Album Review

Score 10
Written by Sasha Horn
Published on 4/11/2008
Arsis are a band that need no introduction. But if I absolutely had to, at a party let's say, and I forgot your name, I would introduce them quickly as my boy Arsis '08, with personality traits Death (quite a bit), and Byzantine (quite a very little bit), and Lamb Of God (track nine exclusively), with an affinity for PCP and coffee, and then turn around and run away. You see, I've been listening to those three alot as of lately, when I wasn't doing my homework, plus I have a social anxiety disorder with a side of ADD, so don't "What the fuck?!!?!?" me. True that my "setback" has me pretty much saying anything to get me away from you at this point, but there's still a little truth in that hurried and scattered comparison.  Anyway, you should already know who these poster-boys of American technical-death-metal are, and if you don't, then let me go shove my fingers down my throat. I've been at this party for a week, I drank this album about 30 times, I've obviously gotten belligerent, and I have this next paragraph to vomit out so that we can get down to business.

Not everybody on this planet could have known that Arsis took the melodic-death-metal world by tsunami when they dropped A Celebration Of Guilt back in '04, even though it seemed that way. It made 99% of critics', and the general publics', year-end-best-of lists, and then filled the number one slot on 99% of those lists. I think that even my mom put that one on her top ten along side whatever Seal album came out that year. Not really, but you get the point; surprisingly strong and consistent for a debut. Pulling at the heartstrings harder was the fact that it was the brainchild of one James Malone, who composed everything and handled all instruments aside from the drums. One year later, those saviors of the sub-sub-human race teased us with A Diamond For Disease, spawning chronic masturbatory symptoms within that ever-growing world of pretentious tech-metal-heads, AKA my address. Yeah, I live there too. I ain't knockin' it. They stepped up their game in all three of the areas that are bar-graphed above. Their teeth got sharper. If there were any non-believers left, they were mostly silenced. Of the three songs on Diamond..., there was only one new one, but that one original composition, the title track, was thirteen interesting minutes long and was written for NYC's Ballet Deviare. Welcome to the upper echelon. That's impressive, in a morbid-coffee-house kinda way, and surely gained them at least a few new fans in the upper decks. Now they've got the masses salivating for a second substantial piece of meat, so United In Regret drops in 2006. Not bad. Maybe just almost good, then. One step to the side, a half step back. I find it to be completely redundant, now. I still enjoyed it a helluva lot more a week and a half ago, before my bender with the biggest nightmare they've ever written. Many things will get left in the shadow of this.

What does We Are The Nightmare sound like.....  Can I start with what this album feels like? It feels like five hundred thousand maggots and five hundred thousand baby spiders all tangled up and fighting for breathing room and nourishment inside of the one million nooks, crannies, crevices, creases, and folds of my veins, intestines, and tracts. Seriously. Nothing else in their back-catalog, or anybody's catalog really, ever gets this close to actually making me feel buried. The trip over from United into Nightmare mirrors, eerily, the transformation that Death took on from Spiritual Healing into Human, in both sound and consequence. It's a leap forward of monolithic proportions, making Malone sound like he spent the last two years deep in seance with his axe. Besides just never having lost the part of him that sounds like, well, himself (a feat no doubt), he now channels equal parts Muhammed Suicmez (Necrophagist) and Ihsahn (Emperor,etc.), making this body of work feel fragile, like a butterfly on the shoulder of a serial killer. There's grace in every swing of Nightmare's chopping spree.  (Fretboard gymnasts of the current Generation Zzzzzz take note: you can dance all over the neck, but most of you are forgetting about making anything stick). These riffs here drive a nail through it, in multitudes, with purpose, and they never let up. Injected, perhaps by the newly added second guitarist, Ryan Knight (The Knife Trade), was the whole Arsis embodiment, because it just now dilated and peaked out. This is the pulse I've been waiting for. For every sickeningly precise flailing of chord progressions, there's a hammer riff waiting on the wing to pound them out. It's like the frigid mathematical schizophrenia of Necrophagist getting balanced out by the warm-bloodedness of Arsis B.C. (before catharsis). Also crucial to how this piece got twisted into form, was the entrance of new drummer Darren Cesca (ex-Burn In Silence) with the absence of first and only Arsis drummer Michael VanDyne.  From a drummer's perspective, I absolutely welcome with open arms, the (pretty much never heard of previously on Arsis material) blast-beating with the kick between the snare hits. If there's one thing I grew tired of early on, it was VanDyne's extreme love of the "Suffo-blast" (named after NY death metal outfit Suffocation, who's drummer Mike Smith is credited with "inventing" the blast-beat who's snare hits are played simultaneously with the kick hits). To sum up Cesca's whole performance in short, he stabs through speakers, so very much like what Sean Reinert did for Human after Bill Andrews left us with Spiritual Healing, that it's scary. Cesca leaves Nightmare littered with fills that lock in perfectly with Malone's fretted paranoia. Not showoff-y. Premeditated. Granted, VanDyne did an admirable job, but things started to feel a bit predictable. And of course, what would all this be really, if it wasn't brought to you in part by production pristine courtesy of Zeuss (Shadows Fall, Municipal Waste). Sounds like crystal. The only thing that could feel colder, crisper, and more calculated is if you shoved fucking icicles into my ears. 

You need some "highlights"?  Some "key tracks"?

Buy this. Go die. Get buried.



6whore6grinder6's Avatar
6whore6grinder6 | posted on 7/2009 | Reply
these guys are ok. the artwork is fucking gnarly though.
Beak's Avatar
Beak | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Forerunners of Tech Death Metal.
Andrewmassacre's Avatar
Andrewmassacre | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
Also when I listened to this album all the way through (because it's way too hard to switch songs) I found my self actually getting tired. That is a perfect example of what any album of this stature should do.
Andrewmassacre's Avatar
Andrewmassacre | posted on 11/2008 | Reply
I have to be honest here since I've seen them live and I've heard the album. They are as you so Un-nervably randomly described it, a phenominal band and a definite force to be wreckoned with in Technical Death Metal. Dare I say that if Bach and Bethoven were still alive they would both constantly party with Arsis and Children Of Bodom. This album is one of the only "Death Metal" type albums I have ever enjoyed and listened to other than anything from In Flames and Whitechapel. It's build is that of a Dream Theater album, sped up on steroids with the vocals of a trully sinister reverend spitting out the words of a Demon that has possessed him. As a side note, when i saw them live they were with a bunch of Hardcore bands on Thrash And Burn in Louisville. We spent most of the night making fun of the Thrash dancers because they almost hit us or did hit us and it was pissing us off. When Arsis came on I looked back at them to see if they would even try. One guy tried to do it but he couldn't find any breakdowns to do it with, the guy next to him just nudged him and gave him a look that said, "Dude, no. Just no."
dougwhatyoudidisrape's Avatar
dougwhatyoudidisrape | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
Agreed. Arsis make every other tech-metal band sound like they don't know how to write a song, and every other melo-death band sound like they need to practice their instruments more.
CheezThief's Avatar
CheezThief | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
MY best of '08 so far, but don't forget, we still have Mastodon, The Faceless, All Shall Perish, and a few other bands coming out with shit this year. Arsis are the best thing going in metal right now.
tiberious's Avatar
tiberious | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
I've been listening to this band for a few days now. My first impression was its decent but didnt really tingle my spine much. After repeat listens it seems to be slowly growing on me. Nothing I would straight 6's too, but overall pretty tight album.
