Album Review

Score 8.2
Written by Michael Wuensch
Published on 10/13/2006
I’m gonna let you in on a little secret. Not only are Buzz Osbourne and Dale Crover the founding members of the Melvins, they’re also soulless wraiths that have survived for centuries by feeding on unsuspecting bass players unfortunate enough to fall into their fold. They apparently ensnare 4-stringers with delusions of stardom, and eventually fall upon them in the pitch of night, gobbling blood and innards until all that’s left is a gruesome, hollow husk of a cadaver…

Well, at least that’s what I’ve imagined, but I don’t actually have any proof to substantiate such a bold claim. Regardless, the fact remains the Melvins have torn through a hell of a lot of bass players over the past 20 years, and following the recent  "disappearance" of yet another, they’ve recently had to rekindle the hunt for their next bass wielding nutriment. So, with shadowy intentions cloaked, the two set out and plucked a feller directly from a band whose bass sound already very closely matched their own - Big Business/Karp madman, Jared Warren. But that’s not all. Evidently, the boys have decided to expand their cannibalistic palate to include hapless drummers, because they incorporated Jared’s Big Business companion, Coady Willis, into the flock as well. That’s right folks, not only are the Melvins currently a foursome, but they now boast two unbelievable talents behind drum kits, and the results are pretty damned spectacular.

Quite simply put, (A) Senile Animal rocks. The strange, experimental ambient/proggy/psychedelic samplings that flitted about on Honky, The Bootlicker, and their recent collaboration with Lustmord have fallen to wayside in favor of spotlighting the immense percussive talent of their newfound drumming duo. In fact, nearly every song on this record throws some sort of nod to the drumming gods, with four of the ten songs closing out with various rolls, kicks, clatters and fills. “Talking Horse”, “Blood Witch”, and “Rat Faced Cranny” are all ballsy rockers that smack the listener in the face like an old Kiss tune swaddled in fat, juicy pastrami. “Civilized Worm” - despite having a huge, arena rock-esque drummed beginning - eventually transforms into a beautiful, breezy hit that gingerly floats across the brainpan like a dinghy through still waters. And for those of you just dying to question why we would choose to review yet another ‘rock’ record, “The Hawk” and “You’ve Never Been Right” are both filled with the kind of metal riffage that could only be delivered directly on the tip of Odin’s spear, and destined solely for your sniveling hearts. Hell, this record even satisfies a filthy doomster such as myself with the odious crawler, “History of Bad Men”, a tune that spotlights Warren’s tar-soaked bass beautifully and immediately brings to mind the wonderful Lysol days of yore.

My only gripe with (A) Senile Animal is the relatively lackluster way in which it ends. For an album that so thoroughly showcases their new rhythmic, rowdy energy during the first half hour, “Mechanical Bride” and “Vast Filthy Prison” close the album with a relatively quiet ‘plink’, instead of the ‘wa-BAM!’ I was truly hoping for. Then again, this band has never really been known for doing exactly what’s expected of them, right?

If you consider yourself a long-time fan of the Melvins, but perhaps have been avoiding this record for fear of another Prick or Colossus of Destiny, be not afraid, (A) Senile Animal is definitely worthy of your attention, and just might visit your stereo as often as the band’s seminal, classic material. Definitely recommended.



Unknown Metalhead
Nailed to Sculpy Flesh | posted on 9/2007 | Reply
Melvins, Pig Destroyer, Suffocation then everyone else.
Unknown Metalhead
MIWS | posted on 9/2007 | Reply
they are weird.
Unknown Metalhead
cimmerian | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Melvins, Godflesh, KILLING JOKE, then everyone else.
Unknown Metalhead
A Different Chris | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
There is the Melvins, Godflesh, FUKING KILLDOZER, then everyone else.
Unknown Metalhead
windowlicker | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
without Melvins the world would be dark and chaotic.
Unknown Metalhead
Chris Sessions | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
@ WBM, I hung out with a lot of people who had the exact opposite stance. Melvins were Gods and Godflesh were just noise. But I place both groups on the same level. They both do something fundamental and at the same time abstract. Neither gives anything away. You have to earn the right to love it.
Unknown Metalhead
Galen | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
First time I heard them...me like!
WBM's Avatar
WBM | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Godflesh, classic masters. Melvins, I cannot get into at all.
Captain's Avatar
Captain  | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Just as a side note, if you're a fan of the Melvins and haven't checked out Big Business' "Head for the Shallows", I *highly* suggest you do so at some point. And you should pick up the self titled Karp record as well. That is all...
realist's Avatar
realist | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Melvins Shmelvins.
Unknown Metalhead
Jorm | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
I can't wait to pick this up.
Unknown Metalhead
Chris Sessions | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
There are Melvins, there are Godflesh and there are Everyone else. I wasn't thrilled with the guitar tone, though.
Unknown Metalhead
The Other Chris (Yes, Again) | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Good review, btw. The comparison with old Kiss tunes and fat, juicy pastrami is a classic.
Devin's Avatar
Devin | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
YES! The Melvins are consistantly great - I even like their experimental records like Colossus of Destiny. I am really, really into this album right now. Great review, but I'm surprised there's no mention of the added vocals. There are some seriously cool harmonies throughout this record.
Unknown Metalhead
Chris Sessions | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Like I can even fantasize about being able to keep up with either of those two. I would pop off in about twelve seconds and spend the rest of the evening shouting at them to keep it down so I could sleep. So, really? Yeah.
Unknown Metalhead
The Other Chris | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Better than a MFF with Vida Guerra and Eva Mendes?
Unknown Metalhead
Chris Sessions | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
Melvins are better than whatever you think is best.