Album Review

Score 8.6
Written by Jordan Campbell
Published on 1/29/2008
From an ethereal void, a salvo is fired…

Nearly five years ago, Decrepit Birth unleashed their debut album, …And Time Begins. The album's esoteric lyrical approach and riffcramming athleticism elevated them to cult status among brutal death metal fans, but there was something missing. The defining power (the "x-factor", if you will) that propels grander acts was nowhere to be found, and the band slid back into the shadows. Now, the band has pooled their energies and re-emerged, reborn. Their viciously dexterous attack remains intact, but has been completely revamped. Bolstered by a jaw-dropping emphasis on hypermelodic ultra-shred soloing, Diminishing Between Worlds is a new beginning for the band, packed to the gills with something largely absent from 21st Century death metal: The element of surprise.

Surprising, not only due to the glorious overhaul, but for the way this new approach dominates the album and controls the tide. Mithras seem to be their only peer in this regard (is that cover art merely coincidence? I think not…), as both bands are adept at manipulating mood through light-speed melody. In fact, to dip into the shallow well of comparison, Diminishing Between Worlds sounds like Mithras on a Death binge. This tendency to lean on a Schuldinerian bite lends an impactful edge to the band's otherworldliness. The result? An immediate skull-kicker. The moment the opening track throws down, the claws sink in. And while the band has nearly done a 180 by making the leads the focal point, they still kowtow to the power of the riff. Guitarist Matt Sotelo seems to adhere to the stone-faced credo of "A solo is only as good as the rhythm beneath it", and ensures that all aspects of the guitar work are delivered with blowback annihilation. The result is the first great album of 2008.

So here's the breakdown (because, thankfully, the album contains none):

The relentless drumming, handled by Odious Mortem's KC Howard, is nothing short of phenomenal -- and for once, does not go to waste -- while the bass guitar fights for attention. Aside from the wonderfully Cynical breather "The Enigmatic Form", you'll only notice it in flashes, but that type of neglect that is to be expected when residing behind the Great Wall of Riff. The only contentious bone in this record's skeleton lies in the vocal department. Bill Robinson's midrangy, coal-fired bellow certainly does its workmanlike best as an accompanying rhythm device. However, there's not a single vocal hook to be found here, and his expulsions are slightly buried in the mix. Of course, this is to make room for the six-string fireworks, within which the real hooks reside. As such, there are no true standout tracks, simply a monolithic album, chock-freaking-full of hummable, frenetic melodies. This isn't a Kataklysm record, folks.

No, this stands on its own as an elite death metal record that will appeal to a wide range of fans. The Unique Leader disciples will eat this shit up, as it goes toe-to-toe with the Severed Saviors out there in terms of sheer wrecking ability. The cerebral Atheist/Cynic geek will stand next to the pissed-off Immolation/Incantation jawgrinders in mutual respect. And the Mithras fan floating around out there will finally be satiated, because this is the finest DM offering since Behind The Shadows Lie Madness. Diminishing Between Worlds succeeds as not only a necessary reinvention (a point only underscored by the re-recording of "...And Time Begins" included herein), but also a measuring stick by which the veracity of brutal death metal albums shall be judged in the latter part of this decade. Is it perfect? Nope. But it's damn close.

Just buy the damn ticket and enjoy the ride.



idesofmarch's Avatar
idesofmarch | posted on 7/2009 | Reply
ive been listening to this a lot and i think this band is turning into my favorite DM band.
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
This is one of my favorite death metal albums, if not one of my favorite albums in general. The production is amazing, a little quiet but every instrument is very audible. KC Howard is a fucking monster on the kit. And I love Sotelo's leads. At times they sort of remind me of later-era Death solos. Also the bit just after "I am never ending" in 'Through Alchemy Bound Eternal' is brutal. I don't understand how people could compare this disfavourably to 'And Time Begins...' yes that album is awesome, blistering, brutal death metal - but the songs don't stick like the ones on here - and the drum sound, in fact the sound of the album as a whole, hardly compares. But this is of course all opinion. Which some people seem to forget.