Unknown Metalhead
\m/usclehead | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
I never really checked this band out before, even though I am a sucker for Melo-Death. I went ahead and downloaded United in Regret and A Celebration of Guilt, and I'm really glad I did. I know I'm kinda late in the game on this one, but I'm totally gonna have to get hold of this album too, because A Celebration of Guilt is freakin' awesome.
crucifiedjesus's Avatar
crucifiedjesus | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
album of the year!!! this is such a beautiful evolution of their sound and some of the best song writing i have heard in a long time with technicality to rival the best. this album has absoultly everything i look for in metal from the blazing solos to the sick riffs and tight as shit drumming. I just cant say enough about it
Beak's Avatar
Beak | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
Fucking great album. "The only thing that could feel colder, crisper, and more calculated is if you shoved fucking icicles into my ears."
iezzywiezzypoo's Avatar
iezzywiezzypoo | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
a perfect 10 in my book.
vggls's Avatar
vggls | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I liked this record very much
fightingmike's Avatar
fightingmike | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I love Celebration of Guilt, but didnt really get into United or Diamond. This is technically very impressive, but there aren't any hooks like there were on Celebration. It just seems like super wankerism to me and the drums really bother me alot of the time as well, totally overplayed!
Corporal Jigsore's Avatar
Corporal Jigsore | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
Listened to this 3 times in the 24 hours since i got it. Every listen it gets better. I reckon this will be a grower that ends up being huge.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I'm liking this. A lot. I do prefer VanDyne's drumming, but only because I think it fits the music better. Gets better with every listen for me.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Much better than last album, but fuck that production/mix is dry.
animate's Avatar
animate | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I haven't heard this yet, but this review isn't helping. Darren Cesca better than VanDyne? Shit, man, that dude was pretty much unstoppable. And "predictable"? What?!
scintilla's Avatar
scintilla | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I love this album! Downloaded it (legally!) but wondering about the DVD. Is it worth buying with the album? Whats in it? Just them goofing around?
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This one got me snoring..
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Well in an interview that Malone did he said that Cesca did the low growls on the album because Malone did not feel comfortable with his voice for doing the lows. And not to sound like an ass but I don't see how naming one song Talley didn't drum extremely technical makes him more suited. He is an amazing drummer and but he's not the kind of drummer that is gonna dumb down his technical skills just to play in an amazing band like Arsis (although I never heard him on the Chimaira and Daath albums he did both which I heard were completely average). I know what you mean with Cesca and hopefully he will tone it down a little next album since but I think he did a great job on this album.
gumplunger's Avatar
gumplunger | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
@Steve P: Cesca does some low growls and some high screams live but the studio vocals is all Malone. Also, Talley is a much more musical drummer than Cesca. He knows how to not overplay in metal, maybe not so much in the Dying Fetus days, but he still wrote some very memorable drum parts back then. Just off the top of my head, compare the first track on Misery Index's Dissent to the last track. He goes from doomy, almost minimalist drumming to all-out thrash and death metal blasting. Cesca's drums seem to all blend together into one big clusterfuck of blasts and tom rolls.
xrybreadx's Avatar
xrybreadx | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
wouldn't gave this is a 6/6/6, maybe a 5/4.5/6. I'll be recording with Zuess this summer so I'll be curious to ask about how the recording session for this went. But yes, I liked this album, still not as good as Celebration, but better than United.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Picked up my copy, the free dvd is indeed funny and its cool to watch those dudes jam out. But man it looks bad in HD.
Unknown Metalhead
no life til leather | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Arsis brings metal community together anyway. They are bridging that gap between Swedish Melodic and well... Arsis. Not a great album but really refreshing.
Unknown Metalhead
no life til leather | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Arsis brings metal community together anyway. They are bridging that gap between Swedish Melodic and well... Arsis. Not a great album but really refreshing.
Bradination's Avatar
Bradination | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Sasha writes great reviews. I'm not knocking his grammatical supremacy (like that?). I just dont' like Arsis, at all.
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This album is good, but 6/6/6? Why does this band have such a loyal following that the album MUST achieve these scores or else? On another note, I'm not sure fellow reviewers from this site should be bashing on other reviewers, or their reviews. Isn't it their place to be possitive or objective of other reviewers?
Bradination's Avatar
Bradination | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This band is beyond overrated. I'm interested to hear their next album. It's supposed to be a concept album about a nap I took last Saturday.
