Album Review

Score 8.6
Written by Jon Eardley
Published on 4/25/2007
There was a thread posted recently on the MetalReview.com forum that talked about getting “burnt out on metal”…basically, does it happen to you, and if so how do you cope? It was a very interesting little read, and the consensus was that indeed “yes”, most listeners of extreme music do get tired of the heavy from time to time and simply need a break of sorts. Enter Porcupine Tree – one of the bands that I always feel comfortable turning to in times of 'metal burnout syndrome', and if you haven’t caught wind of the band yet during your music listening tenure, then it is my hope that after reading this review (or Dave Pirtle’s splendid review of Deadwing, the band’s prior release) that you will use the music this band competently writes and effortlessly plays to your advantage during those times of metal exhaustion.

For those unfamiliar with the band, main man Steven Wilson and company play an easier listening progressive rock style coupled with mild experimentation in ambience and a strong 70’s psychedelic influence. But that hardly covers it all because there is so much tossed into the “melting pot”, as Wilson calls it. The band’s previous album, the aforementioned Deadwing, even saw the band flirt with a more metal edge in a couple of songs, which was probably a result of Wilson having worked with Swedish metal darlings Opeth on the Blackwater Park, Deliverance and Damnation sessions. While In Absentia and Deadwing are arguably the band’s most prized and fully fleshed out recordings – thanks in part to more folks becoming more familiar with the group – Fear of a Blank Planet is a return to the band’s middle, darker era that saw them find their stride with a trilogy of releases that might go down as the band’s best work ever – the eerily addicting Signify, the catchier and more straight-forward Stupid Dream, and the drearily dismal vibe on the all-out jam that was Lightbulb Sun, my personal favorite.

The album’s title track gets things going with a little acoustic intro followed by a solid n’ rocky drum beat that drives it most of the way, and the slower section about midway through the track sets up the first of a few metal-ish moments that pepper the record. If you’re into excellently written lyrics – somewhat of a lost art these days – you’ll love what Wilson and company have come up with. As I stated, this is some of the darker material that the band has offered up in years, and the lyrics match the gloomy theme perfectly. "My Ashes" is a slower piece that focuses more on the lyrical message than the song itself, as Wilson tells a story of the little boy that literally gets fucked up by his parents and literally struggles to carry on – indeed a very, very common scenario. King Crimson’s Robert Fripp and legendary Rush guitarist Alex Lifeson each make a guest appearance, with the latter’s guitar solo at the 4:00 mark of "Anesthetize" adding a welcome touch. The song covers a myriad of different emotions ranging from softly strummed hues to an all out metal assault toward the middle of the seventeen minute song. The rolling double bass coupled with thunderous tom fills almost knocked me on my ass the first time I’d heard the track. "Sentimental" follows with its piano driven intro that evolves into a beautiful chorus that almost brings hope to the album's sad nature, but it's still murky enough to keep the box of tissues within reach, and "Way Out of Here" is a slowly building track that shows the band’s expertise at the use of dynamics as it rises to peaks of agonizing emotion and falls just as hard. Closer "Sleep Together" is yet another song that starts out softly and has a string arrangement around the 6:00 point that reeks of climactic proportions and ends the album extremely strong. I'm sure it's just me but that part of the song brings me back to my youth and reminds me of The Beatles' legendary song "I Am the Walrus" each time I hear it.

Bottom line: Porcupine Tree simply do not disappoint, and the group is as consistent as any band that composes and records music. Period! With a lengthy catalog of stellar releases to back up that statement, I encourage any and all fans of good music to seek out the mesmerizing and beautiful sounds this band explores and ultimately delivers. If this will be your first taste of the Porcupine Tree experience there’s no doubt you’ll be aching for more before the midway point of the first listen to this record. While this may not be the band’s best work, there’s no arguing that the group is worthy of being among the other bands in your catalog, metal or otherwise, and the perfect remedy for 'metal burnout syndrome'.



