Album Review

Score 9.2
Written by Justin Bean
Published on 1/12/2005
As with many younger American metal enthusiasts, my love of metal has its origins in the punk and hardcore genres. Noticing my chosen path of 'weakness', a friend’s older brother lent me three albums that have forever changed the course of my musical explorations—In Flames’ The Jester Race, At The Gates’ Slaughter of the Soul, and, last but not least, Dark Tranquility’s The Gallery. Presently In Flames is working furiously to make nu-metal ‘cool’ and At The Gates has broken up with its members failing, for the most part, to scratch the surface of their prior greatness. This has left Dark Tranquillity, among a dwindling handful of other genre mates, to wield the torch of Gothenburg melodic death metal. The question that must be asked is whether or not, after six full length releases and a number of EPs, they are up to the task of carrying and continuing this rich legacy. The answer is yes, absolutely.

Staying attune with the strong opening heard on Damage Done (which I will refer to throughout the review, since Character and Damage Done have many similarities) that foregoes any synthesized instrumental track, Character opens with an extended drum fill followed by, surprisingly enough, blast beats, the trademark death metal percussive maneuver that DT generally seemed to shy away from. As the immediately recognizable dual guitar harmonies kick into some quality melodic thrash, you know Dark Tranquillity is back and kickin’ it, not necessarily ‘old skool’ style (the mandatory second part of any phrase ending with ‘kickin in’), but with their trademark combination of decidedly soothing, cool melodies buttressed by pure death metal aggression. That said, with an opening as powerful and convincing as “The New Build” I was worried, upon reflecting how often a great opening can easily give way to many a weaker track, that my optimism would be ill founded. I was wrong indeed.

Anyone familiar with Damage Done will notice the evident continuation of the sound developed on said album. At times the keyboard-backed harmonies on Character come dangerously close to blurring the line between it and Damage Done, but early on I could see that the song writing has been greatly improved upon for this release, adding to the disc’s overall cohesion. When I think of the many bands trying in one form or another to emulate the sound pioneered in part by Dark Tranquillity (As I Lay Dying, Unearth, Enforsaken, etc.), one of the key dividers between the ‘true’ genre-definers and the imitators is the amount of skill displayed in song writing. On Character, DT has, to a higher degree than was heard on any previous releases (except perhaps on The Mind’s I, which I thought was superbly focused as far as song writing goes), truly honed their writing capabilities.

This is not to say that Character is without its flaws (it didn’t get a triple six, now did it?). After three tracks of nothing but solid melodic death metal eliciting nary a complaint, speed gives way to a more unhurried pace on “The Endless Feed”, a keyboard driven track that just doesn’t match up to the preceding songs in catchiness or creativity. But not to worry; the intensity is given a swift shove back in the proper direction and “Lost To Apathy”, while still displaying prominent keyboard work, rekindles any interest lost during the prior track. This sort of ebb and flow makes an appearance every so often, but its negative effect is minimal. Lesson learned: Keep on thrashin’.

The production is excellent and offers a clear presentation of DT’s delicate balance of beauty and brutality. If I had to nitpick any one part of the recording, I would say that the recording could benefit from a bit more bass overall, but the levels are well mixed, especially between the keyboard and guitars, which can indeed make or break an album.

Dark Tranquillity has shown that while times and styles change, there is an approach to this inevitable evolution that keeps intact the integrity of the genre and its diverse styles and forms. Any fan of their later work, from Projector to Damage Done, I have no doubt will enjoy Character. While the days of The Gallery and The Mind’s I are clearly gone, Character provides good reason to be pleased with Dark Tranquillity’s development as musicians.