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
@ gumplunger: Not to sound like a nitpicky dickhead but there are actually 4 snare drums that Cesca uses. I also think its really stupid to blame all the triggering and stuff on Cesca when Arsis is basically James Malone's band and I'm sure that if Malone didn't like something then it wouldn't have been put on the album. And you're complaining about Cesca being just technical and you want to see Kevin Talley instead? I love Talley but I don't see him as being a better replacement at all. Also the low growls you speak of are actually from Cesca.
gumplunger's Avatar
gumplunger | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I'm an Arsis nerd but I'll keep this objective. Vocals: Jim has never sounded better. He uses the low growl more often than usual and I'm liking it. It makes the vocals feel less one-dimensional, which was my main complaint with Arsis vocals before this album. Guitars: Awesome as usual. Ryan Knight is a beast. Seriously, he's one of the best, and under-appreciated, guitarists I've seen recently. Not much to say here, just that they've stepped up the technicality from past releases. Bass: Noah is an awesome bassist and a fine songwriter too (I heard some of his power metal Guitar Pro tabs), so why is the bass so buried in the mix? I can't really say much about the bass since I can't hear it - on another forum someone said this album was the "And Justice For All" of technical death metal. Drums: Here's where I start to have serious problems. It seems most people either loved Van Dyne and dislike Cesca or vice versa. Personally, I loved "Celebration..." but when I went to see Arsis for the first time, a few months before "United..." came out, Van Dyne was very obviously struggling with keeping up the tempo during blasts. He kind of ruined it for me actually. A fluke perhaps? Well I saw him again months after that and again, he couldn't keep up. It was painful listening to the tempo of "Face Of My Innocence" drop by 30 BPM when the blasts came in. Fast forward to when Cesca joins the band. I had only heard of him from Goratory and I thought it was kind of a strange choice, but hey, at least he'll be able to keep up the tempo live. Well, he did - actually, every song was noticeably faster than on record. This wouldn't be a problem except for in some cases it sounded TOO rushed and every song seemed to be at exactly the same tempo. Also, he put his trademark 32nd note kick rolls under EVERYTHING. Most of the drums the first two times I saw Arsis with Darren just sounded like one constant triggered kick at the same tempo for 30 minutes. That made it fairly difficult to get an accurate impression of what he would sound like on Arsis's next album, so I held out hope. I'm disappointed. Everything about the drums on this album reeks of an ego-maniac drummer; the same sort of feeling I get from John Longstreth (apparently Guy from the Red Chord had the same basic opinion, yeah he's fast, but he always wants to do something overly technical and doesn't pay much attention to the song itself). The guy not only has one speed, but one style. Jim and Ryan seem to be able to alternate the ridiculous technical riffs with the simple "fist-pumpers" and make a catchy song. Darren seems unable to do anything but play really technical, fast, unmemorable stuff ALL THE TIME. Also, there are three snare drums on this album - all obviously triggered samples, but probably sampled from his own kit - and they all sound less than stellar. For the amount of snare drum hits on the album you'd think he would actually want a decent sounding snare. I've got the same complaint about the toms - they sound like ass, and again, I'm assuming they're sampled from his kit. This is typical ego-drummer behavior: I may tap my huge drum kit so I can get the speeds that I do, and nothing in the kit actually sounds good, but I demand that we use the samples from my drum kit. Its the producer/mixer's job to make the band sound good and its understandably hard to do that when you're on a limited budget as Arsis must be, and the drummer needs to be constantly quantized in Pro Tools and he insists on using terrible sounding drums. It's been my position for a while now that Arsis need a drummer on the level of Kevin Talley or Gene Hoglan to really reach the top of their game. That was longer than I wanted it to be, but I felt like someone out there should present a good argument as to why Cesca brings this album down a few notches.
Unknown Metalhead
bartlett | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This review is awful. How can MR have this terrible writing represent their website, especially on such an anticipated release? I'm embarassed. Looking forward to this album though...
Dr's Avatar
Dr | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I was really excited when I heard Darren Cesca was going to be on this album. After hearing some of his other bands (Goratory, Pillory, Burn in Silence) I knew that this was going to be entertaining.
