Album Review

Score 6.9
Written by Gregory Bradley
Published on 4/14/2003
Anthrax’s highly anticipated new album has finally graced my ears. Some are hailing it as the great return to form, whilst others are condemning Anthrax to a fate worse than their namesake would inflict on a human being. I lie somewhere in the middle, more towards the positive. There is nothing bad about “We’ve Come For You All”, but it’s not the so-called return to form that many have claimed it to be. I don’t know if I’d call it “classic Anthrax”, but it is definitely an acceptable new release from one of the grandfathers of thrash. One thing that is true about older bands is that many times they tend to head towards the hard-rock side of metal than their original direction. This is somewhat true of “We’ve Come For You All”; there are songs that give me a distinct hard-rock vibe, namely the slower ones like “Safe Home” and “Cadillac Rock Box”. I kind of like the sound though, especially on “Cadillac Rock Box”, it’s such a western sound. There are some very metal songs though, like the opener, “What Doesn’t Die”, and “Black Dahlia”, which actually has a blast beat! One of the great things about Anthrax is that they have such a distinct sound, which can only be described as undeniably American. In the midst of all the Norwegian black metal, the Swedish death metal, and the German thrash, it’s kind of refreshing to hear some good ol’ American metal. Anthrax is as American as you can get. The other great thing about Anthrax- as is clearly evident on this album – is the fact that Scott Ian is arguably the best rhythm guitarist in existence. Every ‘Thrax song has a sweet rhythm, masterfully played by the great Scott. Few things are greater than a kick-ass beat in metal. It seems like people’s main gripe with new Anthrax is singer John Bush. This I do not understand. I think Bush fits the band perfectly, he has a great voice. So what’s the big deal? I guess it’s the same deal as with Blaze Bayley and Iron Maiden. Just because he wasn’t Dickinson, he was shunned. Same for Bush, just because he isn’t Belladonna, he too is shunned. I don’t get it. Anyway, enough ranting. The new Anthrax is more than decent, but less than masterful. It definitely has its moments, and if you missed both “Stomp 442” and “Vol. 8”, then you might as well check out what Anthrax is about these days. Also if you hated those 2 albums, you might wanna give this one a chance. But if you’re a die-hard Belladonna fan, you can both skip this album and kiss my ass. Wrathchild’s Choice Cuts: Refuse To Be Denied ~ I love the beat, great song Black Dahlia ~ Interesting, very \m/etal



themetalisgood's Avatar
themetalisgood | posted on 4/2009 | Reply
Bush is a good singer but i prefer him in Armored Saint, also there is a huge difference in the songwriting between anthrax in the island years and when the John Bush joined. Its not a big deal but Anthrax lost their thrash a bit seems how they are considered to be in one of the thrash 4.
Unknown Metalhead
Swiss Cheese | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
huhuhuhuhuhuh............not EVEN gonna say anything
Unknown Metalhead
oi 'jon' | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
shut the fuck up, this album has a sound of its own, no way is it commercial. So bands aren't allowed to change from their previous albums, and if they do they are 'lame'?. retard.
Unknown Metalhead
Jon | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
What in the fuck happened? I don't get it! These thrash metal greats producing this album? It sounds like another nu metal band or some other mainstream crap. With lame slow simple riffs and simple unskilled drumming. Don't get me wrong their other older albums rule but this one just went in the bin. Too mainstream and unskilled, they did this one simply for the money.
Unknown Metalhead
deadbydawn | posted on 6/2004 | Reply
some good vocals, but it didn't really interest me as most of there other stuff did... pass
Unknown Metalhead
chuckles | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
this is a really good band i was surprised. 5 outta 6
Unknown Metalhead
Whoreacle | posted on 4/2004 | Reply
This is a fucking great album... its really pure fucking metal. Oh and mettalmann, it was #4 on my top 10 of 2003 also. I think this may actually be my favorite anthrax album.
Unknown Metalhead
Fuzzbastard | posted on 12/2003 | Reply
Anthrax blows since they got rid of Belladonna. Metallica blows since Justice. If you want to blame anyone for the fact that you don't like Anthrax anymore, Scott Ian isn't really the one to go after - Charlie Benante actually wrote more guitars than any other nenber of the band until after Belladonna was ousted, blame him for letting the ther guys write. Thank you. Listen to Testament for REAL thrash, you homos.
Mettalmann's Avatar
Mettalmann | posted on 12/2003 | Reply
Hey get this CD...if you like Volume 8 you'll lov ethis..it's #4 on my top 10 2003!!! GET IT
Unknown Metalhead
houde666 | posted on 8/2003 | Reply
Compared to St.Anger it sucks big time. 2 or 3 good songs on it. Don't waste your money on this one. And don't get me wrong, i'm a big fan of Anthrax but this one... no thanks.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim | posted on 5/2003 | Reply
Anthrax? never heard any of their shit, to me sounds like a fucking poofta band, listen to AmetallicA you dicks, they are the best.
Unknown Metalhead
mentalmeltdown | posted on 5/2003 | Reply
...and your first statement is that you don't like Anthrax, you cum-guzzling fag. Anthrax are the rulers of Metal and if you don't agree, go listen to St.Anger you pussy.
Unknown Metalhead
T-bone | posted on 4/2003 | Reply
If you don't like Anthrax - ..l.. they rock - are rock!! Who else has music like them - especially nowadays. If you don;t like 'em , go listen to your bubble gum Sum 142, Blink 182 FAGGOT SHIT!! and by the way FU. If you do like them __ ROCK IT. OH YEAH if u can do better -- go out, get a record deal, and Let me see u fuks!
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 4/2003 | Reply
A band doesn't make music that you like anymore so all of sudden the guitarist is a "cunt". How long did you sit there and conjur up that response before actually posting it? I mean that was incredibly intelligent. Here let me sink down to your level for a moment.....why don't you put the gun in your mouth and pull the trigger. The world would be much better off. Next time just state why you don't like the album and save the Jr. High drivel for the Relapse board you fucking numbskull.
Unknown Metalhead
Macabre | posted on 4/2003 | Reply
Fuck Scott Ian, they don't bring the noise like they used to. It was more interesting when they wrote about wanting some milk!
Unknown Metalhead
David | posted on 4/2003 | Reply
On the subject of John Bush I think the much overlooked album Symbol of Salvation contains his finest work. Great vocals and great lyrics. Also the most enjoyable, not necessarily the most technical drum solo I have ever seen live was in Sydney Australia seeing Anthrax for their time tour. simply brilliant . A true metal moment.