Album Review

Score 9.3
Written by Doug Moore
Published on 9/6/2005
Does it seem to anyone out there that metal is getting gradually heavier on average? The standards for speed, technicality, and (of course) brutality seem to edge just a bit upwards with each passing year as extreme metal pursues its for-better-or-worse arms race for the most intense band ever, often with disastrous results. Fortunately, the masses of Krisiun snoreblasters and Unique Leader signees are balanced out by the occasional high-powered creative aberration that makes all of those downtuned guitars and incomprehensible time signatures sound like something other than a defective cement truck; this is, of course, where Ion Dissonance come in. You probably already know by way of Breathing is Irrelevant that these Canucks are way ahead of the game in terms of both full-choke firepower and songwriting finesse, and Solace sees them simply turning everything up a notch. Though universally dense and sometimes virtually impenetrable, Ion Dissonance have struck another earsplitting blow in the name of virtuous musicianship and aggression, and it will be difficult for their contemporaries to dislodge them from their perch atop the technical metal heap.

Where Breathing is Irrelevant hovered between monolithic, discordant violence and high-end fret spasms, the band has streamlined and further unified their sound this time around. Most of the squiggling tech runs have been stripped away, and Ion Dissonance have firmly established themselves alongside the tragically short-lived Rune amongst the few worthy disciples of death metal legends Gorguts. However, where Rune injected morbidly baroque melody into their forefathers’ sickening cacophony, these guys have opted for all-out vein-popping aggression. Solace is even more unrelenting than its predecessor; from the blistering opening of “Play Dead…and I’ll Play Along” to the final drone of “A Prelude of Worse Things to Come,” there is hardly a second to breathe or get one’s bearings. The outcome is that this album is a spectacularly tough listen, and the consistent cerebral riffing takes at least ten or twelve go-rounds to really digest. A passing familiarity with the songs is where the carnage really starts, though; tracks that seemed like directionless stop-start chunkfests bloom into gorgeously spiteful assaults on one’s senses. Churning, elaborate chord progressions slam forcefully between blastbeats and thunderous midtempo with the grace of a ninja elephant, building up into towering auditory landscapes before leveling the terrain with a heart-stopping breakdown. The fact that the band employs any sort of even groove, particularly a variety that can be at all associated with the ‘h’ word, is sure to draw them fire, but this shit has nothing to do with any brand of hardcore that’s rightly assigned the name. These chugga sections hit with Despise The Sun-esque power, and are invariably complex, interesting and—most importantly—brief. Serving as anchors for the otherwise insurmountable song structures on early listens and gale-force climaxes once acclimated to Ion Dissonance’s harsh atmosphere, they are integral to the band’s deadly songwriting.

It needn’t be repeated that this band has achieved an inhuman level of musicianship; their reputation has been built largely on their accomplished technique. What this band does that most other super-tech bands can’t is create a genuinely threatening, intimidating atmosphere. This owes much to Solace’s production; this is one of the thickest, most corrosive guitar tones I’ve heard all year. It perfectly compliments the consistently ugly and abrasive riffing with its massive bassy tone, but unfortunately it reveals Ion Dissonance’s slightly imperfect control of their own monstrous sound. The fusion of the mega-downtuned guitars (these guys are rivaling the likes of Neurosis here), the busy riffage, and the production sometimes creates a muddle totally impervious to any sort of comprehension. These wall-of-sound moments are few and far between, and the dearth of excellence that fills the remainder of the disc is more than worth it, but they stand between the album and perfection.

I honestly can’t recommend this as a universal must-buy, because it’s just too damn heavy and complex to click with everyone. There’s no shame in not ‘getting’ Solace, as one needs a broad streak of musical masochism to put in the hours and effort required to plumb the pitch-black nadir that comprises the heart of this album. Those who possess the requisite patience and penchant for self-abuse will likely go apeshit over this stuff, though, and they’re a goddamn lucky bunch. Metal may be getting heavier as time goes on, but somehow I don’t think many will ever scrape the ceiling of human extremity the way Ion Dissonance do.