thetrooper's Avatar
thetrooper | posted on 2/2011 | Reply
i've had the title track of this disc stuck in my head for 2 weeks straight. great stuff
Mr_Arch's Avatar
Mr_Arch | posted on 12/2008 | Reply
Just Great!!! First Listen to this album Prog-rocked my brains out...
onthedownlow's Avatar
onthedownlow | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Hmm. Its okay, but its very obviously a B-Sides and Remix EP of 'Fear..'. Track one is an intro-esque instrumental, which fits fairly well, and is pleasant enough; tracks 2 and 4 have sections that you'll recognise from 'Fear..', and work fairly well, and track 3 is a new track (I think) which is again, not too bad, but then then not too amazing either. Tone is very much like In Absentia.
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
The Nil Recurring EP comes out tomorrow (Feb. 19) in the states. Can't wait to hear it.
onthedownlow's Avatar
onthedownlow | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Soon to be released (here in the UK anyways, dont know about the US) will be an E.P made up of B-Sides from this album. ..just FYI really.
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 10/2007 | Reply
This is my album of the year, hands down. And if you don't consider this metal, then this is better than any metal album I've heard this year. This is a triple 6, metal or not.
Jishwa's Avatar
Jishwa | posted on 10/2007 | Reply
Porcupine Tree is fantastic.
yas666eer's Avatar
yas666eer | posted on 10/2007 | Reply
true review... listening to it and its great
powerade's Avatar
powerade | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
in australia this album has an opeth sticker on it. "porcupine tree is easy my favourite current band - michael akerfeldt". As for the album, it's worth of 5's across the board. And that's pretty damn good in my book.
onthedownlow's Avatar
onthedownlow | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
Thanks. Just to stress again, I like this album musically. I really dont have any love for the lyrics on some tracks (read most of them), but otherwise a very respectable release. Its a pretty cool chillout album if youre a bit too worn for that latest Pig Destroyer album or somesuch.
Unknown Metalhead
cageofman | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
of course its a concept album. Its not written from steven wilsons point of view either, he has written from the point of view of a teenager in todays society. You are not the only one who has had problems dealing with the concept for this album. I for one dont mind it too much. (the concept that is)I think the lyrics are pretty cool actually, agreed a bit tiresome after a while, but its the concept of the whole album so you know, what do you expect. I love this album. Not as much as the last 2 though...
onthedownlow's Avatar
onthedownlow | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
..After reading this review, Im convinced I must have missed the point of something somewhere along the way; are the lyrics from this album supposed to be sardonic, yes? I really hope they are. Or maybe its a concept album of some description, and Ive not picked up on it somewhere.. again, hopefully so. Because if not..? They're fucking awful. Ive never been so turned off by the lyrics in a song; normally, I dont really care what anyone is singing about with bands, but they're so angsty and whiny that I just cant hack it on this. And the worst thing is that they're repeated on tracks one, three and four - literally some parts are nearly exactly the same, with Wilson singing about malls, commercialism and plastic culture, and how he doesnt like his parents. Seriously, you just sit there in absolute bewilderment and wonder if there is a new pre-pubescent emokid who just broke up with his girlfriend on vocals. Which is a shame, because the music is pretty good, and the vocals are also extremely well done. The guy can obviously sing - and on past albums, Ive had no problem with them. So am I missing something? No-one else seems to have noticed..
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
This one definitely tops Deadwing in my opinion, just the flow and the concept album effect just makes it much more appealing to me. Each song is solid but "Sleep Together" and "Anesthetize" are easily considered high calibre songs. Lovin' it!
DeathHead's Avatar
DeathHead | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
Excellence from PT once again. These guys have never disappointed me. Right now they're one of my favorite bands in any genre. "Anesthetize" is one of the best tunes they've ever written (which is saying a lot), and there's not a bad track on the album. I'd put this up there with In Absentia, Lightbulb Sun and Signify, my personal favorite PT recordings. Steven Wilson is on a serious roll between PT and Blackfield. 6/5.5/5.5
Unknown Metalhead
Del | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
Porcupine Tree when you're tired of metal!?? I mean they can be pretty heavy too. When i'm tired of metal i listen to Jazz, electronica or pop......
Unknown Metalhead
windowlicker | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
Porcupine tree continues to restore my faith and shows me that there is still great REAL music out there (outside of metal). Its fucking pure. Some of us have a wide range of listening pleasures. Another band who continues to restore my faith--JESU.
