Album Review

Score 8.6
Written by Tim Pigeon
Published on 1/19/2005
It’s nice to see that those boys in Sweden are staying busy. Scar Symmetry is a melodic death supergroup comprised of members that have very formidable groups of their own. On guitar is Jonas Kjellgren of vicious death/thrashers Carnal Forge and Per Nilsson of Altered Aeon. Henrik Ohlsson (Theory in Practice) handles the drumming while Kenneth Seil strums the bass. Lastly, the very talented vocalist of Unmoored, Christian Alvestam, provides one of the best performances in the genre.

Refreshingly, the end result sounds nothing like any of their original bands. What I’m hearing is basically everything that Soilwork is trying to sound like, but Scar Symmetry have them beat in a few critical areas. First are the majestic vocals of Christian. He roars like a beast and could easily land a singing post in a big rock band with his smooth clean vocals. What’s really impressive is that the music accommodates both styles well. There are beefy and thrashy rhythm riffs abound, which act as the main foundation, but also adept soloing by Kjellgren (my apologies if it’s Nilsson). Synthesizer usage is prominent, mostly in the background, sometimes like a solo. Ohlsson’s drumming is impeccable, but the dude was in Theory in Practice, so this is expected. Furthermore, the production is perfect, with a thick guitar tone, sharpness on the high notes, a good balance between the instruments, etc.

The twelve songs enclosed have a very modern metal sound, and while the song composition is lacking in complexity, the fact that I’ve listened to this at least ten times without tiring of the hooks is a testament to its quality. Symmetric in Design is the type of album where everyone will have a different set of favorite songs, depending on which riffs and choruses appeal to them most. “Orchestrate the Infinite” is my fave, opening with a choppy Illdisposed feel, before transferring to a beautiful chorus. They maintain at least a mid-paced tempo throughout the album, so even the clean passages are carried along at a fast clip. “Seeds of Rebellion” and “Reborn” are another pair of hits, but ones that lend themselves to another comparison as one of our boardies noted – riffs similar to Edge of Sanity.

This album might be the pinnacle of this growing post-Gothenburg form of melodic death metal that tries to combine everything: growls, clean vocals, keyboards, solos, and thrashy riffs. Their vocals are better, their riffs have more bite, their rhythm section is tighter, and their synthesizers give more atmosphere. If you liked where Raunchy and Soilwork have been taking their sound on their last few albums, then Scar Symmetry is a must-have for your collection. They’re Gr-r-r-r-eat!



James's Avatar
James | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
I agree that posers and elitists are ennoying, but you can dislike a band if you think their music sucks.
Alex's Avatar
Alex | posted on 11/2007 | Reply
These guys are amazing. Fuck anyone who doesnt like them. Do you know what is more annoyign than a poser? An elitist.
Unknown Metalhead
J213 | posted on 6/2007 | Reply
pretty good album....did anyone else notice the similarity between their lead player and alex skolnick?
Unknown Metalhead
majog | posted on 3/2007 | Reply
this barely feels like metal every chorus is cheesy and poopy as fuckt...i dont understand why everyone likes this band
Matt's Avatar
Matt  | posted on 7/2006 | Reply
So sad, that so many people are so intent on hating other people's bands rather than liking their own.
Unknown Metalhead
Metalrocker31 | posted on 7/2006 | Reply
I just heard "Chaosweaver" today. It was fucking amazing. I am definately going to check this one out.
Unknown Metalhead
dumsbhit | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
gay band emulating a gay band. this is shit music for posers - as expected most ppl here like em.
Unknown Metalhead
rattle | posted on 6/2006 | Reply
The elderly abuser must be no more than 12 years old. And dont fuckin deny it coz it's so obvious. He possibly shouts: HAIL KORN every morning
Unknown Metalhead
m4ggot | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I think I'm getting sick of all the soilwork comparisons.. This band is just so much better and this album probably better than anything soilwork ever made. "but also adept soloing by Kjellgren (my apologies if it’s Nilsson)" for metal's sake, just look it up if you don't know. Great album 10/10
Unknown Metalhead
m4ggot | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
I think I'm getting sick of all the soilwork comparisons.. This band is just so much better and this album probably better than anything soilwork ever made. "but also adept soloing by Kjellgren (my apologies if it’s Nilsson)" for metal's sake, just look it up if you don't know. Great album 10/10
Unknown Metalhead
kkkkkkkkkkkkkk | posted on 2/2006 | Reply
apparently your stupid ass does not know how soilwork sounds like.
Unknown Metalhead
BULSHITOLOGY TAKEN SERIOUSLY ! | posted on 2/2006 | Reply
Really now, How logical is it to compare this band with soilwork. Lololololol you motherfuckers are obviously retarded. Its better to do a nevermore comparison than this "soilwork" thing. There are so many stupid fucks in this planet that you will be
Unknown Metalhead
sathanas | posted on 5/2005 | Reply
so i finally broke down and bought the japanese import version. the album is great, but i'm disappointed i paid so much just to have the 2nd track "2012 - The Demise of the 5th Sun" get cut off in mid solo. that's pretty fucking lame. the length of the song is supposed to be 3:51... well on the import i got the song is only 2:56 :( now i have to send it back (cd universe better take it back) and wait for the nuclear blast u.s. version. lame.
Unknown Metalhead
scock | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
http://www.metalblade.de/scarsymmetry.html There seems to be a sample of the track "Reborn"
Unknown Metalhead
jon | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
does this band have a website? id like to hear some mp3's, but cant find any.
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
*points below*
Unknown Metalhead
the elderly abuser | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
YOU STUPID PIECE OF FUCKING SHIT, THIS SUCKS LIKE YOUR MOM SUCKED CORN OUT OF MY ASS. THE REVIEWER IS A RETARTED MONGOLOID ASSHOLE WHO HAS SHIT FOR BRAIN, STUPID FUCKING BITCH, STUPID FUCKING ALBUMS, I HATE YOU ALL AND HATE THIS ALBUM EVEN WORSE. ASSHOLES. DUMB SHITS, IDIOTS.
Unknown Metalhead
drtbag- | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
i got this shit ages before it was released and it owns the new soilwork album.
PainMiseryDeath's Avatar
PainMiseryDeath | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Where did that Raunchy comparison come from?
lordperrin's Avatar
lordperrin | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Listened to it all the way through. Very much like new soilwork with more pop-ish clean vocals. Highly dissapointing.
Unknown Metalhead
bobbydrake | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
if this band is worse than soilwork, they must be pretty horrible. since you compared them to edge of sanity i think i'll check them out though.
CannibalDave's Avatar
CannibalDave | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
It's pretty good. The music is good, production is good, but the clean vox are not on par with Soilwork's, in my opinion.
lordperrin's Avatar
lordperrin | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Not too sure about this one, I liked Soilwork up to Predator's Portrait, but after that they started infusing far too much pop and nu metal into their sound, which kinda sucks. I'll give this a download I guess..
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
It does sound really fucking good. Need some new sweedish injection in my life.
Unknown Metalhead
xesbx | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I gotta hear this! I totally dig all the mentioned bands, so this has got to be fucking HUGE!
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/MetalReview | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
...is my favorite album of 2005 so far. I would of scored it the same.
Unknown Metalhead
filth | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I'll check into them.
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
nicely reviewed Tim, as usual.
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I'd give it a 9.5/10, which is comparable to the score given. THIS BAND RULES, END OF FUCKING STORY.