Album Review

Score 8.3
Written by Jon Eardley
Published on 2/28/2007
Finland’s Swallow the Sun is a band that has done incredibly well to stake its claim as a serious contender within the beautifully depressing doom/death genre. Even though I thought their debut album – The Morning Never Came – was worlds better than 2005’s Ghosts of Loss, that follow up was still a solid enough outing that showed the strength and confidence of a band that plans on – and should very well be – making quality records for many years to come. Enter studio effort number three, which is irrefutably a far more consistent listen than its predecessor, and without a doubt puts the band back on track with the supreme songwriting displayed on their 2003 debut.

Hope is an album that seethes with the same mouth-watering ingredients that have been present on the band’s previous albums – effortless yet chunky riffs that pave the way for disheartening guitar melodies, somber atmospheric keys that paint the ideal dismal and murky background, and boisterous gutturals peppered ever so lightly with solemnly sung clean interludes (Katatonia's Jonas Renkse and Amorphis' Tomi Joutsen each make a guest vocal appearance). The clean vocals are much more prevalent than has been the case in the past, showing not only a vast improvement in range and smoother choice of melody, but also a searing sense of confidence and maturity in the overall delivery. Also more noticeable on the album are the attention grabbing choruses that are far catchier and more prominent here, as heard on songs like the serene "The Justice of Suffering", the single "Don’t Fall Asleep (Horror Pt. 2)" and the alarmingly tranquil "Too Cold for Tears". What some may call a slight attempt at writing more digestible songs for the sake of gaining a broader fan base, I simply call more cohesive songwriting and an ability to write more noteworthy hooks, yet the band still manages to retain their integrity as a group. While songs like the opening title track and "The Empty Skies" lurch and mope along blissfully, other tracks like the slightly up tempo "These Hours of Despair" and the luminous "No Light, No Hope" and "Doomed to Walk the Earth" flourish with riffs of deepened girth sprinkled with some of the gravest melodies I’ve heard from the group.

All in all, if I had to complain about anything it would be that Hope doesn’t offer the doom/death genre anything groundbreaking or revolutionary, but while not a perfect album by any stretch of the imagination, I feel it is certainly a close second to the debut. And really, how much more can be done with this sound to help it evolve? At the end of the day Swallow the Sun can no longer merely be considered a contender within the genre; with three very solid albums under their collective belt they are truly among the elite here in 2007, and I don’t see that changing anytime soon. Fans of the band will love this, and fans of the genre are encouraged to get your grubby little paws on this release. It is a very impressive listen that just doesn’t seem to ware thin like so many albums in metal do these days. Recommended to any and all fans of beautifully depressive metal music.



Unknown Metalhead
Fan Club | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
www.swallowthesunfans.com for everything swallow the sun related!
Zal's Avatar
Zal | posted on 9/2007 | Reply
I hadn't heard of this band until the reviews on the site, and man was I missing out. Definitely a grower, this is a fantastic album that gets a lot of rotation for me. Will almost definitely be at or near the top of 2007's list. And good news for them, I saw them a couple of days ago on the first date of their North American tour with Katatonia, Scar Symmetry and Insomnium. Their set was fantastic, and I could see them quickly establishing new fans during the show. I also saw a lot of their merchandise selling, so there's no doubt they'll be going back to Finland with a significantly wider fanbase. Very nice guys to talk to, too.
Rob's Avatar
Rob | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
I love it...especially sitting at night on my pc chilling out....everysong is dark, depressing yest melodic. * * * * * STARS
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
i like the 2nd track- great keyboards and heavy \m/ i wouldn't call it a perfect album though. the debut reigns supreme! i had to download the cover track since it's not included on the US version [this is where tomi joutsen makes his guest appearance]- it's definitely cool, though i think i prefer the original.
Ryan's Avatar
Ryan | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
The Justice of Death is the best, most soothing song I've heard in months. Definitely the highlight of the entire album.
RobotRuler's Avatar
RobotRuler | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
Can't stop listen to this album.
Unknown Metalhead
Miss N. Thrope | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
I just bought this today and I think it's a contender. Renske sounds great on "The Justice of Suffering. The production in beautiful and so are the songs. Yes, it is a bit depressive, Supposed to be. It is doom. I think this at least equals their best if not better. The last three minutes of the final song, "Doomed to walk the earth" are just perfect IMO. Might even be a little better than the last MyDying Bride and the last Kat album and both of those made my 2006 list.
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
i'm adding- i wanna hear the f'n Rautianen cover!
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
don't pay import prices! this comes out either the 13th or 20th! almost here- although the endrecords.com sometimes gets stuff earlier.
Unknown Metalhead
robcat | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
this record sounds so fake and mechanical. i blame that on the production, but geeze, this recordings needs some balls to it! music isnt bad though.
Unknown Metalhead
Jimb | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
After hearing Hope many times I can't help but feel this normally brilliant band is slipping a little with this release. Overall it's another worthy album that has some excellent moments, but also their first release that feels a bit stale at times. Same ideas, same songwriting, same sound, all while not even matching their previous efforts. Let's HOPE (Pun!) that the band tries something new next time and makes an a I'd also like to express my sincere disgust that the phrase "mouth-watering" is in this review. That's a phrase used to describe baked goods and hot naked women, not a fucking doom album.
Unknown Metalhead
itunes? | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Is it available for download yet?
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/Metal Review | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Click the AMAZON.COM button underneath the album cover art. Yeah, it's an import, but well worth it.
hey's Avatar
hey | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
where do you get thissssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
Paul's Avatar
Paul | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
which song does Tomi Jousten sing in ?
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
I need to get this.
Rocco's Avatar
Rocco | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
I really enjoyed this as well as Ghosts of Loss. I need to check out The Morning Never Came. Highly recommended.
hey's Avatar
hey | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Hey Im dying to buy this. who has it state side?
brandonmetal's Avatar
brandonmetal | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
morning never came is still brilliant and highly enjoyable. ghosts of loss was surprisingly boring. and now with the song 'don't fall asleep,' it looks like they're going in the complete opposite direction, but i'm gonna get this when it comes out.
Unknown Metalhead
Die Benny | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
"is that Treebeard's nipple on the cover?" HA!!!
Unknown Metalhead
dooooooooom | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
this album rules. i think the songwriting is just as good as the morning never came, and the musicianship has been moved up a peg as well, but nonetheless good review.
Jess's Avatar
Jess | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
I've been playing this pretty consistently for the past 2 weeks. Great album. Very likely top 5 year end material.
behemoth666's Avatar
behemoth666 | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
is that Treebeard's nipple on the cover?