Album Review

Score 8.3
Written by Keith Fox
Published on 3/24/2008
Winter is slowly receding here in Minnesota as all of the snow and ice is giving way to mud, cold rain, and stormy winds. I love spring for a lot of reasons, but right now top on the list is that spring's raw power puts me in a constant folk metal mood.  Only folk metal can answer spring's call of the wild and provide me with that musical sense of adventure that I need to thaw my bones and get outside. So it's fitting that I've found a new friend in Slania, whose Celtic woodland melodies are as immediately convincing as they are escapist. Eluveitie sound a lot like Dark Tranquillity filtering In Flames and expanding their sound with eight musicians playing Celtic music with instruments like the hurdygurdy, the violin, various pipes, a bagpipe and female vocals. If that sounds as good to you as it does to me then fear not because this album should meet your expectations. If you still need a review read on.

The band call their style the "New Wave of Folk Metal", and that tag suits them well. This is  folk metal for sure, but definitely also something fresher than the mere combination of folk melodies with metal instrumentation. Equal parts melodeath and folk, with neither side overpowering the other, the songs here feel so natural that even after many spins I often find myself wondering whether that song on my iPod shuffle is some new Gothenburg band I've forgotten about or some kick-ass folk metal band that writes good riffs and catchy choruses that could stand alone if separated from their Celtic accompaniment. It's always the latter. "Bloodstained Ground", for example, comes ripping out of the gate before the folk instruments make their appearance, and even when they do, the song's forward lurch doesn't slow to make room for the piercing woodwinds that supplement rather than overpower the sound.

None of this is to say that the folk elements are superfluous. It's not the heavy Dark Tranquillity vibe that makes Slania so great, and neither is it the folk melodicism; it's the seamless pairing of the two that Eluveitie does so convincingly and that makes Slania such a great listen. Watch the video for the first single "Inis Mona" for example. Around two and half minutes into it, during a very metal bridge with riffing that calls to mind In Flames in their good days, lead singer Chrigel pulls out his pipe and belts out a solo. And it's not funny at all, because it just feels so right with them. Similarly, if you thought bagpipes weren't metal, think again: Sevan looks fit to play bass in a viking metal band and he plays his bagpipes with as much conviction as any viking metal axe-man.

Of course a unique, well-executed sound can only get you so far, and luckily Eluveitie write really good, catchy, forest-evoking, beer-swilling, sword-fighting songs to boot. My favorite tracks are "Inis Mona", "Calling The Rain", "Gray Sublime Archon", "Slania's Song" and especially closer "Elembivos" which is the least like its other non-interlude brethren. It's got a long buildup featuring pipes and male chanting before, at nearly four minutes, a guitar solo joins the folk metal march and is soon followed by the violin's turn in the spotlight. This pipe-driven song is simple and really more of a cool-down than a track proper but it's done well and representative of the more traditional folk sound that Eluveitie are equally skilled at producing. Think of Týr  for a good point of reference.

The one flaw with Slania is that it doesn't vary too much. There's an intro, outro, and a few Celtic instrumental segues along the way, but the ride mostly consists of this New Wave of Folk Metal played on repeat with little variation among the song structures. Why the scores are so high then, in case you were wondering, is because I think the formula is done so well that the listener shouldn't mind the repetition. I certainly don't.