Xero337's Avatar
Xero337 | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Didn't think that tis would get so much controversy lol but each person has their opinion i spose............Malone is my hero another great album from the legion of darkness Arsis
Iron Maiden's Avatar
Iron Maiden | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Wow. I'm a little surprised at the score and all of the hard-on's people are having over this album. But hey, to each his own I guess.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I intend to get my hands on this one soon.
Dethtroll76's Avatar
Dethtroll76 | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
There is nothing more vexing than when a non-musician trys to be overly critical and analyze a real musicians skills. Stop making superficial judgments on skill when you know absolute dick about drumming. Once again...Holy Fuck this album is good!
Facial La Fleur's Avatar
Facial La Fleur | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Interesting review. In a good way of course. You're all over the place and with the album in question I'm sure it's more than appropriate cuz said album likely shares the same characteristics. Can't wait to hear it.
lolograde's Avatar
lolograde | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Persecution, the funny thing here is that you're getting upset because of my comments and you're tell *me* to relax? Hahaha, irony! You're right, James can do whatever the hell he wants. But is he making good music now? Nope. I hope he enjoys making bad music, cause you gotta enjoy what you do in life, right? To the people that say Cesca is a "better drummer", I've gotta say that there's a massive difference between technique and tastefulness. Cesca maybe a better drummer technically, but for the genre Van Dyne's style fit perfectly with Arsis' original sound (it was groovy, it was heavy, and it was unique).
Dethtroll76's Avatar
Dethtroll76 | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I was never a big fan of Arsis's previous albums because it always felt like something was lacking ( weak production, repetitive riffing, indistinguishable songs) After hearing this album I think they have finally arrived! Musically this album is to Arsis what "Slaughter of the Soul" was to At The Gates. If this album does not blow you away...you should blow your head off! Fucking Brutal....End of Story!
m4gg0t5's Avatar
m4gg0t5 | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This album is sooooo good ! It make me forget about UiR that was IMO terrible. It's their best since A Celebration Of Guilt. And for those you don't like this drummer.. ehhh.. what you need more than this ? This guys destroys VanDyne's stuff. Don't get me wrong, VanDyne was very good but we can feel that he's going nowhere in UiR compare to the first 2 albums. Cesca make me forget everything Vandyne has done in Arsis. He's a faster, better and more complete drummer in everything. 6/6/6 for sure
persecution's Avatar
persecution | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
fuck. i hate commenting more than once, it comes off as having some kind of dependency problem. but anyway, where is this shit coming from? arsis should do this, arsis should do that. FUCK. let them be. you don't own them. you sound like my doting grandmother (bless her soul) if james malone's self esteem is hurting, it is because he has a small penis. NOT because his band is signed to nuclear blast, that he plays music for a living, and a lot of people seem to really appreciate what he does. so leave your amateur psychoanalysis at home. and go get a beer. relax. i'm sure there will be other bands to satisfy your advanced criteria for musical appreciation.
lolograde's Avatar
lolograde | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Also, can you guys get someone to review these albums from a objective point of view??? This Sasha guy probably wrote this review without even listening to the album.
lolograde's Avatar
lolograde | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I agree with YourMom. This album does nothing for me. I feel like James has lost his sound. ACoG and ADfD are both incredible. I love the sound of both those albums. I'm pretty sure the reason why Van Dyne left was because he didn't like the direction the band was headed. It seems like Arsis' tour with The Faceless and Necrophagist killed James' self-esteem. Because I have a feeling that he's trying to be something he's not on this album as well as United In Regret. The guitars are less meaty, the gain is nearly a zero, and instead of actually created any half-decent melody he's trying to go for wow factor with the guitar wankery. Muhammed (of Necrophagist) proves that guitar wankery can be heavy as fuck and melodic, but the way James does it on We Are The Nightmare is often times just a silly mess of non-melodic notes.
dougwhatyoudidisrape's Avatar
dougwhatyoudidisrape | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I don't know why people shit over UIR, that album (while not entirely as catchy as ACOG) was a step forward in diversity between songs and within the songs (particularly the structures) themselves. Anyway, this album is incredible and it should go without saying that those who don't enjoy it are suffering from some sort of listening-handicap that is deserving of pity.
