Album Review

Score 7.1
Written by Erik Thomas
Published on 3/16/2006
Synopsis:

If you tend to blow your technical death metal wad over Decapitated, Necrophagist, Gorguts, Capharnaum, Anata, Spawn of Possession and such, grab another box of Kleenex...

Review:

Australia’s Psycroptic return with new , label, new vocalist and new album, following up 2003 well received The Scepter of the Ancients. Not much is tangibly different though; new growler Jason Peppiatt isn’t as gruff as Matthew Chalk, the production isn’t as bass heavy, but other wise underrated drummer Dave Haley (The Amenta) is the impressive backbone of this ultra complex effort that will leave you in awe with its sheer mix of velocity and technicality.

The thing with technical death metal is that, to me, most of its seems for show. Even Decapitated’s recent effort, though it grew on me, isn’t an album I’m likely to remember or revisit, unless I’m absolutely in the mood for some technical overload. I tend to prefer my death metal more simple and memorable. That being said, if you're one of those folks turned on by a total riff orgy, Symbols of Failure will test your refractory period to its limit.

The guitars of Joel Haley (also of The Amenta), I will admit however, are just sick, this guy can shred it up with any of his European or US counterparts, and rarely is a riff in place for more than a few seconds before, you can take that as adventurous, boundary shattering song structures or as extreme, note based ADD. Either way, to me, the 9 songs blend into one long frenzied, fret spasm, and that’s good or bad depending on your take on this style of death metal.

As “The Color of Sleep” impressively opened The Scepter of the Ancients, “Alpha Breed” sets the bar high for Symbols of Failure. That’s good in that it grabs you sharply by the balls right off the bat, but bad because the bar is set so high. Psycroptic then bludgeon and pelt you with such an array of incredibly tight and almost robotic taught death metal, that there’s rarely a moment to fully appreciate all that is going on. It’s not until “Repairing the Dimensional Cluster” and “Epoch of the Gods” that there is any point remotely resembling a breather from the constant vortex of shifting notes and stop start slicing. In fact, I could barely tell the stop and start point between “Alpha Breed”, “Missionaries of a Future to Come”, “Merchants of Deceit” and “Minions: The Fallen”. Again, good or bad depending on your view of this particular delivery. Only “An Experiment in Transience” hints at being a ‘slow’ song, and even then it soon careens into a stachato maelstrom.

The production is a little dry for me, with barely any bass or low end lacking Decapitated’s total skin shredding tones, even if arguably even more complex. It also lacks Necrophagist’s intricate melodies and also woven into the complexity, making the album almost seem like one indefinable song.

All that being said, while Symbols of Failure didn’t hit me or grow on me as much as Organic Hallucinocis did, its still a very impressive display of musicianship, and if you are happy with that for your dollar, this is a no-brainer, but I want a little more long lasting substance for my money.