Unknown Metalhead
i hate you | posted on 7/2007 | Reply
ya where the fuck is the review for minus the herd? that shit is baller. heavy as fuck with way better production than this one. the opening song is absolutely punishing.
Unknown Metalhead
rpj | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
ok, the new album is fucking tits. can't wait to see the review for it
Unknown Metalhead
fdsfsafsd | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
This is what all metalcore should sound like.
Unknown Metalhead
s62 | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
Great review for a great album. Cheers
Unknown Metalhead
DELONLECHERY | posted on 11/2006 | Reply
GOD I love this band/album. This one took me quite a few spins to full appreciate, but now I've grown to love it a helluva lot more than "..Breathing". Great review, and I couldn't agree more with the part about the production being caustic and abrasive. It fits ID perfectly.
Unknown Metalhead
JRX | posted on 11/2006 | Reply
I didn't find this album that hard to get into, actually. Still fucking awesome, brutal as hell, and loving it, but not what I'd call a difficult disc to jam to. It's my CSS background music right now. :D
Unknown Metalhead
SunnyvaleTrash | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
Fantastic album. Rarely does metal sound this violent.
Unknown Metalhead
The King of Town | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
FucBush: Unfortunately, Solace is the only album I own, so I couldn't tell you. Sorry.
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/MR | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Typo. Haven't felt like correcting it. Sorry duder.
Unknown Metalhead
dearth | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
reviewer used the word dearth with the exact opposite meaning of the correct one. exactly wrong. yay ion dissonance
Unknown Metalhead
FucBush | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
@the king..., anature... how is the production compared to BIE, b/c i got that the other day and it is glorious!
Unknown Metalhead
The King of Town | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I just got it today, and I found the production great. All of my previous worries were laid to rest. It's pretty much an amazing album.
Unknown Metalhead
anaturaldisaster | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
To: The King Of Town Don't worry about it. If you listen to this record on a good system or at least passable headphones, it's one of the most boneshatteringly heavy mixes of all time. The bass is completely buried, and the drums are pretty low too, but the guitar tone is fucking ridiculous.
Unknown Metalhead
The King of Town | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
As I wait eagerly for this album to ship, i have one little concern. Now this may have been my computer's speakers, or MySpace's suckiness, but when I listened to one of their songs on MySpace, it sounded very flat. Should I really expect the album to sound like that, or is someone lying to me?
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 2/2006 | Reply
kick ass album. on par with dillinger escape plan except much heavy. i really cant see tho John how you can compare this to Between the Buried and Me and The Red Chord tho.
Unknown Metalhead
john | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
I bought this and it immediately started kicking my ass. It blurs together alot and it takes alot of listening to pick apart songs, but there is always something on every song that stands out enough to identify all of it after the first few listens. I dont think its as memorable as BII but this still wipes the floor with btam and the red chord, its best taken in as a whole, if you tryed to do it on a song by song basis youd be missing the point. the atmosphere of this album is just so opressive and violent that it makes you squirm in your fucking seat, but somehow the drone of 'solace' is very comforting at the end of the album.
Unknown Metalhead
meshman | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
Finally, a just review.
Unknown Metalhead
nate | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
fuck yes i'm going to buy this right now
Unknown Metalhead
ippopedinyourcloset | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
http://stores.ebay.com/HC-4-Ever-Distro
Unknown Metalhead
Invectenae | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Wow. just picked it up today. I agree with all the hype. Its nice to finally shrug off Dillinger escape plan in favor of this peice of pure agression. Oh yeah. I saw them live, and they fucking ruled. Right up there with The End's live show.
Unknown Metalhead
Ian | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
i really don't find the production bad at all.
sol381's Avatar
sol381 | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Its a shame when you have all these great bands who just cant afford the expensive studio time and have to do with inadequate production. This could have been a sensational album if the bass was a little less muddy and the guitars were more distinct and louder in the mix. drums were great. Its a pity for a lot of bands we see here.
Unknown Metalhead
joe | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
the guitars are mixed way low... i know from talking to the band they aren't happy with it either. needs to be remixed..ran out of time. production could have been way way better to make this the perfect album.
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/Metalreview | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I think you're mistaking the guitars for bass. That shit is tuned WAY the fuck down.
sol381's Avatar
sol381 | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Seems to me like the guitar is mixed way too low adn all thatyou hear is a lot of bass and kick drum.. The guitars are hardly audible ,probably due to a slightly muddy production and that is what really makes an album truly heavy.. Hva e alistne to this then listen to occults-elegy for the weak.. That is ultra heavy.
Unknown Metalhead
David | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
What's up with Quebec anyway? Is every band from Quebec this insanely talented? I mean Martyr, Neuraxis, Cryptopsy, Gorguts and now this. Great stuff.
Luke's Avatar
Luke | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Breathing is Irrelevant absolutely killed, so on that album alone im keen as shit to get Solace. i did hear an mp3 off the new album online & i wasnt entirely impressed with the production though. maybe it was the shitty computer speakers but i thought the production on the demo version of She's Strychnine hit the nail on the head, it had much more balls & beefiness then the finished product. it's always cool to hear a Suffo reference but imo Despise the sun was a fairly dull, stale representation of a great band.
Unknown Metalhead