Mugwump's Avatar
Mugwump | posted on 7/2011 | Reply
This is a perfect review. I actually prefer Finntroll's more technically varied take on viking metal. Eluveitie has a damn fine formula and nail their Celtic instrumentation to their metal with perfection, but it's pretty much the same block of death metal with some bitchin' melodies over the top.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 3/2011 | Reply
I agree with what everyone is say, and just want to add one thing: aside from all the Celtic stuff and vocals, the fact is these guys just write and execute killer guitar riffs. Really catchy and super heavy, riffs that would stand out in any metal band. For example the riff on the instrumental on Inis Mona is so kick ass, as is the prechorus on Gray Sublime Archon. I don't think people would be so in love with Eluveitie if not for the outstanding metal bed tracks.
()'s Avatar
() | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Finally picked this up the other day, and to needlessly add my two cents, I have to say I agree with the review. I could give a shit about variance in song structure in regards to this CD. It just works so well, by the time I've spun it through, I'm hitting play and starting the ride all over again.
dupont's Avatar
dupont | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
Spot on Review! Great combination of death and folk elements. A nice, fresh apporach to the genre. @BEZOAR The DT/Riverdance comparison works well for this album!
ash's Avatar
ash | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
The singer sounds alot like the dude from norther. Really awesome album though. I think there are more variations in this then the Ensiferum album. I thought the throaty/melodic singing in whatever language in Slania's song was awesome. A good break from the melodeath riffing.
Unknown Metalhead
GameFreac | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
One of my favorite bands Never thought I would see them in the US but here we are with a month away until Paganfest I can't wait Spirit is better IMO but this album is GREAT I love it....Bloodstained Ground is my favorite
tiberious's Avatar
tiberious | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
A great viking album, not superb; but has some familiar sounds to it as well as some newer experimention like for instance; the heavenly fucking bag pipes. This review is dead on, some of the songs do sound like what In Flames should still be sounding like, but fuck them, this about Eluveitte. The good: -killer vocalist (both lead and female singer) -nice Gothenburg style riffs -bagpipes are nicely done and blend well The bad: - Much repetition in most of the songs, the fiddle song just keeps repeating the same notes over and over which gets tiring. - Not enough instrumental spaces and mystique that couldve been added to give more depth (turisas does this the best) - and agreed with however said it, the female needs to sing more, she adds a nice edge to the album. Overall some good shit to spin for awhile. A very commendable album.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
This is my first taste of "pagan" metal, and I must say this cd is killer. I'm sure another band has done it better, but for my virgin ears this is pretty damn good. One thing I found hilarious was in the video for Inis Mona, the guy playing the pipes has this fierce look of destruction on his face. Just looks a bit strange, that's all. Sounds like Dark Tranquility crashing a showing of Riverdance.
fightingmike's Avatar
fightingmike | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I really like this band, but if they didnt have the extra instruments, they would be extremely boring. This is BRAVEHEART-METAL!!!
ephemeral's Avatar
ephemeral | posted on 4/2008 | Reply
I love this CD, yes is it Swedish metal with Celtic instruments, but it is done so perfectly that I can forgive that. I think they should use their female vocalist more, she can sing. Also, the intro is awesome and I wish they would have made that into a song.
Radar's Avatar
Radar | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Really it's a lot less adventurous than I was hoping for. To me it's just Reroute To Remain with Finntroll's guitar tone and Kalmah's keys.
The Great Cretaceous Bob's Avatar
The Great Cretaceous Bob | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
The standard melodeath with metalcore production with folk elements lash is correct; the absurd "Finntroll-Switch-Engage" lash is not.
VileVengeance's Avatar
VileVengeance | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Damn that's a lot of band members!!
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
It's kind of like Finntoll-Switch-Engage. I can't tell if it's good for a laugh or actually good. I recomend hearing it once to see.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
I plan to get this CD eventually. Definitely seeing em live in April though. Should be a blast.
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Excellent album!
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Well this just sounds killer.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
yeah- at times, this is a pipe break away from being US sounding Swedecore at times, decent thought
Zal's Avatar
Zal | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
I loved "Spirit" and with Paganfest a month away, I was already planning to pick this up. And now this review only enforces that. Sweet.
Warhammer Battle Master's Avatar
Warhammer Battle Master | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
hmmm....It's catchy. That's for sure. I like the folk alot more than the melodic-death parts though. Listen to 'Bloodstained Ground.' 1:10 to about 1:37, it's totally generic melodeath, maybe with an almost standard metalcore production. Then suddenly the folk instrumentation kicks back in and it's fucking awesome. I'm feeling conflicted.
Mortem's Avatar
Mortem | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Been meaning to pick this up. Can't wait to see them live in may. I just hope their songs can translate to a live setting