Album Review

Score 10
Written by Matt Mooring
Published on 7/11/2005
Just months after offering fans a scintillating preview of their new album with the March into the Sea EP, Pelican unleash their second full length effort, The Fire In Our Throats Will Beckon the Thaw. March into the Sea contained a 20 minute work up of the title track, which appears here in shorter form, as well as a Justin Broderick remix of the Australasia track “Angel Tears”. At 32 minutes long, March into the Sea was one hell of an appetizer, but fans will relish every ounce of this new effort, and if March into the Sea had you penciling in The Fire In Our Throats Will Beckon the Thaw onto your year end list of favorites, you can ditch the pencil and get out the black magic-fucking-marker.

Like close sonic cousins Isis, Pelican have a distinctly elemental vibe, providing the scenic aerials to compliment Isis’ oceanic tides. The songs soar weightlessly across expansive skies, while the band winds layer upon intricate layer over the framework until the weight is too much for their structures to bare, sending them crashing earthward, twisting and spiraling passionately as they go, equally resenting and relishing their actualization. The open, airy feel is further served by the manner in which the band sculpts the trajectory of the songs, subtly adding texture and density until the songs redline into passionate, tightly wound acrobatics. The transitions are sublime, both in reaching apex and gracefully shifting from crescendo. Pelican stick and move, firing off measures of mouth watering runs and riffs before abandoning one course in favor of building to another, guaranteeing several speaker pointing “that part right there? I fucking love that part” responses from the listener. You know that response? I fucking love that response.

“March into the Sea” has been cleaved in half, the second, atmospheric half undergoing the knife in favor of the fierce, roiling dive bombing of the first. The band takes the polar approach for “Aurora Borealis”, which has the slow turning, antigravity spaciness that the title suggests. “Untitled” has a similarly low key, acoustic bent that somehow manages to be simultaneously insistent and blissful. The longer tracks (five, including “March”) are opulently dynamic, balancing equal measures of billowy atmosphere and dense heft, culminating with the affirming head nodder “Sirius”. Pelican’s evolution from the dense, choppy (but still entirely enjoyable) arrangements from their first self titled EP is highly impressive. The Fire in Our Throats Will Beckon the Thaw is an expertly conceived and executed work, stretching the bounds and shattering the glass ceiling of the instrumental construct. One of the finest albums, of any genre, that you will hear this year.



Unknown Metalhead
usernamesucks | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
@ danny You're actually right for the most part However the definition of song being understood as lyrics or having lyrics is an old English definition. In this day an age there are things considered instrumental songs, and not ‘pieces.”
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 10/2007 | Reply
So I pick up a pelican disc after all the praise and listen.......kind of lame......... listen again..... better....... listen again......... I dig this.......... listen again......wow, I fucking love this disc. I'm terrible with track names (especially instrumentals) but track three is absolutely incredible.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Thank you Mooring.
Unknown Metalhead
Danny | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
So maybe I'm being a little pedantic but my point's still valid, if nothing is sung over a piece of music that piece of music is not a song.
Unknown Metalhead
the jones | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Looks like Danny's getting a little too smart/technical for his own good.
Unknown Metalhead
M. Mooring | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
So an album without vocals is an album without songs? What you're describing is not a songwriting score, but a lyric score. The songwriting score evaluates the writing on the album.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
I think a spoken word album would get a 0 for musicianship...but whatever you use to gauge your shit. I was merely throwing in my two cents.
Unknown Metalhead
Danny | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
well I've clearly misunderstood what was meant by songwriting. For me a song is the lyrics not the music, for instance Bach's 3rd Syphomany or any other classical music without vocals, you wouldn't refer to as a song would you? A song is sung by a vocalist, music is played by musicians. Nothing is sung on this album so a score for song writing can't count in my view. You could substitute songwriting for musicwriting, but music writing is covered in the muscianship score, song writing should only apply to songs, there are no songs on this album because nothing is sung, there are only individual pieces of music and as anyone can tell you a song and a piece of music are not the same, they exist independently of each other. Would you give a spoken word album a score for musicianship becus the vocals were good?
Unknown Metalhead
Danny | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
well I've clearly misunderstood what was meant by songwriting. For me a song is the lyrics not the music, for instance Bach's 3rd Syphomany or any other classical music without vocals, you wouldn't refer to as a song would you? A song is sung by a vocalist, music is played by musicians. Nothing is sung on this album so a score for song writing can't count in my view. You could substitute songwriting for musicwriting, but music writing is covered in the muscianship score, song writing should only apply to songs, there are no songs on this album because nothing is sung, there are only individual pieces of music.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
I think you've got it all wrong man....songwriting, for me at least, is how well the riffs and parts of a song flow and interact with each other. The better/higher the score, the more seemless the songs move along without sounding forced. Musicianship is a score that reflects how well-versed the members of the band are with their respective instruments.
