Album Review

Score 8.1
Written by Jason Jordan
Published on 12/2/2007
If technical, instrumental metal is your thing, then look no further than Texan trio Blotted Science. And if you’ve read reviews of The Machinations of Dementia, and/or are familiar with the band already, you know that it features absolutely phenomenal musicianship from the likes of guitarist Ron Jarzombek (Spastic Ink, Watchtower), bassist Alex Webster (Cannibal Corpse, Hate Eternal), and Charlie Zeleny (Behold…the Arctopus, Jordan Rudess). Though it’s at least semi-accessible, it also seems to cater to musicians or listeners who simply enjoy basking in jaw-dropping, mind-bending musicianship.

Yes, at close to an hour in length, The Machinations of Dementia is a dense, intricate ball of wax in line with what the threesome have released with their respective primary units, though groups such as Canvas Solaris, Dysrhythmia, Scale the Summit, and many more prove slightly less taxing by requiring less concentration to fully grasp their songs. Despite the relation of the song titles to each other, which refer to medical conditions/terminology, the songs themselves are varied enough that they don’t blend together, while most of them do call for one’s undivided attention to comprehend exactly what’s transpiring. Still, it’d be nice if Blotted Science added more flavor to the mix a la Canvas Solaris. Regardless, jumpy opener “Synaptic Plasticity” shifts more than overhead luggage during a plane crash, though it settles into a solid groove at the 1:41 minute mark prior to taking flight once again. Naturally, guitar and bass leads punctuate the soundscape, in addition to nimble drum fills, like in “Laser Lobotomy” and numerous others. Also, for better or worse, it’s nearly impossible to not compare portions of “Brain Fingerprinting,” “Activation Synthesis Theory,” and “Night Terror” to instrumental sections from the past few Dream Theater and Liquid Tension Experiment albums. However, the six-part “Activation Synthesis Theory” is different insofar as it clocks in at over eight minutes, whereas its peers range from 1:11 (“R.E.M.”) to 5:55 (“Synaptic Plasticity”), with plenty falling in between. At times aligned with progressive, death, and thrash metal, Blotted Science do indeed keep the listener on their toes, and have a sufficient amount of groove to tie it all together.

Even though it’s a tad too long at 57 minutes – there’s also the fact that the bass drums could use more oomph – The Machinations of Dementia is entertaining nonetheless. The replay value is questionable, but for what it’s worth, Blotted Science have crafted a complex, knotty record that is surprisingly approachable and more user-friendly than initially thought. It won’t change your perception of instrumental metal, as the basic premise remains the same, but it’s still one of the more intriguing albums of its kind.



GDubya's Avatar
GDubya | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
Holy Bump! Adler couldn't play any of this stuff. That is why Zeleny is on it.
Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 5/2011 | Reply
This album is actually the best album ever. buy it
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
JB: yeah it would've been really interesting to hear him on this. Dude is actually a great drummer, and way too good for the kind of b.s. Lamb Of God is putting out nowadays. Roddy preceded him, but I personally thought his style would be a bit too one-track for this band. Zeleny is/was a great choice though so, no biggie. *shrug*
Unknown Metalhead
Logan | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
I can't wait to listen to this one !!
Unknown Metalhead
SunnyvaleTrash | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
perfect review
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Chris Adler was originally supposed to play drums on this. I was excited to hear Webster and Adler on the same record. Still, sounds pretty good.
Unknown Metalhead
Tyler Wagnon | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
this sounds right up my alley, yet i'd never heard of this band before this. more thoughts once i actually listen to it.
rat's Avatar
rat | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
This album is great, especially on X.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
About time on this review! ;P I'd been excited about this from the moment I read about it, and I'm happy to say that it completely delivers. Technical, but the riffs seem to stick quite easily (at least for me), so it's got the "hummability" factor going for it. This cd is easily Top 5 for the year and a good candidate for best. Also, I completely agree with greigoroth about the Meshuggah influence. Some of the riffs scream Meshuggah, which only makes me enjoy them more :)
greigoroth's Avatar
greigoroth | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Okay, I am basing this off myspace, but damn! This is a huge record! I can't believe no-one mentioned the meshuggah influence - the bass in EEG Tracings sounds very meshuggah-ish at times, both tonally and rhythmically. It is so nice to be able to hear Alex Webster clearly - I think he is one of the best basists going round and he doesn't get nearly enough cred for it. Also want to throw in my 2 cents and say that it really sounds like a band playing, rather than 3 virtuoso dudes sitting in a studio doing whatever virtuosos do in studios. If ya get my drift.
Unknown Metalhead
Martinator | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Album of the year for me! I don't really see the Dream Theater comparison, aside from being instrumental - there's a lot more going on here, and if you like your metal really technical and progressive, I don't think you can go wrong buying this. Props to Ron, Alex, and Charlie!
Desperado's Avatar
Desperado | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
I enjoy this cd.I respect the musicians too,very talented guys.I don't listen to this much not because I can't handle it,its because Im afraid I'll overdoit.Stuff like this doesn't come by in droves,and I like to bounce around what I listen too.Very rarely will I ever repeat something.Good stuff though.
Unknown Metalhead
Elad | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
still prefer spastic ink, gordian knot or watchtower work as opposed to this. It's really just way too much and too taxing on the head to take it all in. I tip my hat to their tremendous effort and work but they really over did it.
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Jarzombek and Webster are masters at what they do, period. Excellent album. Though, as with all Ron's work, I can only listen to his stuff in small dose. It's not negative, just that there's a lot going on in what he does.
Unknown Metalhead
deathtoemo_420 | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
theses guys are tighter than a virgins vagina they are absolutly men among boys