Album Review

Score 7.5
Written by Matt Mooring
Published on 9/14/2005
Nobody sounds like The Mass. Their second full length is another convincing display of Genre Twister, where left hand is on metal; right foot, jazz; right hand, hardcore; left foot, indie sensibility. And whoever is spinning that little square cardboard spinner is a warped genius, because stretched, bent, and contorted into a most unnatural position, The Mass has somehow discovered enough balance and strength to turn that posture into some kind of Ralph Macchio flying crane knockout-kick stance. The band’s influences are so well integrated that their sound is near incomparable, but when you hear them play, it sounds completely natural.

Although Crucial Blast’s release of City of Dis came out (and was reviewed here) only a year ago, the album has actually been around since 2003. The band has obviously kept themselves busy during these intervening years, because Perfect Picture of Wisdom and Boldness is a much more developed and intricately crafted collection. Not only are the songs more polished, but also much longer (the eight tracks span an hour), which gives time for countless turns and forays. The band has clearly progressed, although progress isn’t necessarily synonymous with improvement. Perfect Picture of Wisdom and Boldness is probably a better album than City of Dis, but there are times when I miss the raw, impetuous vibe of the last album. On balance though, The Mass gains as much as they’ve lost through progression.

Front man Matt Water’s double duty on the saxophone is in and of itself enough to make The Mass a strange bird; the fact that the prominent sax isn’t the most defining element of their sound is remarkable. Maybe it’s because Perfect Picture is my second time around with The Mass, but this time out it seems like the sax is better integrated into the songs, some of which rely upon it heavily, and others that could easily exist without it, although its presence inarguably adds to the color and charm of the music. The Mass’ songs are quite dynamic, but the band maintains a consistent and distinct personality. On “Little Climbers of Nifelheim” they shimmy effortlessly through transitions to passages of pensive grooves, desperado surf punk mania, and dissonant, syncopated math metal. The minute and a half freak out “Gas Pipe” is a flight of the psychotic bumblebee, but the song is followed by the 180 of the Percoset and sax at twenty paces of the somber “Meditation on Some the Carcass”, which is instrumental for the first six of its seven minutes. Acrimonious and angular at times, and blissfully meditative and insular at others, Perfect Picture spans the gamut of mood and styles. Although the band has developed their songwriting, there are a few occasions that could have been edited down, and it seems very likely that The Mass’ best work is still to come. Impressive, as Perfect Picture of Wisdom and Boldness is already a must hear for open-minded fans.



Unknown Metalhead
Speci | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I've been looking forward to this release. City of Dis was really enjoyable. "Genious" might be jumping the gun a little, but it's still very good. And it's not the factthat they combine genres that makes them good, its the unique melodies and writing that does it.
Unknown Metalhead
Dr. M | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I wish these guys would get a tenth of the pub that goes to Opeth. They are every bit as good songwriters, if not better. The genius of this band is that they do mix several styles and do not sound forced at all.
Unknown Metalhead
M. Mooring | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Thanks for your feedback--Points well made. In truth, I was being somewhat flip in my use of the term, as it seemed appropriate in the context of my metaphor. I DO think The Mass are uncommonly good at combining styles though. And no, it’s not difficult to clash genres together–to turn that into something worthwhile takes a lot more talent. I’ve given plenty of higher scores, and I don’t think this will end up on my best of year list, but I always appreciate hearing something unique, especially when it’s as good as this.
Unknown Metalhead
Sarcastro | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I agree with Jeff. Mixing styles isn`t genius, it`s just jamming two kinds of music together, and it`s easy enough to do. Whether the results are good (Opeth`s prog-metal) or bad (Andrea Lantz`s polka-metal) it`s still only really impressive to someone who`s not completely familiar with both styles. Having said that, these guys are pretty good at what they do. Check out the mp3s on their site.
Unknown Metalhead
Erik | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Much better and heavier than city of dis
Unknown Metalhead
Dunk | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Is genius originality? Or...is it originality paired with skill and passion and all those good things?
Unknown Metalhead
jeff | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
why does any album no matter how shitty it is gets reviewed with great scores and the reviewer calls the head of said bands a "genius". WHY?!?!making shitty music that is an almalgamation of jazz and metal is not something hard to do, metal can be put into almost any genre of music. so calling these guys geniuses is beyond me.
HateDragon's Avatar
HateDragon | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I have to say even though I've been into heavier stuff lately, I like these guys. Originality always intriges me.
Unknown Metalhead
Jason w/MetalReview | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
Great album! Such a breath of fresh air, as they say. 4.5/4.5/5