Unknown Metalhead
Jon w/MR | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
Settle down, Raven. I think there's only been one negative comment made here, probably by someone who hasn't even heard of the band let alone any of their music. You know they're great, I know they're great, and that's that. If other folks don't then who friggin' cares? It won't affect Wilson's ability to create music we enjoy.
Raven's Avatar
Raven | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
keep talking shit you fucking punks porcupine tree is a good olfashioned easy listening badass band
Unknown Metalhead
Adam C. | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
The band rocks, they always have. The album is great. Buy it if you haven't. Enough said. BTW, "Sleep Together" is my favorite song on here. I find myself humming it five hours after I've finished listening, seriously.
Unknown Metalhead
God of Judgement | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Behold Killer Duck - the ultimate musical authority for all of mankind. Such wisdom and spoken with such articulate intellect. Porcupine Tree is a good band.
Unknown Metalhead
Killer Duck | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
What kind of peice of shit listens to this sorry excuse of music?
Unknown Metalhead
The Great Deceiver | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
MW: Just referenced my ticket which has been safely tucked into my wallet for over a month now. They're playing the House of Blues, which is a great venue that you may or may not have had the opportunity to visit since it's sorta recent. I saw Opeth/Nevermore/Into Eternity there and the sound was great for every band so I'm fucking pumped. You know where Mayfield Heights is? That's where I lived for about 10 years. I guess I still do technically, I just inhabit Columbus for college now. Cleveland in the house.
Unknown Metalhead
SunnyvaleTrash | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
good band. Check out the DVD they recently put it, it's great.
Unknown Metalhead
Jimmy | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
As a hardcore PT fan, this album definitely DEFINITELY does not disappoint!!
Unknown Metalhead
Zack | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Gonna see them May 9th. Should be awesome!!
Unknown Metalhead
MW w/MR | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Great Deceiver: Shit yeah, dude. I've seen them live twice now, and they're great. Usually have a nice visual display in the backdrop as well. Very cool live band. And I lived in Cleveland for 13yrs! Where are they playing?
Unknown Metalhead
The Great Deceiver | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Sidenote: I'll be seeing them in about three weeks in Cleveland for the first time. The DVD they came out with recently blew me away and I'm expecting an incredible show. Anyone else hitting this tour?
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
this is a pretty significant record for PT- successfully combining elements from the older mellow eras and new heavy stuff. though deadwing had some fun singles, i think this may be more satisfying as a whole.
Unknown Metalhead
spicee | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Check out the giutar solo @ 4.00 on anthesteize.......sp? by Rush"s Alex......Wonderfully delicious
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
I reaaaaaaaaaally need to hear this.
Unknown Metalhead
Tunefreak | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Excellent Review of one of the most under the radar bands going... But not for very much longer!!!! If this band doesn't get your head banging (once in a while) you best check to see it it's still attached. Addictive, Monster Riffs and Drumming that will make any drummer take notice.
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
havent had time to listen yet, but just from skipping around, it sounds less 'heavy' [PT aren't metal, so i hesitate to use that word] than deadwing- meaning the title track/single isn't representative of the rest of the album. and i don't get why everyone likes 'Trains' - to me, it's a weaker song on my least favorite PT album. i am surprised that PT blew up- their shows always sell out in Boston. since listening from the lightbulb cycle, i never imagined they'd get to this point- pretty awesome! and they didn't even have to sell out \m/
RobotRuler's Avatar
RobotRuler | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Everytime I see this albums name I think of Public Enemy ... its one letter away from being "Fear of a Black Planet"
Adam's Avatar
Adam | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Took a few listens to get into but it has really grown on me. I probably had such high expectations after "Deadwing" and "In Absentia" that at first it seemed like a little bit of a let down, but it's gotten better with each listen. Probably doesn't have a standout track like "Piano Lessons" or "Trains" but it's a very consistent album that you can listen to from start to finish without any trouble. I don't think it's their strongest work, but it's still much better than most of the shit that get's released today. They aren't afraid to experiment a bit and, at least for Porcupine Tree, it pays off. It's definately worth a look. 6 / 5 / 5
Unknown Metalhead
CB | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
YourMom. You are a bitchfest. Save it for the sewing circle. I'm not offended that you dislike this and you are entitled to your opinion just like everybody else, But I completely diagree about this being superficial. I still listen to thier albums that came out 8 yrs ago and I am definitely schooled enough in music to not be fooled. Tell me what bands you think are the real deal, I'm sure you probably have better taste then you let on.