megalith's Avatar
megalith | posted on 8/2011 | Reply
I was bored until the last track. "Observant" is pretty awesome(apart from that damn bass drum sound). Awe-inspiring riffs, in my opinion.
DUDE's Avatar
DUDE | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
The Scepter of the Ancients is way better!
Unknown Metalhead
Nephalim | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
The album is good...but after a while, I thought it was more of a "riff salad" than a full lenght album. It feels like some riffs don't have a good reason to be in the songs. So I will have to agree with the reviewer. There is about three or four songs really memorable (for me) on this album. Merchants of Deceit, for example. Another thing : the singer...He's competent, no doubt about that, but he seems to want to take all the empty space available, like a second guitar would do. It would'nt hurt if he would shut the hell up once and a while so we, addict of insane riffs, can appreciate the finess of the guitar work, wich is utterly impressive. Speaking of the guitar work, the tone, while being all chopped off and damn clear, is somewhat...cheap. I don't know, but the tone on Scepter was a hell lot bigger and badder than this. Don't get me wrong though, I enjoyed this album, but I think that these australians can (and WILL hopefully) do better in the future.
Adam's Avatar
Adam | posted on 7/2007 | Reply
I will defend the reviewer from that stuff they aren't into comment because he brings up preferring the new Decapitated. I have been thinking about these two albums as well and conclude that, although there are aspects of both bands I like, it is just more fun for everyone when you got a little more leadwork going on. I think 4 out of 6 is still a fair score though. I mean that isn't bad is it and I do believe that Psycroptic still have room to improve their overall songwriting to slightly decrease the monotony. Bottom line of course is that this band still kicks ass and that it can only get better from here!
Unknown Metalhead
Irukanji | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
Why the fuck do people review stuff they "aren't in to", and expect to be objective? WTF Erik? The review isn't bad, opinion and all, but that's the problem: it's condescending as all hell because of your opinion. Frankly, there's a large crowd that find much of this very memorable. Organic Hallucinocis is practically radio catchy compared to this (one of my favorite records regardless). The point is, you make this sound like you've walked into a dance club and said, "gee, this isn't really my scene", and then hung out anyways standing out like a rabbi in Mecca. The production is pretty weak, 4-4.5. Songwriting? Let's not completely forget the complexity of interlacing musical themes amidst both logical chord progressions and hybrid chromatic runs while changing key or time signatures. I'm no world renowned virtuoso, but if I can sit down in Guitar Center and crack out most of "Alpha Breed", unlike the fag one row of amps over playing "Enter Sandman" too loud, it's memorable music. 5.5 Musicianship is the execution of this ability to write/create from scratch. Yeah, they go hand in hand, but nobody is arguing Psycroptic's ability to play. So what if you can play augmented or diminished scales backwards and forwards: using it to create songs like Psycroptic has is what counts. 6. This review paints an unfair and biased view of an excellent record. This isn't Killswitch Engage, who have great musicians playing average catchy riffs. So don't review it with a slant.
Blake Solomon's Avatar
Blake Solomon | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
@ Dave I'm sorry, I must have forgotten that OR had shit in my ears. I just recalled at the time that there were slighlty more clean vocals on their previous release "The Isle Of Disenchantment" Both on the songs Psycroptipath and The Labyrinth. I was just trying to say something positive though, no need to get hostile.
Romain's Avatar
Romain | posted on 10/2006 | Reply
EXCELLENT, IF YOU LIKE THEIIR PREVIOUS, YOU WILL LOVE THIS ONE !!!!!!! MY RATE : 5 / 5,5 / 6
Unknown Metalhead
Cabecao | posted on 7/2006 | Reply
The guitarist is a machine but yeah the production is lacking. As far as comparing them to decapitated goes......to me they sound vastly different. To see them on the same bill would be awesome though.
Dave's Avatar
Dave  | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
Chalky did use clean vocals Blake, listen to the chorus of 'The Valley Of Winds Breath And Dragons Fire' Nothing more irritating that people licking the rims of musicians without a proper ear to hear with.
Blake Solomon's Avatar
Blake Solomon | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
"and it was also in my opinion the best showcase of DM vocals ever. Period." -Sculpy on "Scepter..." I completely agree. I was blown away by not only the music, but the vocals as well. That guy threw in everything but the kitchen sink on SOTA. Mid-pitch death bark, low pitch grind gurgle, black metal rasp, even a hardcore yell here and there, and he did it with class. The only thing missing would be clean vocals. I'm not saying clean vocals would've worked, or even belong, but you never know. Perfect example of vocals being used as an "instrument."
Unknown Metalhead
Redux | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
You know something else? im really happy that the tech genre has gone beyond the confines it had a few years ago. It seems like the scene was clogged with dilllinger clones, but this kinda stuff ive been hearing, Psycroptic, Capharnaum, and the like, seem to all have their own place in the new genre. Most of all though i like it when people make music that sounds genuinely new. I wonder why Psyopus isnt on metal review?
Unknown Metalhead
Sculpy | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
Nothing wrong with wanking in a DM context... techdeath gives us some of most bangin' and interesting riffs in music, and Symbols is no exception. It definitely is not nearly as catchy as Scepter, but I quickly thought Symbols' songwriting (especially riff progressions and lyrics) would be more consistent and enduring... and time hasn't proven me wrong! Scepter is really the classic Psycroptic release; it's the one that got them on the radar in a big way, and it was also in my opinion the best showcase of DM vocals ever. Period. So in that sense I think i'd always reluctantly reccommend Scepter over Symbols, as well as favour it....but man, Symbols is in no way a step down for the band. I think it just shows they're still at the top of their game.
Unknown Metalhead
Redux | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
Why do i feel like an asshole for liking tech shit when i go on this site? My ADD wont let up. This release has what i think may be some of the best death metal drumming ive ever heard, eclipsing necrophagist's insane drummer even. By the way i finally saw necrophagist live, and they kill, and so does arsis. Though all of those could be called tech-wank bands. I guess i like wanking.
Unknown Metalhead
Abyssous | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
Holy Shit..you must to be crazy man..4.0 on production, and songwriting..i just can't believe this..Scepter is actualy betther than Symbols but give this 4.0 is a fucking insult..
animate's Avatar