SymX's Avatar
SymX | posted on 1/2009 | Reply
Can't get into this, each song I say didn't I just hear that? and the vox are terrible.
yevgeniy's Avatar
yevgeniy | posted on 1/2009 | Reply
Lyrics have a lot of Biblical themes. i dig it. Growls are still some of the deepest and most intense I've EVER heard. I absolutely love the new melodic solo-style incorporated into this. The tones of the guitars were outstanding and meaningful. Song writing also improved. This album has taking this band to another level which I didn't think existed in their genre
GestateReality's Avatar
GestateReality | posted on 1/2009 | Reply
sorry for the double post... hehe @ Anxiety Hangover: All of those reasons are OPINIONS not actual reasons why the album is shitty. The saying "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder" applies almost indefinitely to all forms of art. Especially music....just wanted to throw that out there. By the way Jordan, I really enjoyed your review of this album. I joined the site because of it.
GestateReality's Avatar
GestateReality | posted on 1/2009 | Reply
@ Anxiety Hangover:
vggls's Avatar
vggls | posted on 12/2008 | Reply
Very good record. I like it, but definitely not album of the year. It has its flaws. For example all tracks tend to sound the same and lacks agressiveness. Especially compared to the band that decrepit birth used to be.
Mr.Bojangles's Avatar
Mr.Bojangles | posted on 12/2008 | Reply
album of the year if you have cock in your ears. check out the new Arghoslent, Dead Congregation, Hail of Bullets, and Dismember if you want 4 albums way better than this wank fest
MetalFusion's Avatar
MetalFusion | posted on 12/2008 | Reply
Album of the year. Easily.
Klopek's Avatar
Klopek | posted on 9/2008 | Reply
@ Irukandji Yep, my disc is quiet too. Annoyingly so. I just downloaded a track and it's much louder! Anybody know if there was a bad pressing/recall?
Irukandji's Avatar
Irukandji | posted on 7/2008 | Reply
Hands down a top 5 album for this year. Seeing them live in Jan @ State Theater was awesome. They were so damn tight as a band. And kudos to UNique Leader for letting them pre-sell the record at the show. Nuclear Blast probably won't allow that. One prob: did anyone here notice the disk being a little quiet? I had to turn up my speakers abnormally high for this record. Might just be my disc.
CheezThief's Avatar
CheezThief | posted on 6/2008 | Reply
Beautiful music.
m4gg0t5's Avatar
m4gg0t5 | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
This album is in my top 10 this year for sure. Extremly heavy but with a lot of melodies. I can't ask any better. The drummer is a beast with Bass Drum and they're only 3 in the band. Man sound like a tons or bricks. I suggest to every death metal fans. give it a try at first you'll like it but not like it should. I had to listen to it 5-6 times to really realize the beauty of this thing. 5.5/5/6
Unknown Metalhead
acapiporla | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
A Gathering of Imaginations, Essence of Creation, Through Alchemy Bound Eternal. It doesn't get better than this. Pretty much every single track is a winner, awesome album, I'm diggin this motherfucker more and more after each listen.
chatham's Avatar
chatham | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
[joke] I couldn't agree more about Shadows in the Light. One of the finest albums of 1989, without question. [/joke]
The Devil Himself's Avatar
The Devil Himself | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Chatham: Shadows in the Light was released last year, 2007. Anxiety Hangover - you're entitled to your opinion. Sorry if if sounded like a dick (with the long winded comment) Not everyone is going to agree. I dont really think there are many death metal albums out there that sound like this nowadays, but then again, what do I know.
chatham's Avatar
chatham | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@Anxiety Hangover I couldn't agree more about Shadows in the Light. One of the finest albums of 1989, without question.
Unknown Metalhead
acapiporla | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@ Anxiety Hangover Dude, every song on DBW is... well, a song. It's a lot going on in them, but definitely they are fluent, cohesive and distinguishable from each other. Well-written. This album is full of emotion, it also has soul. And I think the production fits him like a glove...