Unknown Metalhead
cryptic*slaughterer | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
@ Rev: brother, i hear you. but i actually think that Cesca stepping into the spotlight acts as some kind of conduit. it sounds to me like they're feeding off of each other, meeting riff with riff, and taking Arsis to another level. i feel like there is still a little ACoG in Nightmare, and i'm glad that they didn't just make ACoG Act 2. But i would like to always hear the evidence of Celebration in everything to come.....
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I'm a total Arsis geek. ACoG is one of my favorite albums of all time, and I think this one kicks ass as well. This album is proof that Ryan Knight is a great asset to the band, and James' riffs and vocal lines here basically make United In Regret irrelevant. But count me as one of those die-hard Arsis fans that doesn't get down with Cesca. Van Dyne was one of my favorite drummers -he absolutely killed live- and seeing him go was a tough pill to swallow. I think Cesca's handwork is a little too "look-at-me!"; the focal point of this band should be the guitars, not the snare drum. That said, I'm in love this album, and I can't wait to see this material played live.
Radar's Avatar
Radar | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I've finally made headway in enjoying this. Hooray, another few months will be spent in servitude to Arsis! Production's definitely not perfect though. The guitars need that compressed, blackened edge back that they had on ACOG, and the drums sound clicky even for a tech-death album. All the pieces fit together well, though. So there's that...
YourMom's Avatar
YourMom | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
On anothe interesting note, a lot of people also seem to have the exact opposite opinion about the drumming. Seems a lot of Arsis fans I've talked too don't think Cesca fits in with the band and much preferred VanDyne.
YourMom's Avatar
YourMom | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Ummm...wow. Really? Many people whose musical tastes I trust seem to have a pretty negative view about this album. Weird to see such a completely opposite opinion. I haven't checked this out and don't think I will. I though ACOG was good but overhyped..DFD was pretty rad... but then came UIR which I found laughably bad, to be honest. The songs Ive heard from this haven't done a whole lot for, so I won't bother.
Unknown Metalhead
Metalhead_87 | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Man theres way too many good albums out right now I dont know how im going to keep up
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
@JB: At times on the blast beats you can hear differences in snare sounds but I don't think I've heard him doing fills with different snares or maybe I just can't tell but I read the same thing. I'm sure he did but I don't think hes doing anything to insane with them all.
Reason's Voice's Avatar
Reason's Voice | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Just got my CMdistro package, listening for the first time, and so far... holy shit! The art of shredding indeed.
jason jordan's Avatar
jason jordan | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
@ JB: It wasn't UM because we haven't reviewed this yet.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Arsis gets further from my tastes with each new release. Celebration was amazing from start to finish, probably one of the best melodic death metal albums ever. But they keep moving further and further from the all-out aggression that helped to define the first album, replacing it with the same hackneyed technical prowess that is the focus of too many metal bands. To me this sounds like the progressive thrash of Watchtower/Anacrusis/Annihilator, more than anything else. I wish they'd go back to their more straight ahead melodic thrashing death metal style.
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Whew! I was reading another site the other day, maybe ultimatemetal.com or something, and they crapped all over this album. I was worried because I was really looking forward to it. I'm relieved to see my favorite metal site has given it props. As long as it's better than United and more in line with Guilt. I read that their new drummer has 4 friggin snares on his kit. Does he use them all, or has anyone noticed?
ragnarok's Avatar
ragnarok | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
way over-hyped
cooperaa's Avatar
cooperaa | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Definitely and amazing album that even rivals A Celebration of Guilt for their best! Check it out!
elpants's Avatar
elpants | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Oh yeah, you forgot that the DVD it comes with is worth the cost of the CD alone.
elpants's Avatar
elpants | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
mmmm, good review.
briandestroyer's Avatar
briandestroyer | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This album is ridiculous. jaw dropping the whole way. too bad they keep missing shows with transportation problems.