animate | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I'm very happy with this release. I think the review accurately describes it; what does it matter if Decapitated isn't 'technical'? Decapitated set a standard for death metal with "Winds of Creation" - giving reference to that is a blessing. I'm still taking all this in. I like that the tracks blend together, but I think "Scepter" had better production. Even with Chalk gone, this band is still going strong. B
Unknown Metalhead
Erik | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
We have editors for that-they will be summarily beaten.
Brian's Avatar
Brian | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Please improve your punctuation and grammar (e.g. you're, not YOUR) if you're going to be a reviewer. I would've thought that would be a no-brainer. Agree with you on the review though, just goes over my head for the most part. I really like the last song, but can't remember the name.
Unknown Metalhead
CletusVanDamme | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
"i agree with fucktard" haha
Unknown Metalhead
aDAMN | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
i agree with fuktard #25512 decapitated isn't nearly as technical as these fuckers
fractal_mortality's Avatar
fractal_mortality | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Meh, I'd rather have overproduction on guitars and underproduction on drums than visa versa... *looks at Cryptopsy's latest album*
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I really think he has a point with the whole production part. There really is no impact with the guitars and at least when i played this in my car it seemed like i could barely hear the double bass over the guitars. Very good album but the production at least on the drums really failed.
Metaltoon's Avatar
Metaltoon | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I've been listening to this for about 3 weeks now and the more I listen to it the more I really fucking enjoy it. it's definately more mature then The Scepter. These guys are truly a shinning light coming out of OZ right now.
Unknown Metalhead
Gniewo | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
This was the most anticipated album of 2006 to me ! And it didn't fail ! At first I thouyght it's less catchy than "The scepter..." but after few spins you can embrace it as a whole - this one is more mature and sophisticated. And I think they're the best technical death metal group out now !! My opinion : 6/5,5/6
Unknown Metalhead
Elnimio | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
"I tend to prefer my death metal more simple and memorable. " That's retarded...
fractal_mortality's Avatar
fractal_mortality | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I don't think anyone made an accusation specifically aimed at you, Erik. I simply think it was a general recommendation to anyone that might want to give the album a try, and might arrive at different conclusions of musical proficiency (as I did, and others did).
Unknown Metalhead
Erik T | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Do you guys really think I gave this one scant listen and threw this review together? I gave it many many listens hoping it would click like the Decapitated did, cos i initially wasnt impressed with that. Howver, other than being impressed, nay-stunned by the skill, the songs still did little for me.
Unknown Metalhead
Fuktard | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Decapitated is not really that technical......don't know why they ended up in this review.
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/MetalReview.com | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Patrick: "This album was like opening a cold can of my favorite beer, anticipating that wonderful taste, then to my horror finding out that the can was flat. No bubbles, its still the beer I love, but it is no fun to drink now." PERFECT analogy!!!!
ThrashBeast's Avatar
ThrashBeast | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Only 4 song-wrting????? At least 5 imo
Unknown Metalhead
Patrick D w/ MetalReview | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
The band didnt let you down, the engineer did. The production has no snap and no presence. Tech Death has to be mixed at the highest possible standard. This album was like opening a cold can of my favorite beer, anticipating that wonderful taste, then to my horror finding out that the can was flat. No bubbles, its still the beer I love, but it is no fun to drink now.
Fractal_Mortality's Avatar
Fractal_Mortality | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I love this album. Listen to it a few times (as everyone has said).
Ryan's Avatar
Ryan | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
definite let down. New singer is not very impressive. Riffs aren't as exciting as Scepter, but the drumming is still sic. New Decapitated mops the floor with this album, which is a bit depressing, I was really looking forward to this release.
Unknown Metalhead
Rufus | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Deserving of a 5/4.5/6 in my eyes. I agree with the reviewer/lashers: it's not as impressive as Scepter.... BUT this is well worth many listens. And yes, it is lacking the bass-heavy production that made Scepter fucking superb. However it still packs some punch. Thus far, my favortie song on this record is Merchants Of Deceit - those riffs are just cock-hardening. Oh and I'm just wondering, Does anybody care that there aren't any solos? I certainly don't mind thanks to the insane riffing of Joel Haley. Jason Peppiat really a commendable job of handling the vocals but I definitely miss Matt Chalk's bullfrog growls quite a bit. All gripes aside, this album is still fun as hell to listen to.
Unknown Metalhead
Drittbjørn | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Great album, but it definately takes a few listens, as everyone has said.
Unknown Metalhead
Dago | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
i give it 556 Good album but you need to listen to it at least 7 or more times.
Unknown Metalhead
Sculpy | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Best death metal album of 2006 in my opinion. I find the album extremely memorable (after about 6 listens) and often hum riffs and tunes from it to myself...and I never do that. You should have mentioned the lyrics because they're pretty stunning, and really elevate the atmosphere of the album, once you know the themes etc. I'd give it a triple 6, but I do adore my tech death.
Cainam's Avatar
Cainam | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Yes, I'm jone of those guys who masturbates while listening to all the bands mentioned in this review. I like Capharnaum, Necrophagist, Anata, Spawn of Possesion, I like it when the new thick produced Decapitated album blow up my ears. but I also like Psycroptic a lot. They don't focus on heavy as hell music and production, but they focus on clear, crispy, compact technical Death Metal. It takes you some time to really appreciate and discover the fine details on Symbol of Failure, but when you really do, it must be one of the finest death metal albums of 2006.
Ciprian's Avatar
Ciprian | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I've listened to both albums and i cant tell wich is the best.I think both are good with a plus for vocal parts on the second
justinbean's Avatar
justinbean | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I pretty much agree with you on this. The music, of course, is sick, but it just doesn't hit very hard at all. I thought Scepter of the Ancients was pretty excellent, but this one was a let down. but decapitated not being memorable? ehhhhh. in my humble opinion its one of the finest death metal albums ive come across. but to each his own, aye?