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@The Devil Himself I listed the reasons why I don't like this album in my "long winded" post below. They are as follows (with a couple more after listening to the album a few more times): One, despite what some people think, death metal works better with actual songs; I'm not asking for verse chorus verse type stuff, but a little cohesion never hurts; just throwing a bunch of disparate riffs and tempos together does not make a song. Two, death metal, at least good death metal, has to have the right atmosphere, it should be dark and/or evil; for examples I would point to Onward to Golgotha, Into the Grave, Necroticism, Slowly We Rot, Rituals of Infinity, or Cross the Styx. There is much more to death metal than just riffs and blastbeats. Three, while the production is definitely not bad on Diminishing Between Worlds, I am of the school that thinks death metal should be heavy first and technical second. Even with the obvious bass guitar presence, I don't think this is a "heavy" album. Four, the solos, sure they're good, but they are not any different than what Trey Azagthoth has been doing for years in Morbid Angel. DB have not reinvented the death metal wheel or even given it a fresh coat of paint. I'm not asking for originality, which is difficult to come by at this point, but their own style might be nice. As for Immolation's Shadows in the Light, the reasons I like that mirror the reasons I dislike Diminishing Between Worlds. They actually write songs that are distinguishable from one another. The atmosphere as with every Immolation album, is palpably evil and dark, it not only sounds like death metal, it feels like death metal. Immolation are definitely masters of their instruments, especially guitarist Bob Vigna, but this in no way effects the heaviness of the album. And they definitely have their own sound, sure there are imitators, but no one sounds all that much like Immolation. Shadows in the Light is heavy, mean, evil, well-written death metal.
stncttr908's Avatar
stncttr908 | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@Haphazard I can see your point, but it's not like this band has a long-winded history. If this were their fourth or fifth full length your frustrations would be more understandable. I don't how you can classify "the real Decrepit Birth" when we've had so little exposure to their music so far and especially since their sound has progressed so much in a few years.
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
I only picked up And Time Begins a couple months ago (took me awhile) and I love it. I was kinda disappointed when I heard the newer stuff at first. When I bought And Time Begins, it was because I wanted some of the heaviest, guttural, technical, brutal death metal I could find. I got it, but then they changed their sound. That being said, it IS Decrepit Birth and I suppose it would get kind of old if they did And Time... Part2. I don't guess they could've gotten much more brutal than they did on that album, so what do you do? I guess you could compare it to the change Carcass made going from Symphonies of Sickness to Necroticism. Still definitely Carcass, but with a LOT more melody. And still great Classic death/grind albums at that. Hell, Death made the same transition. After my initial slight disappointment, what I've heard still kicks ass and I'll definitely be picking this up. Looking forward to the new Hate Eternal as well.
The Devil Himself's Avatar
The Devil Himself | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
This album sounds like Death on Crack (which is a good thing). I wish the vocals had a little more oomph ! Besides that, this album is gonna be up there with the best of 2008. One more gripe.... it took 5 years for this album to come out, even though some songs had been written for almost 2 years. I saw a long winded email about someone whos been listening to death metal for 20 years bitching about this album. Everyone is entitled to their opinion..... Not sure why he cant into this, yet he praises the new Immolation, which really isnt anything special at all.
Thalamus's Avatar
Thalamus | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@ Iron Maiden No I don't think most people think metal was "always about hard riffs....", thats the beauty about metal - its mutifaceted. I don't need to go to a history class, i enjoy old-school rock, blues, thrash - whatever. I also like heavy-as-fuck death metal aswell and when it sounds good, fucking nice one. If you don't like death metal - don't listen to it, but don't asume that if someone likes it they don't know metal - thats just dumb. Sometimes i want melody, sometimes not! Sometimes I want burgers and sometimes I like a nice Paté. Diversity bud, diversity.
Iron Maiden's Avatar
Iron Maiden | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Just what is the problem with melodic anyway? Do some of you really think metal was always about hard riffs and a bunch of idiots growling and screaming? If there was a metal history class, I would suggest some of you would be the first to attend.
