Album Review

Score 9.6
Written by Doug Moore
Published on 2/21/2007
In my recent review of Swedish prog rock act Wolverine, I bemoaned the state of so-called progressive rock. To abbreviate the argument, I feel that prog rock has lost touch with its goals; instead of actually progressing, most of the genre’s practitioners are content to rehash past explorations. But if Wolverine are a typically stagnant prog band, San Francisco’s Grayceon are the real deal. This self-titled debut is as legitimately progressive as they come these days, not to mention as meticulously detailed and beautifully crafted as anything I’ve heard so far this year.

Grayceon is a composite group of sorts. Featuring Max Doyle (guitars) and Zack Farwell (drums) of excellent San Fran thrashers Walken, the band’s lineup is rounded out by one Jackie Perez Gratz on cello and vocals. Gratz is a veteran of long-running Relapse act Amber Asylum as well as a new member of the up-and-coming Giant Squid, not to mention a contributor to albums by the likes of Today is the Day and Neurosis, so you could say she’s something of a genre-buster veteran. It certainly comes out in Grayceon’s songwriting; this trio’s sound is immediately distinct and unusual. Spanning 45 minutes with just four songs, Grayceon is a sprawling journey through the minds of three musicians who seem bent on both pushing boundaries and expressing as many different emotions as possible along the way.

Though perhaps ‘songs’ isn’t really the right term. Firstly, only the fiercely brief “Song For You” resembles a normal song in terms of dimensions; the rest are far more elaborate and dynamic than traditional rock or metal songs. Secondly, there’s not much singing going on. Though Gratz injects ethereal vocal lines occasionally and sometimes conducts hair-raising harmonies with Doyle, the vast weight of these compositions rests on the instrumentation, and some fuckin’ instrumentation it is, too. Somewhat neoclassical (and not in the Yngwie sense) in both melodic feel and structure, these tracks are stunningly elegant and tasteful examples of cooperative musicianship. The most immediately obvious point of comparison is Apocalyptica, though far more textured and melodically diverse. Though Gratz’s cello lines are both rhythmic and eloquent, the real star of the show is Max Doyle’s guitar work. Using an unusual finger-picked style and an arsenal of trebly, low-gain tones, Doyle employs a seemingly endless vocabulary of chords to generate an incredibly broad spectrum of moods, from folky to progressive to…thrash riffs and borrowed Fleetwood Mac bits? Sure is strange, but it sounds impressively organic anyway. The two instruments dodge and twist through a maze of lead and rhythm segments that, while initially overwhelming, are frequently quite beautiful. Driving the clouds of harmony is the rollicking, powerful single-peddle drumming of Zack Farwell. Though his roll-heavy bombast seems out of place at first, it lends reams of urgency to the otherwise somewhat ponderous music. A sparse but booming production emphasizes both the intimacy of the drum-free moments and the heft of Grayceon’s more intense passages.

It’s obviously somewhat difficult to capture Grayceon’s sound on paper, but trust me: this album is a treasure trove for those with a taste for the unusual and enough patience to tolerate long, multi-segment songs. Honestly, the heartbreakingly mournful ending of “Sounds Like Thunder” and the four minutes of riff brilliance that constitute the final third of “Into The Deep” are worth the price of this disc alone. Grayceon have released an inventive and vivid debut that easily bests most metal released this year. Looks like Vendlus Records has gotten another good start in 2007. Highly recommended.



Unknown Metalhead
Zack | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Very interesting album. That Wolverine release was great too.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
amazing band.
Unknown Metalhead
Joseph @ Vendlus | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Hey Doug I will be there for sure! We are located in D.C so I'm planning on seeing that show and the JAXX performance. Jon no problem! glad you like the disc! I honestly meant what I said to JimB maybe he will like Havoc Unit ha ha :)
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/MR | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
I'm really pumped for that tour actually, it's coming through Philadelphia on April Fool's Day I think.
Unknown Metalhead
Jon w/MR | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Joseph, thanks for the information, it's much appreciated. Great record here with shining originality at its finest! And never mind Jimb...it seems he's having a tough year thus far.
Unknown Metalhead
Joseph @ Vendlus | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
To: JimB you are entitled to your opinion but are you on our promo list? If so please let us know so we can plan ahead in the future to not send you challenging music :) To all Readers: Grayceon is going on tour with Giant Squid in March/April if you can try to go see them! They are truly a great band to see live and nice people to meet (recently they have been doing local shows where for 5usd to get in and 10usd you get in and a CD! that's too nice i think ha ha!)
Unknown Metalhead
Jimb | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
What's so amazing about this? It's just a band of geeks performing pointless long instrumentals (with the occasional bad vocal delivery) that are just thrown together without any thought. These guys may be able to play their instruments, but they aren't doing anything special or worthwhile. Highly un-recommended!
Unknown Metalhead
Jon w/MR | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Wow...
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
This sounds like something I'll like. Looks like I'll be checking this out soon.
Unknown Metalhead
Joseph @ Vendlus | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
I am so happy with the response from this release. I really believe in Grayceon they are an amazing band to work with and very dedicated! I also love this review you guys are the best at what you do!
Unknown Metalhead
Erik T | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Friggin brilliant album
Zach's Avatar
Zach  | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
This sounds cool, and with the double Jordan-Moore endorsement I will definitely be checking it out.
Unknown Metalhead
Jason w/MetalReview | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Great album.