Unknown Metalhead
Higgins | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
Danny, I find it hard to believe you're actually being serious here, but one never knows. Giving a 6 to songwriting means the songs on the album were perfectly written. And "written", in terms of music, means "composed", and has absolutely NOTHING to do with actual written words.
Unknown Metalhead
Danny | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
6 was giving for song writing, songs are the lyrics of the piece, not the music, the muscianship score counts for the music. Giving a 6 for song writing suggests great lyrical content and has little to do with the music, thats why giving a 6 for song writing on a instrumental album is more than a little odd.
powerade's Avatar
powerade | posted on 4/2007 | Reply
ha. the previous lash is very amusing. does the music just write itself?
Unknown Metalhead
Danny | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
6/6/6 ?? how do u give 6 out of 6 for song writing on an instrumental album? meh n/m brilliant music
Mark's Avatar
Mark | posted on 12/2006 | Reply
I'd put Pelican just a notch above Cult of Luna, and Red Sparowes nowhere near them. Mouth of the Architect take the genre to a whole new level.
Unknown Metalhead
Mark (from China) | posted on 12/2006 | Reply
Pelican is great. But Red Sparrow is better. And Cult of Luna is the best.
onthedownlow's Avatar
onthedownlow | posted on 9/2006 | Reply
This is just awesome. They're really, really, good live too; although I expect that most of you already know that..
Unknown Metalhead
the jones | posted on 8/2006 | Reply
This is good, quite good actually. I'm just not sure I understand all the over-top praising of these guys. Nothing on this CD 'blows my mind', etc. But, to each his own. Good stuff, keep rocking.
Radar's Avatar
Radar | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
I love this album, and I need to check out their back catalogue, but does anyone else have a problem with the drumming? To me, it seems too lethargic for the sound they're going for.
Unknown Metalhead
Ohgr | posted on 5/2006 | Reply
Very Very Cool album. I'm a huge Neurosis fan and Isis fan, so this Somber Heavy music really appeals to me.
Unknown Metalhead
windowlicker | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
A sonic masterpiece. Even my girl who dislikes any metal or anything remotely close was like "this is fucking awesome"! Then she fell asleep drooling on my shoulder. This pelican disc will do that. I love the ambient and atmospheric,yet heavy music like this..Isis and Nuerosis included. These boys are on the same level, without a doubt. A cool review as well!!
Unknown Metalhead
Hood | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
amazing album!
Unknown Metalhead
dog_stomper | posted on 9/2005 | Reply
I heard one of their songs on the radio once, a good word and a good song = me buying the album.
Unknown Metalhead
bosredsoxgzr | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
lee, mandrake is their best but, to clean and dance around the kichen, its lavatory love machine. its just so much fun
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
But Hellfire club is not their best work. Mandrake is great Heavy metal album.
Unknown Metalhead
bosredsoxgzr | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
i thought i was the only one who liked edguy. lavatory love machine is my fave tune to clean the kitchen to. anyway matt nice review. i'll have to check this group out.sounds good from what everyone says.
Unknown Metalhead
Beaddloyeragg | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Yodll ov si'niil Lahiem ricto nocctdo flivadr lo'ckkaol sedlo--hits si ocol! Olny taht m'dae ssene!!
Unknown Metalhead
Harley Carlson | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
I'm gonna have to check this out.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Bravo yourself Greg, lol funny.... Yes, everytime I hear that opening bar to lavatory love machine I have shat myself... I have taken to just listining to it on the pot now....
Unknown Metalhead
T.E.A. Sucks (Unless... | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
It does: obviously Frank got to T.E.A....because he all of a sudden turned off the mentally-debilitating caps. And the elderly don't need to be abused...just pushed out to sea on an iceberg. The word "poser" is stupid any way you spell it (especially the French way); if we were checking grammar we'd all have grammar books shoved up our asses. Pat: you need a writting class apparently. Typos are one thing...laziness is another (and I'm sure someone's going to try to find a mistake in this rante--rant). Passive voice rocks by...the...way. Not btw. Forget internet "lingo". Now I hope this feud will end, and people will follow Amorphis' example and rant about Pelican.
Unknown Metalhead
greg | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
i salute you. edguy is awesome. the only reason i dont listen to them too often is i dont like having to change my shorts every couple of minutes. I will def. check this one out. I really like neurosis and godflesh and the like. I really havent been able to get enough of Panopticon and The Ocean's fluXion since it came out i probably listen to at least one song from each album daily. the last time i heard pelican was on the untitled ep. good but im not really the type of guy that can listen to drone too much. but this review makes me think this has more variety and coupled with the earlier review of march into the sea im gonna have to hear this. thanks, great review.