Haphazard's Avatar
Haphazard | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
What happened here?!? They ditched what put them on the map in the first place and replaced it with melodick lead overkill. A little is tolerable but not and entire pack of sweet tarts and definitely NOT in a Decrepit Birth album. This is not the real Decrepit Birth and it is definitely not brutal death metal. Beyond disappointing.
Kill_Traitors's Avatar
Kill_Traitors | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Buying this tonight!
Thalamus's Avatar
Thalamus | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@ Mr.2 I agree with you about the bass in the mix. I think its nicely balanced and i'm coming at it as a bass player. Maybe i'm just more sensitive to hearing it or am listening out for it ... whatever, it's there, and there is some good playing to boot. I think its a killer album, I see the Mithras comparisions. They're different albums - both very strong. I must say I'm a big death metal fan, though i've only gotten back into keeping up with the seen in the last 2 years (for a few years it seemed there was nothing happening and I was listenig to other shit). I'd not heard of these lads and i'm glad I read that review - killer ablum. Good honest, interesting death. Plain and simple.
Mr. 2's Avatar
Mr. 2 | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Wow, I only heard the songs posted on their myspace page, but from that small sample, it does seem like DB made a giant leap in songcraft. The reviewer noted that the bass is barely heard... I have to disagree. Maybe I'm just too used to the bass being buried in the mix by most dm bands, but the bass seems nicely set in the mix on the new songs on their myspace page. In fact, I could hear some very impressive bass work happening!
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@ Iron Maiden Hey, man, I got my copy of Politics of Ecstacy sitting right next to my copy of ...And Time Begins. I enjoy the hell out of both of them! Of course my local record store didn't have this, so looks like I'll be heading over to Amazon.
Unknown Metalhead
acapiporla | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
I understand the Mithras comparisons, but this album is, IMO, waaaay better than Between... The production is better, by far. The songwritting is killer, fluent, technical and emotional... and the tandem Matt/KC is flawless in execution. Uhm, about KC... the drumming displayed here blows Mithras away. Matt has to be one of the most (if not THE most) talented songwritters/players in the genre, and the chemistry between him and KC is perfect.
Fractal_Mortality's Avatar
Fractal_Mortality | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Excellent, excellent album.
Unknown Metalhead
sunshinehappykitten | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
hmm...i might have to check this out. thianks reviewer
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Great review, Rev. Great album, too. Great way to start off 2008.
IronMaiden's Avatar
IronMaiden | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Just like Between the Buried and Me. What a great band. What a crappy voice.
IronMaiden's Avatar
IronMaiden | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Whatever. I can't believe the orgasms over this crap. Yet another death album with growling vocals. What is going on with metal? Where is my freaking Slough Feg? Or my Nevermore?
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
@ Anxiety Hangover: I share those EXACT feelings about many of the brutal/tech bands out there, but I firmly believe that this album is head-and-shoulders above most of the Neurotic and UL releases out there. Other than your opinion on this album, you have some damn good taste in music. ;) @ shroudofimpurity: Thanks for stopping by and checking out the site...and for dropping this killer album. I'm looking forward to your set in St. Paul on the 9th. Cheers.
Red's Avatar
Red | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
I got this via mailorder about three weeks ago and having spent alot of time with it I must say that it deserves a 666 rating. Whether you like this album is obviously a matter of opinion, but I don't know if anyone can deny the amazing jump in musicianship from thier last album to this (maybe it's just me but I thought And Time Begins was boring/lackluster). With this release, Decrepit Birth have set the bar high for themselves for sure!!!!!
rat's Avatar
rat | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Wow Jordan, I hope the album holds up to this review! I'm pumped for this one.
endless yeti's Avatar
endless yeti | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
your comparisons are exactly what i thought when i listened to this the first time. death with some mithras-ish-ness in there but still maintaining the feeling from their debut. amazing album to start out the year with.
persecution's Avatar
persecution | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
"in the living doorway" i mean. no drinking before 6 pm anymore.
