Album Review

Score 7.9
Written by Dave Pirtle
Published on 11/26/2007
At the beginning of most album reviews, we writers normally like to include a brief history lesson, or perhaps a whimsical anecdote or thoughtful musing about the artist. Frankly though, Helloween has way too much history to cover in a single paragraph, and I have no anecdotes or even musings about the German speed metal pioneers turned power metal warriors. Well, there was the time when two of my radio colleagues refused to play Sepultura’s double-live Under a Pale Grey Sky (or was it Prophecy by Soulfly?) because Max Cavalera had talked shit about Helloween. That’s pretty indicative of the passion that their fans have, though. They’ll admit when Helloween puts out a poor album, but don’t you ever take their name in vain. Following the lukewarm reception of the highly-anticipated but perhaps a decade-too-late Keeper of the Seven Keys – The Legacy, it will be interesting to see how fans and critics respond to Gambling With the Devil. In my opinion, it is a worthy addition to their storied discography.

The tracks here run the usual gamut of Helloween material. There are the fast and heavy tracks like “Kill It,” “The Saints,” “Dreambound,” “Paint a New World,” and “The Bells of the Seven Hells,” the latter two representing the best of this set. Along the way, we also get a few of those “not-quite-ballads” that they like to do, in the form of “As Long As I Fall” and “Fallen to Pieces.” These are actually damn good in their own right, with the latter using orchestral elements to power its chorus along with a well-delivered vocal line. Then there are a few tracks that fall somewhere in between. The one glaring exception – the sore thumb; the black sheep, if you will – is “Can Do It.” I’m sure this was written with the best intentions as a driving, upbeat anthem, but it ends up sounding more like something you might hear at one of those middle-school motivational assemblies, as lights flash and pictures of youth succeeding at things they do are projected onto a screen. It may be the most bubblegum thing they’ve recorded since “Heavy Metal Hamsters,” but it is also only a minor blemish on an otherwise solid album.

Gambling With the Devil should please the Helloween faithful, starting with it’s non-embarrassing album title (do YOU know anybody that could say “Rabbit Don’t Come Easy” with a straight face?), on through a set of songs that will latch immediately onto your brain, both the memory bank and the nerve center that controls all of the big rock moves (horns, headbanging, pumping fists, air guitar). The next time some young kid in a Dragonforce shirt tells you they’re the greatest band ever, whip a little Helloween on ‘em - that oughta put the little bastard in his place.



Mr_Arch's Avatar
Mr_Arch | posted on 12/2008 | Reply
This album is a killer one!! never left my ipod list for months now and it's still playing!!
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Heavy Metal Hampsters---Wow, that gets me every time. Holy fucking gayfest.
jhwrathchild's Avatar
jhwrathchild | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Finally Helloween has released the album they should have put out after Keeper Part 2. After nearly two decades of sub par albums they unleash this massive affair of metal righteousness. I am truly a believer in Helloween once again. Kai Hansen beware, the 'ween are back!
Dismal Euphony's Avatar
Dismal Euphony | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
these guys couldn't hold a candle to Skillet.
Unknown Metalhead
steel prophet | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
The nick" Steel prophet "has nothing to do which the band,witch i think is a fine band.Lightyears better than any pathetic "extreme" band.
Unknown Metalhead
Steel Prophet= | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Only horrible noise
Unknown Metalhead
The Great Deceiver | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Damn, I kinda forgot about these guys after Keeper - Legacy. That album had a couple decent tracks, but man did they fall short. This one, on the other hand, sounds like a good time like Better Than Raw and Rabbit. I'm not listening to newer Helloween to find traces of Walls of Jericho (their best) but rather to bang my head and pump my fist to some solid melodic power and I'll be all over this disc like a bum on a sandwich.
Unknown Metalhead
steel prophet | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
Another good exemple of what metal really is.This album is awesome.Death metal ,black metal, metalcore- only horrible noise.
James's Avatar
James | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
I'm eighteen and I've enjoyed Helloween for years...
luke's Avatar
luke | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
im only twenty five and this is by far the best album since master of the rings, nowhere near keeper one and 2 but great . Better than raw was good too.
Unknown Metalhead
... | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
This is an awesome album, probably the best since the original Keepers for me. I`m actually enjoying this sort of old school metal more than anything else nowadays...it`s nice to hear some melody and decent vocals for a change.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
I must admit, I too am a metal grandpa. I have the first two Keeper albums on tape. Back then they weren't too bad, but now I just can't stand this type of metal anymore. I got rid of my mullet quite some time ago.
Unknown Metalhead
Necro Molester | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
This band makes Opeth sound like fun!
Unknown Metalhead
Lee's Grandson | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
Grandpa come on its time to change your depends.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
I said, I didn't mean to offend. Sorry Lee-what do you think of Helloween? Do you think they kick ass? Stupid, dumb fuck kid metal is whatever Jimb listens to.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
Granpa metal? So what is "stupid, dumb fuck kid" metal?
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
Yuck. This is fucking grandpa metal. Heavy Metal Hampsters? For real? This shit is corny. Ok, I'm sorry-don't mean to offend anyone. Heavy Metal Hampsters? Jeesh. (sorry, I'm from Wisconsin)
Unknown Metalhead
John | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
What I loved this album showed the range of material that this band can create and it is an awesome comeback after keeper 3 which the 2nd disc was alright...and i can say rabbit don't come easy.....all you need to do is ask the duck.....watch the helloween video discography dvd special features to get that part.......give it a 6/5.5/6
Ryan's Avatar
Ryan | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
My first Helloween album......... I heard KIll It on the Metal Injection podcast and it sounded awesome so I immediately got this album.......it's great And I have a Dragonforce shirt........but Helloween >>>> Dragonforce
Unknown Metalhead
Rino | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
6/6/6
James's Avatar
James | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
Good review DP, I like Helloween so I'll check this out "but it ends up sounding more like something you might hear at one of those middle-school motivational assemblies, as lights flash and pictures of youth succeeding at things they do are projected onto a screen." hahahaha!!!!!
mak28's Avatar
mak28 | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
Their best album ever. Seriously. I've loved most everything the band has done with the exception of Chameleon. I love the Kiske material, the Deris material and the legendary Walls of Jericho. Yeah, the Keeper albums (the original 2) are undeniable classics but the modern sound the band has had since Master of the Rings has long been my favorite. For many years now The Time of the Oath was my favorite but Gambling has usurped it. Adding the two speedy bonus tracks to the track list put it over the top. Easily the fastest Helloween album since Keeper II with no ballads. The poppy As Long As I Fall, while good is the only weaker moment. One of my favorite bands back at the top of their game and it's great to hear! Anyone who enjoys the Deris era should love this. If you haven't, avoid as always.