Unknown Metalhead
Amorphis | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
To me, this review is based on the excitement and anticipation of what this album could possibly be like and not necessarily what it actually is. I, too, was extremely excited once I got a hold of it. But after listening all the way through several times, I certainly don't feel as though it deserves three 6's. It certainly isn't bad, but I don't think it touches Australasia. Hopefully it'll grow on me, which I'm sure it will, but not to the point where I give it straight 6's.
Unknown Metalhead
theelderlyabser | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
this review is classic the dialogue is some of the nerdiest shit i have ever read, high school really must have sucked for you matt
Patrick's Avatar
Patrick | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
"The fire in ouR throuats" Type-o son, grow a brain.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Isn't the the English way to spell it, like humor and humour? What are you in Subway U? This is like a landmark lash agreeing with the Elderly Abuser who has called me a fag at least 6000 times. See this is how I feel when you guys rag Edguy..... I find their music to move me with " an open, airy feel is further served by the manner in which the band sculpts the trajectory of the songs, subtly adding texture and density until the songs redline into passionate, tightly wound acrobatics. The transitions are sublime, both in reaching apex and gracefully shifting from crescendo." Especially Lavatory Love machine, which causes me to scream out loud in orgasmic frenzy while pointing at the speaker speaker “that part right there? I fucking love that part” I have similiar moments when contemplating the inner majestic workings of the entire opus of "Tooth and Nail" and the latest Entwine album.
Unknown Metalhead
Nick | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
...yep def. worth all 6's
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Matt is fine, he is just arty at times..lol. You would call me a fag too for some of the stuff I like, avantegarde to me is just not stuff like this, to hard to listen too and I am lazy and simple.
Unknown Metalhead
davefons | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
you dicks are still finding new and exciting ways to spell poser.
Unknown Metalhead
theelderlyabuser | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
to frank: good attempt at trying to be funny. unfortunatly you failed miserably, which im sure isnt your first taste of failure and surely wont be your last. anyways, you would like this stuff, its great for kids who still havent come out of the closet and still want to be respected in the metal community without looking too gay, posuer
Unknown Metalhead
circus_brimstone | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
I think using the passive voice is fine, occasionally. /descriptivist
Unknown Metalhead
PelicanPants | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Yes these guys fucking rock, their past 3 releases and the DVD. To bad i couldn't get the money for the Pre-Order
Unknown Metalhead
Frank | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
1.) To THEELDERLYABUSER: Turn down the caps lock, granny. Stop posting here. No one reads the drivel you post, anyway. 2.) To Patrick: "Why not, "The Fire in out throats beckons the thaw"" Maybe because "The Fire in Out Throats" makes no sense. Dumbass. 3.) To Matt: Great review. I will soon be getting this.
Unknown Metalhead
THEELDERLYABUSER | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
LEE I ALSO FOUND THE HUMOR IN THIS REVIEW AND QUESTIONED WHETHER OR NOT THE REVIEWER IS SERIOUS OR JUST A SENSATIVE GUY GETTING IN TOUCH WITH HIS FEMININE SIDE. WITH THE AMOUNT OF CRAP THEY REVIEW HERE ITS ANYBODY GUESS
Patrick's Avatar
Patrick | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Why not, "The Fire in out throats beckons the thaw" Somebody get all these dipshit bands into a writing class.
Unknown Metalhead
Speci | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
I always feel like a hypocrite for disliking Isis, but loving these guys. I can't help it, though. Pelican have something that Isis doesn't, that's really hard to put our finger on, but it makes all the differance.
Unknown Metalhead
eh? | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
one of the best cds ever recorded in the history of music. holy shit balls!
Unknown Metalhead
xknifeintheback | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
...will be one of my all-time favorites, when it's all said and done. This band never fails to amaze me, and this cd is no exception. The 666 score is well deserved. Flawless.
Unknown Metalhead
iowametal | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
This album is nothing short of amazing. Like their previous two releases, massively heavy, yet not necesarilly classifiable as metal. Anyway, it's very debatable that they're better than ISIS. Somehow they seem even more... original and dynamic, more refreshing and interesting. More melodic too, which makes the heavy even heavier. These guys are about to blow up. This album will be huge. Watch out for Lair of the Minotaur, too. Brutal crushing death!!
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
great review, matt; some of the best moments on Isis' last two full-lengths are instrumental, so i get a really good idea of what these guys sound like See this review guys? I fucking love reviews like this.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
But this review makes me laughs, I am sure they are awesome but....lol but I dont know if I listen to music subtly adding texture and density until the songs redline into passionate, tightly wound acrobatics" Nice review anyways, but I think I wouldn't touch this with a 10 foot pole. I saw Isis once tme and they kept blowing their shit and then got pissed and this fat guy in the crowd called them a bunch of art pussies and they stormed off the stage.
Unknown Metalhead
robontehcob | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
i 100% agree. this band never disappoints me and they remain one of the few bands i can purchase anything they release without doubt it will suck.