Album Review

Score 8.6
Written by Erik Thomas
Published on 10/24/2005
With the recent news that Tarja B has been unceremoniously dumped from Nightwish, the door seems open for another band to take over the mantle of gloriously pompous, female fronted Goth metal. Mark it down-that band is Holland’s Epica.

While most female fronted Goth metal leaves me more flaccid than an under the table hand job from Anna Nicole Smith while she eats crab legs, Epica actually had me rather impressed and at least at half mast for the genre. While my sexist, chauvinist side wants to prattle on about delectable, flame haired beauty Simone Simons, I should at least address the band that is Epica. The song writing is solid, the heavy Carl Orff (composer of the famous Carmina Burana opera) like orchestration and choirs are dramatic and typically gregarious, but when backed by some stout mid paced metal and even some death/black metal vocals, the extraneous elements become easier to swallow.

Obviously, this is high end operatic Goth metal, so if you not into the likes of Nightwish, After Forever, Elis, Visions of Atlantis and to some extent, Therion, I’m not here to convince you Epica is for you, but if you enjoy those grandiose, operatic bands, Epica’s conceptual sophomore album (not including their movie score album) has to be considered one of the pinnacles of the genre.

After the few opening bars of “Hunab K’u (A New Age Dawns-Prologue)” which sounds like Bal-Sagoth mixed with the Superman soundtrack, Epica launch into the expected theatrical Broadway metal of “Dance of Fate” with all the bells and whistles (and choirs and brass/horn orchestration and synths and Latin lyrics and galloping guitars and soaring chorus). “The Last Crusade (A New Age Dawns)” continues the overt classical and operatic take on boisterous Goth metal frolicking with ample soaring results that show why Epica were also involved in penning a movie score this year also.

Now, I’m not trying to be immodest here but I’m a pretty solid ‘man’ by all meanings of the word, I’m comfortable with my masculinity and chauvinism. That being said, the nut shrinking, uber feminine ballad “Solitary Ground” had me subconsciously singing in a soprano voice around the house with candles and a lighter waving in the air. My god it’s embarrassingly catchy and addictive. Put it this way; my wife likes the song. A lot. Castrate me now. Heck, and this is the ‘metal’ version, the acoustic/piano version on the bands Solitary Ground CD might actually give me reconstructive genital surgery just by listening to it. The band’s well done mix of catchy, epic metal continues for “Blank Infinity” and “Force of the Shore” introduces some deep death metal vocals that play well with Simons angelic crooning, but the bouncy, folky canter of “Quietus” again had me checking my pants for involuntary penis inversion as I try to convince myself I should not be enjoying this album as much as I do.

“Mother of Light (A New Age Dawns II)” has some black metal screams during the awkward chorus, but there is enough heavy handed, dramatic prose to make up for it. “Trois Vierges” is a little too Phantom of the Opera /Michael Crawford vs. Sarah Brightman for me but “Another Me” and the amazing nine minute closer “Consign to Oblivion (A New Age Dawns III)” end the album with a far more, suitably epic atmosphere that cements Epica are the band to beat in the genre right now.

Now, please feed me steak, porn and football to reverse this album's effect on me.



Unknown Metalhead
Erik T | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
Thanks "M" you rock!!! See you later-literally.
Unknown Metalhead
M. | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
Don't usually listen to this genre of music, but work with ET, so I gave it a shot. Gotta tell you - as I had no idea of what I was going to be slammed with (he also recommended As Cities Burn, The Showdown and Demon Hunter, which I listened to first), I had a preconceived notion that the neighbors might stroke out on Epica as well. So I listened the first time with headphones. Thoroughly enjoyed it, enough to say the second time around - to hell with the neighbors. Turned it up LOUD. REALLY loud. Female fronted or not - goth/symphonic or not - affected or effected - or not..it is enjoyable. So, boys - leave this country girl alone now. I've stepped out of my box a foot or two by listenining and lashing. You've ET to thank.
Unknown Metalhead
Logan | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
When you consider the garbage that the Goth/Symphonic scene endlessly spews out, a band like Epica is actually, although still immature, quite adept at creating infectious melodies. They still have a lot to improve on but the band undeniably has potential. I'm not impressed with the production though. The guitars should be louder and the kick drum is badly recorded. It's a little sloppy in my opinion. This album grows on you. At first, I was not impressed at all but slowly, the melodies left indelible marks. Still, it's not outstanding or exceptional. I give it 7 out of 10...
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
I think it would have been better if Mark Jensen just stayed in After Forever where he belonged personaly
Unknown Metalhead
Utilia | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Don't you think this album would have been miles better is the guitars were higher in the mix? they seem to get lost under all the symphonics, there are some chugging riffs but they dont cut through
Unknown Metalhead
alfjlkdaj;fd | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Katulu: pick up a dictionary; I'm certain it'll be in there. Oh, I was calling you the "Grammar Police". I acknowledge the difference between "affect" and "effect" (besides the spelling difference). Oh, yeah. The band....Not a big fan of female-fronted bands. Like it from time to time...but not always.
Unknown Metalhead
J. | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Just becuase its female fronted does not make it goth, Nigtwish and Epica are are power, and not faggoth crap, even though NW kinda dresses gay.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
My point is, that their are good, female fronted metal out there, even Gothic Metal and that Epica is A. Not good and B. Not Gothic Metal. They earn their name Replica with ease.
Unknown Metalhead
Katulu | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Gotta agree with the Madder Mortem. Awesome band, though I see no resemblance with Nightwish.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
ugh, this is a shit album and I like this kind of stuff, I made the mistake of buying it thinking it would be better then the first one, but it is worse. A. It isn't fucking Goth Metal, it is some kind of Symphonic Power shit. This kind of stuff gives Goth Metal a bad name IMO. B. Only Darkwell and Visions of Atlantis are worse then these guys. C. Good female fronted stuff, Madder Mortem, After Forever, Within Temptation, Flowing Tears and some others. D. Nice review but this is a bad album and bad example of the genre. 3 out of 10.
Unknown Metalhead
Logan | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Good review mate. I like the production job better on their fist album though. Besides that, a strong album in that style. I think this band will only get better...
Unknown Metalhead
Katulu | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
When can "affect" be a noun? "an affect"? hmm... Just curious. As for "Grammar Police", "affect" and "effect" are two different words. As for Epica, sounds interesting, but I really haven't liked what I've heard by Nightwish and After Forever, so if it's the same thing, only "better", I pass.
Unknown Metalhead
adjflfja;lkj | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
The Grammar Police! No, really. Affect can be a verb, a noun, or a transitive verb. But, I must concede to the fact that it's "effect". Goddamn, I hate grammar.
Unknown Metalhead
Katulu | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
"to reverse this album's affect on me. " "effect" "affect" is a verb.
Unknown Metalhead
Chris w/MetalReview | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
"Most female fronted Goth metal leaves me more flaccid than an under the table hand job from Anna Nicole Smith while she eats crab legs." Quote of the month, if not of the year.