persecution's Avatar
persecution | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
hey matt, i dunno if this what you were going for, but there is a riff in there that reminds me of "spirit crusher" momentarily. anyway, i believe there is a lot of good stuff in here, a little psycroptic, a little quo vadis. definitely my thing. great album (although i can understand why a lifer like anxiety hangover might disagree)
Unknown Metalhead
shroudofimpurity | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Hey, thanks for the killer review!! This is Matt by the way. So, this album is all about writing music that I wanted to hear... something that's actually fun for me to crank up loud in my car. Its also about pure emotion, a natural progression if you will. I can hear where the last dude(Anxiety Hangover) is coming from. But all I can say is that every note was written with nothing but pure and honest emotion. I've been through a lot these past couple years, and this is all a reflection of that. So I'm very happy to give you all this album.. ENYOY! or don't! haha...
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
2009 is the twentieth anniversary of the year I started listening to death metal and unlike some other fans, I never jettisoned death metal for other newer, better styles. I started with Obituary and Morbid Angel, and over the years have gained an appreciation for just about every death metal variation out there (I still listen to Obscura, Unquestionable Presence, None So Vile and Human on a regular basis), and there are some great new death metal bands out there, but Decrepit Birth is not one of them. Sure it has the requisite growls, blast beats and riffs of death metal, but that's about it; otherwise this is the same tired brutal tech crap that relies on listeners being too awed with the instrumental prowess to notice they have zero songwriting ability and zero ability to invoke the atmosphere that makes death metal more than just riffs and growls. There is a sterility to this record that seems to me to be at odds with death metal. For my money there have been many better death metal albums released in the last few years. I'll take Gorefest - Rise to Ruin, Slugathor - Circle of Death, Blaspherian - Allegiance to the Will of Damnation, Immolation - Shadows in the Light, Hate Eternal - I, Monarch, or a host of others over Decrepit Birth any day of the week. I think Diminishing Between Worlds is a poor excuse for good death metal.
Rhino's Avatar
Rhino | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
good review bro. I will checking this out.
Yersinia Pestyler's Avatar
Yersinia Pestyler | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
i honestly had no interest in hearing this until readin this review. if it is 3/4 as good as i'm picturing it in my head i'll love the shit out of it.
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
This one got me sleeping half way through. Good production and musicianship, your everyday Death Metal songwriting.. nothing impressive. I must be sick of Death Metal or something, since the last Suffocation, there has been zero album that got me saying "Holy shit I need to buy this" ..
Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Wow, Beneath The Massacre didn't even remotely pop into my head while listening to it, other than both bands sing, use guitars, bass, and "some" drums. This album is abso-fucking-loutely disgustingly good. I can't even put it into words. 6/5.5/6 from me.
Unknown Metalhead
unbeliever | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
a bit too wanky for my tastes..
jbo52988's Avatar
jbo52988 | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Did anybody else notice this album sounding a little bit like Beneath The Massacre? I don't wanna compare DB to BTM but I noticed some similarities between the two
stncttr908's Avatar
stncttr908 | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Amazing album. I don't throw around perfect scores often, but this is a straight 6/6/6 for me. If I had to compromise I might knock production down to a 5.5, but that would be considered nitpicking given the overall quality of the album. The last paragraph sums it up perfectly - this is a death metal record for death metal fans of all types (plus bonus points for the Mithras praise, since I was reminded of them upon hearing this).
chatham's Avatar
chatham | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Thanks for the review. I had to special order this, and I can't wait to pick it up Friday.
erikt@metalreview's Avatar
erikt@metalreview | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Definite 6/6/6 IMHO.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
The samples I heard definitely had the Mithras "vibe" or at least sound to it I must admit. This feels just like how the last Mithras was for me, I should like it, I know the music is fantastic, but the mechanical nature of the band just doesn't register with me. Guess I'm sticking with Immolation.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Well this sounds tasty.
Unknown Metalhead
pichabrava | posted on 1/2008 | Reply
Songwritting is subjective, but I don't understand anything below a 6 in production and another 6 in musicianship. This is, IMO, the best DM release in years and, consequently, a crystal clear 6/6/6. So many riffs/leads/solos/drum patterns/entire compositions I absolutely love in here.