Unknown Metalhead
Herodian | posted on 2/2007 | Reply
@Ash, I second that, the early gothenburg scene paved the way for some of the best bands we hear today.
Ash's Avatar
Ash | posted on 1/2007 | Reply
Sdfl, You have missed out on the Gothenburg Scene. I honestly think the melodic death metal pioneered by In Flames, Dark Tranquillity and At the Gates has a very important place in every metal fan and anybody who really thinks this sub-genre is shit should shoot themselves! The Absence(From your grave) and Dark Tranquillity(Character) really really made 2005/2006 a year for me to smile
Unknown Metalhead
sfdl; | posted on 1/2007 | Reply
I've never really been able to get into this type of metal but my friend told me to check out this cd and damage done as well. I was skeptic at first but HOLY SHIT, once I started listening I haven't stopped yet, fucking awesome band.
Unknown Metalhead
Perennial Quest | posted on 12/2006 | Reply
Only a guy named musclehead would use the word "witchu" on a metal site. Well done.
Unknown Metalhead
Prav the Morbid Chav | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
This album is absolutely stupendous. Probably my 3rd favourite album after Whoracle (In Flames) and Damage Done. I do prefer Damage Done to this, but really the albums are as good as each other, that being excellent. It's a matter of personal taste. This one is a bit heavier than Damage Done in parts.
Unknown Metalhead
\m/usclehead | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
I know it's been a while since this album came out last January, and there have been a few excellent Melodic Death Metal releases this year, but I hope that we haven't forgotten DT when we're putting together our end of the year lists. This has been a consistent listen in my CD player, even though there were a few other kick-ass releases. Scar Symmetry, Black Dahlia Murder, Darkest Hour(like it or not), The Absence, Nightrage, etc. have all put out some nice stuff, but DT definitely has to get the nod for best Melo-Death album of the year. bpugh86, totally agree witchu. It makes me a little sad to think about In Flames, I was such a big fan, hope their new album can bring them back, we'll see in the spring of 2006.
Unknown Metalhead
bpugh86 | posted on 3/2005 | Reply
I agree with Dan. An absolutely amazing album. When I thought of "Swedish Death Metal" the tired recent works of In Flames came to mind. This CD is so refreshing, original and well, great it puts those thoughts to shame.
Unknown Metalhead
dan | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Im a collector and this CD has stayed in my walkman for 5 days despite owning 700 other original CDs. This is a absolutely stunning record from a great band who I had the pleasure of meeting and having a beer and a toke with. Long live DT
Kevin's Avatar
Kevin | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Just an unbelievable album all around. One of the best I own
Unknown Metalhead
Nightcom | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Such yummy perfection.
Unknown Metalhead
justin | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
nope. definitely a triple 5.5
Unknown Metalhead
Brandon | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
just got it- pretty good, after 1st listen, can't say it's better than Damage Done. and reviewer: you DID give it a triple 6.
Chris's Avatar
Chris | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Dark Tranquillity owns, and always did...the best Melodic Death Metal band since At The Gates. period
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I'm all about Strapping Young Lad.
Unknown Metalhead
Harley w/MetalReview | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
...THE BLACK DAHLIA MURDER always rubs me the right way when I am working out.
Unknown Metalhead
Amorphis | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
At first, I thought Character sounded a little too similar to Damage Done. But after a few listens, I realized that the new album was eons ahead of Damage Done. The songs on Character are much more complex and more difficult to get into than the ones off Damage Done. I never thought they'd come close to topping The Mind's I, but this one may very well do it. Contrary to the reviewer, my favorite tracks would be "The Endless Feed, Dry Run, and My Negation."
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I was only kidding you, don't take it serious, you write good reviews. I had my Alt phases and other things
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I think it's a wee bit early to proclaim this the best of 2005. Heard Scar Symmetry or new Blood Red Throne? Maybe new Equilibrium or Moonsorrow? I'd put them in the same league with Dark Tranquillity for 2005's best.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I can't say that DT sees much time in my gym rotation. More like Vader, Deathchain, Dillenger, Amenta, Dew-Scented, Blood Red Throne, etc. etc.
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
i'd prefer something a little more intense or brutal, like the amenta or yyrkoon..but uhh, if you like to thrust iron to keyboards and catchy riffs, hey, to each his own
Unknown Metalhead
Harley w/MetalReview | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Yeah, I am not as in good of shape as I used to be. I was kidding anyway. I know Tim can outlift me, plus, I am not really all that hairy. B) Damn, I need to take my ass back to the gym. Blast my triceps while blasting some DT.
drew's Avatar
drew | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
i'm like robin williams, so i guess thats why i review so much around here.
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
personally i dont care who's hairier or who's got the hugest balls, this was a damn fine review and im looking forward to this album good job justin
Unknown Metalhead
Matt w/MetalReview | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Tim can bench more than you can deadlift.
Unknown Metalhead
davefons | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
should just be glad I didn't review this album, you probably wouldnt be very happy with the scores i gave it. This is a well constructed reveiw though justin, good show.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Maybe I should just pull rank. haha. Dibs on the Testament and Opeth whenever they come out.
Unknown Metalhead
Harley w/MetalReview | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I don't really see what the difference is in who reviews what. Tim has been on the team for a long long time but that doesn't mean that a new kid like myself or Justin doesn't know as much or more than a team veteran. For the record, I was gonna do this album as well but Justin reserved it first. I think next time we have three people that wanna do the same album we should have a deadlift contest. OR a who's hairier than who contest. I never saw a pic of Justin so I am not sure how he would fair. Looks like it's between me and Diesel. hahaha By the way, Justin, great fuckin' review man. My thoughts exactly.
PainMiseryDeath's Avatar
PainMiseryDeath | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Best album of 2005
Unknown Metalhead
wind | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I didnt think you were metalcore, I just know Dez is the resident DT-mellodeath fanatic, so when such an epic band comes through I expect that hes gonna review it. Nice review though, I certainly agree with the scores. Although I dont think the new one sounds that much like damage done, I think its a step back to the gallery and minds I era
Unknown Metalhead
WulfWhar | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Another solid effort by these cats, they just keep coming through with great material.
Unknown Metalhead
Justin Bean | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Lee and Wind - I have to make one small comment in my defense; the transition anecdote i start the review with, from metalcore to metal, took play 7 years ago (when i was 13). also, i wasnt a metalcore kid. i was, like it says, a hardcore and punk kid. booyakasha everyone else, thanks for the kind words.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I thought it was a fine review. My scores would've been in the same ballpark.
Unknown Metalhead
McGahee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
is better than Damage Done, and most people I know personally happen to agree with me. Nice score on the review.
Unknown Metalhead
Will | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
Damage Done is better than this album, but it seems not many people share mt opinion. Still enjoyable though.
Lee's Avatar
Lee | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
same thing Wind. I hate when the metal core kids start listining to actual Metal.....lol
Unknown Metalhead
j | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
good review - well written, and informed (unlike many others that appear here)...great album, great band...
Unknown Metalhead
wind | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
who is this guy and why didnt diesil review this ?
Ryan's Avatar
Ryan | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
I think I would have actually probably given this a 6 on Songwriting. Fucking solid through and through.
Unknown Metalhead
Rufus | posted on 1/2005 | Reply
good review sir. This is without a doubt, Dark Tranquillity's best album since the Gallery. I'm sure DT fans everywhere will love what they hear, I know I did.