Jo | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Their sound is just so thick and heavy it's rigodamndiculous.The production here,in my opinion,is some of the best I've heard on a math metal album.These guys are one of the few math metal bands (from a second story window also) that I can listen to.Great album.
Unknown Metalhead
B-ricer | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Some of their stuff seems to be just random noise and sudden shifts in song writing. Im not to fond of the vocals either, sounds to weak for me, like someone is just screaming at the top of their lungs and not really trying. I like vocals more like Niles and Behemoth, and a little faster guitar work, but thats me. If you like more modern death metal, i guess you can call it, then check these guys out. Just not for me though
Mark's Avatar
Mark | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
. . . what Doug (and Zero) said. lol ID isn't pure death metal, those that understand that won't be disappointed. These guys are playing in Hollywood on the 20th, can't wait to see them again.
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/Metalreview | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
What Zero Tolerance said.
Unknown Metalhead
Zero Tolerance | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
When Ion Dissonance slows down and executes some (non-trendy) breakdowns, they get super-fucking heavy. These guitars have such a great tone on them that I can understand where the Suffos reference comes from. If you're expecting Suffocation-style death metal however, you'll be sorely disappointed with ID.
Unknown Metalhead
john | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
this album reeks of just greatness. other bands out should sit back and learn a lesson from ID. nice review!
Unknown Metalhead
David | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
When Suffocation are well sort of mentioned I get interested. To all Suffo fans the intensity of Despise The Sun is well legendary. Is this some sort of Pierced From Within for the 21st century or is it Biomechanical gone death. just curious. and i could be way off the mark but this album sounds interesting.
Unknown Metalhead
grindmyass | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Review more albums, unlike most of the reviewers on this site you seem to really know what your talking about. Kudos. This album destroys BTW. "Top 10 of the Year" material, easy.
Unknown Metalhead
joe | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
only problem with the album is the production. its very heavey, but its extremely hard to make out the guitars. don't get me wrong, the album kills, but sometimes things are so jumbled and not clear due to the production. i much prefer the production on breathing is irrelevant. now if this band would only start touring with some good bands instead of the second rate metalcore crap they usual play with.
Unknown Metalhead
HolyShit | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Is there any doubt that Ion Dissonance is at the top of the heap? This album is so absolutely, outrageously dark, heavy, brutal, and fierce... Fucking wow. I can't say enough about it.
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
usually im not into this kind of crap, but these guys inject some compelling shit into this techdeath onslaught, def gonna be an ID fan soon...
Unknown Metalhead
me | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
i didn't think that these guys could make something more tech and crazier than "Breathing Is Irrelevant" but "Solace" destroys everything. there are points in every song on here that i find myself saying "OH MY GOD!!!" when they go off on tech runs here and there, the breakdowns annihilate anything their sound waves touch. this is in my top 5 for the year
Unknown Metalhead
ninja | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
This is porbably the best review I have ever seen
Unknown Metalhead
Ninja | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
First this album is a masterpiece. Second the website has changed to id357.com lastly- gabriel - the lead singer- is one of the colest people I have ever met. There is something going on with this bands music that is just at a whole other level.
Unknown Metalhead
doommantia | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Its like Gorguts - Obscura taken to the next level.
Unknown Metalhead
Patrick Dawson | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Ion Disonance are the top of the heap.
Unknown Metalhead
Dmoralize | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I love the music this band creates. The super-heavy/dissonant sound of the guitars definiitely does create a feeling that other bands of this style just don't reach. Very interesting stuff.
Unknown Metalhead
xknifeintheback | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Heavy. So goddamn heavy. I'm in love with this band all over again. Another one of my year's tops. Two in one goddamn week, talk about ridiculous.
Unknown Metalhead
Grindcore Ninja Commando | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
best of 2005 so far. better than despised icon. better than BTBAM.
Ed's Avatar
Ed | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
don't work.. go to http://www.myspace.com/iondissonance
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/Metalreview | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Probably not. This is definitely technical death metal; I dislike BTBAM (see my review) and I obviously love this.
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
awesome review, doug, but i have just one question: if i hate BTBAM with every fiber of my being, am i gonna hate this as well?
Unknown Metalhead
Ian | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
i'm in the middle of the first song. verrry interesting.
Mark's Avatar
Mark | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Thank you, Doug, for giving the credit that this band deserves. These guys are pure METAL and absoutely destroy in a live setting.
Unknown Metalhead
Hraesvelg | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
i saw these guys live recently. AMAZING. really looking forward to picking this one up.
Unknown Metalhead
Zero Tolerance | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I know EXACTLY what the reviewer is talking about when he describes the puzzle finally "falling into place" (as it is) when the listener finally understands the song. That is a wonderful moment when listening to Ion Dissonance. I don't recommend this band to anyone but those who feel that Origin's Informis album was NOT extreme enough. ID are almost impenetrable! But if you manage to "get" them, as the review states, you are a lucky bastard. Though I think that we will see/hear a band more extreme than ID in the future...
Unknown Metalhead
Zero Tolerance | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Damn. This band is awesome. ID were trained on the extreme metal "farm team" known as Willowtip. Look at the success that label is spawning!!!