird) If you've enjoyed any of Kalmah's previous albums, you'll love this album as well. There's nothing but more swampy-goodness to be found here.
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
the black waltz was the perfect album to beat swamplord, in my opinion. this is still enjoyable, and with kalmah, you can't go wrong. for straight up melodic death metal, i doubt we'll find anything better in 2008.
DUDE's Avatar
DUDE | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
If this is anything like the Black Waltz I'm all over it!
Io's Avatar
Io | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
So far I'm finding this to be better than The Black Waltz which may only be because of the vocals; they were mostly low growls on TBW, and there's much more of a balance here, like on the previous albums. Yet, I'm disappointed that this is the second album in a row with no mention of swamps.
Stalker's Avatar
Stalker | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
though by no means bad, I found black waltz to be my least favorite of theirs. If this is a step back then I am happy to hear it. at least the lead song is better than the leadoff on the last one. Cant wait to buy lat er this month.
Widowmaker8008's Avatar
Widowmaker8008 | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I'll always love Kalmah, but I do feel they took a small step backward from The Black Waltz. Near spot on review.
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
borrrrringggg.
Juho's Avatar
Juho  | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
Great review. This is also probably the first time my home town gets mentioned in Metal Review.
Reason's Voice's Avatar
Reason's Voice | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I enjoy all of Kalmah's material, but I felt that this new one seemed kind of lacking upon first listen. Definitely less bite than previous effort "The Black Waltz."