YourMom's Avatar
YourMom | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Incredibly boring and shallow, like most Porcupine Tree records. Pretty good the first time you listen to it, but then it exposes itself for what it really is: superficial pop rock that you won't listen to in 6 months. Amazing how this band has so many people fooled. Props to them for that, but not for their music.
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
I'm looking forward to get/hear this one. They never failed to please my ears in the past, I doubt they'll fail now.
Unknown Metalhead
jon | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
this one definitely is along the lines of the middle-era which noted above. i find that material more difficult to get into than the previous 2 releases, yet completely rewarding when i finally do get into it. this is no different...truly remarkable band, as they are prolific and never fail to write great albums. Awesome stuff. Though I thought they were a tad dry when i saw them open for Opeth on the "damnation" tour, they still were spot-on live, and steven wilson knows what he's doing. this is a great album.
Unknown Metalhead
bob | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
I love the title track and anesthetize. The rest of the album is forgettable, but it might be because those two songs are THAT good!
Unknown Metalhead
Zack | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Bought this album yesterday along with the new Dark Tranquility. This album is epic, a fine addition to the evergrowing discography of PT.
Unknown Metalhead
vag | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
What an amazing band. Bands like that one honour rock/metal with their presence.
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
i'm sure we don't all =only= listen to metal, it's covers the majority of our preference. anyway, i classify PT as one of the great bands of our time [along with Dark Tranquillity]. I randomly got Signify a long while ago [01-02?]- which, along with Lightbulb Sun and Sky Moves Sideways, are my favorites. Though they seem going for stuff that would be more dynamic in a live setting, I'm still eager to hear this album soon. The title track is very Deadwing-ish, though decent nevertheless.
Unknown Metalhead
The Great Deceiver | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Great review, I agree fully. This one is a pull back in direction from In Absentia and Deadwing and sounds alot like Lightbulb Sun with the heavier riffage of late. Anesthetize, for example, builds up from Lighbulb Sun-esque atmospheric jams to an almost death assault that caught me completely by surprise my first listen. And Fear of a Blank Planet really deserves multiple listens, like any PT album, for the full intended effect. I wouldn't quite say that it's for those 'burnt out on metal' however. In Absentia and Deadwing have a heaviness to them that is really quite metal. I'm not talking about sound directly as in riffs and tuning, but more along the lines of an atmospheric heaviness if that makes any sense. Great fucking record, it's really grown on me and continues to do so. Who knows this might beat out Deadwing for second in my PT favorites collection. In Absentia is still perfection though.
69dinner42's Avatar
69dinner42 | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
When I'm burned out on metal I throw on 50 cent
Unknown Metalhead
Jon w/MR | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Folks who enjoy this album, or any of the band's past releases, will also find enjoyment in the new Blackfield album. It's another project involving Steven Wilson that's a little bit more on the easy listening side, but it is highly recommended nevertheless.
DuPont's Avatar
DuPont | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
These guys aren't bad. Still, whenever I feeled burned out from metal I always seem to turn on a Richard Cheese album! I know, its on the other end of the spectrum but thats how it is.
Unknown Metalhead
GrindTylerCore | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
this band is sort of frustrating for me. they write some incredible songs (like "Trains" from In Absentia... one of the most beautiful songs of recent times), but then follow them with 3 or 4 snoozers (most of the rest of that album).
Satanic Dogslaughter's Avatar
Satanic Dogslaughter | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
I'm so GRIM and KVLT that I don't get burnt out by metal...metal gets burnt by me. This is why we have "Black Metal."
Unknown Metalhead
FucBush | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
The 17 minute track Anesthetize is absolutely amazing...I get a good King Crimson vibe here, too, for some reason....excellent album and great review, Jon.