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
this has been the definitive american extreme metal band to get behind, but they still haven't made their perfect masterpiece. i'm more of a proponent of arsis live- particularly for james' insane guitarwork, though the recordings are technically excellent. the songwriting quality is not consistently great, though the good tracks are worth the ride. some of the guitar sections are just amazing, and the vocals are vicious as well as legible, which is a lot more than one can say about many death metal bands.
sweetiemuffinsugarplum's Avatar
sweetiemuffinsugarplum | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Want. Putting it on the list right now...
Warhammer Battle Master's Avatar
Warhammer Battle Master | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Great review. The whole "I've been at this party for a week..." trope was a chuckler for sure. Anyway, I love love love the songs I've heard already and will be picking this up the moment I see it.
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Hell of an album. Good review, Sasha.
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Oh man I can't express my love for this album and I just got it two days ago. I wasn't a hater of United in Regret but this album makes that one sound like shit. These of some of the most technical, catchy riffs I've heard in a long time. The biggest step up from United in Regret besides the production is the drumming is such a step up. UiR's drumming was boring at times but like said in the review Cesca's schizo drumming allows Malone to do a lot more guitar noodling. Bottom line is this is how you make technical death and many bands should take note.
Number2's Avatar
Number2 | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
great review....no one makes heavy sound as catchy as arsis. the comparisons are there b/c the riffs "stick". i have been catching myself humming the riff to "we are the nightmare" daily.
TeraPatrickEatsAHotdog's Avatar
TeraPatrickEatsAHotdog | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
It almost comes across as Quo Vadis on crack, minus the lack of bass. Maybe thats just because of moments in the vocals. Oh well, I view that as a compliment. I'll be picking this up shortly. Good review, too.
Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This is the first Arsis album I really enjoyed listening to, and I'm looking forward to picking it up soon. Another guaranteed sale.
Irukandji's Avatar
Irukandji | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Good review; Great Album. Now somebody review the new Origin and last year's Visceral Bleeding, for fuck's sake.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Guess I shouldn't say 'a bit more bite' as maybe a tad more bass, as Noah is a total freak. But regardless, I'm an asshole for even criticizing an album this good. This is just vicious. And with that, I'll quit commenting.
Bucketochicken's Avatar
Bucketochicken | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
So...... you enjoyed it, then?
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Great review-i need to get this-so long as its better than the last one
Unknown Metalhead
cryptic*slaughterer | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Zach, i thought about the "bit more bite" thing too..... but the more and more i listened to it, the more and more i liked that it still had a very very slight organic quality to it, that i thought any more compression or tweaking would have killed off.
Unknown Metalhead
cryptic*slaughterer | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
yeah Persecution, that DVD wasn't included in my promo pack. can't wait to get my eyes on it.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
But to augment what I just said... is the album perfect? I don't think so. Close, but not there. The production could use a bit more bite. I'd give it a 5/5.5/6. Which is still darn good, and still better than what 99.99% of metal bands can even fathom putting out.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I second that, get Ryan Knight a beer now, that kid is as much a freak as Malone. This album is just ridiculous. Love it.
FollowChrist's Avatar
FollowChrist | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Fantastic. I love this album. Great review. My words can't compare. Just simply awesome album. Something I have been needing, burning, and longing for a long time. Thank you Arsis for that warm fuzzing feeling you give me. God bless.
persecution's Avatar
persecution | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
what, no mention of their dvd of shenanigans? well anyway, this is a very good album. and what great layout and design. the lyrics look like they were written on parchment, or some shit. anyway, this album rules. get that second guitarist a beer.
The Great Cretaceous Bob's Avatar
The Great Cretaceous Bob | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Huh. Well then, I'll probably pick this up when I see them the 24th. Originally, I was going to wait, but you've got my hopes up again. Let's see.
ethr's Avatar
ethr | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
Nice...