Album Review

Score 7.6
Written by Tim Pigeon
Published on 5/18/2004
I applaud bands that have the ambition to try new things, ones that take fragments from styles all over the metal map, and then merge them together in the hopes of producing something epic and transcendent. Disillusion, hailing from Germany, are one such band. Back to Times of Splendor is their first full-length album, and while there are a few kinks to be worked out, it shows the substantial promise latent in these three Germans. The obvious band to compare them to is Opeth, with slight similarities in sound, but much more so in structure. Two songs exceed 14 minutes in length, and another hits 8:27. Within these marathon tracks there are numerous peaks and valleys, fast parts and slow, hard parts and soft. But where Opeth likes to turn dark acoustic, Disillusion turns to neo-folk influences; and where Akerfeldt & Co. descend into near-death metal, Disillusion break out into melodic death. Certain passages bring to mind the music of Suidakra.

The vocals of Vurtox are among the most impressive attributes of this album. His range of styles is enviable, with a capable shout that is balanced by an impressive singing voice that hits a few different registers and tempos. Although, he occasionally uses sounds effects or sounds enhanced. Maybe that adds to the epicness of it all? The guitarwork of Vurtox and Rajk Barthel is deftly layered and evocative, while sporadic use of keys and violins amplify the atmosphere. Not wanting to leave anyone out, Jens Maluschka does a fine, unflashy job behind the drumkit. This is all tied together with a production that is near-perfect for the lighter passages, but becomes muddier when they crank up the heaviness.

“And the Mirror Cracked” is a great choice for an album opener, as it bursts out of the gate aggressively, but then quickly establishes what Disillusion is all about. Hard verses segue into folky choruses, which then give way to a clean/acoustic interlude, then eventually back to the crunch. The title track is one of those marathon tracks, and that’s too bad because it could be one of the year’s top songs with a few minutes shaved off. Somber violins gently pull you into the song, and the following violin/thrash riff combo is one of the most compelling chunks of metal I’ve heard in awhile. A few awkward segments mar what is otherwise a remarkable buildup in intensity from the complete halt that comes at 7:15 in. The Opeth styling rears its head here, but even more so in the next track, “A Day by the Lake”, which flows much like their song “Harvest”. The sixth and final track, “The Sleep of Restless Hours”, stretches on for a ridiculous 17 minutes. There are plenty of nifty pieces which don’t flow together that well, although the five-minute outro is just fantastic.

Listening to this from beginning to end can be quite a rewarding, yet draining, experience. It’s very apparent that Disillusion display serious potential, and my hope is that age and experience will help them to fully realize that potential on their next album. Regardless, Back to Times of Splendor is a promising, ambitious debut that fans of more adventurous metal will enjoy.



deltawing's Avatar
deltawing | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
Incredible album, 666.
Unknown Metalhead
Speci | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
I finally got around to listening to this album in it's entirety, and it would have been near perfect if the singer could actually sing. The guy is so unapollogetically off-key during all the clean vocals, that it's ridiculous. He has a nice growl, though, and the melodies are good. Just teach that guy to stay on key! I also think, that if this album had been released today, it would have instantly been labeled as 'trendy-emo-core crap" and disregarded.
Unknown Metalhead
jon | posted on 10/2004 | Reply
this album is now one of my favorites. it's one of the few (if not the only) album i've heard that combines this much clean vocals with melodic-death guitar work so successfully. i love the amount of emotion in the writing...the music just carries you. fantastic album: brilliant writing, fine musicianship, and packed with sweeping emotion. i agree about the 5 min outro...excellent.
Unknown Metalhead
WT | posted on 7/2004 | Reply
Just got this album, it's absolutely fantastic.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim | posted on 6/2004 | Reply
thanks, were it not for songs two and three, this would've been a 5+ for sure.
Unknown Metalhead
Wrathchild | posted on 6/2004 | Reply
Great review as always Tim, I really dug this album.
Unknown Metalhead
russell | posted on 6/2004 | Reply
this band is much more talented than in flames and I don't see a comparison. this band has lots of potential, and I hope they realize it, great album
Unknown Metalhead
Opeth | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
cool band, great album
Unknown Metalhead
skullfuck | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
After reading your review, I picked this CD up, and I fucking dig the hell out of it. This will without a doubt be on my top 10 list this year.
Unknown Metalhead
crusher | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
well, actually i like the song. i think i'm going to buy the album soon.
Unknown Metalhead
Slash | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
Starts off good, then it hits the SUPER gay melo-pussy N*Flames choruses and it fucking ruins the whole damn song. Melodeath used to be something that was metal. Now I tend to avoid anything called melodeath because it probably falls closer to the fagcore genre rather than metal. Good review, this definatelty doesn't deserve a 666. This guys vocals are also very annoying. The "harsh" vocals have a definate metalcore feel to them and his clean vocals with the super homo choruses make it sound like the latest rock band off MTV. Sorry, the "melodeath" element, which is more like mallcore, is too fucking shitty to give this anywhere near a 666. If you are a N*Flames fan or enjoy the latest offerings from Soilwork, you wil love this shit. The songs, although long, doesnt mean these guys know wtf they are doing. There's a whole bunch of crap strung together. These songs could be all 4 minutes long and have the same impact. I agree with the 4.5/4.5/5 rating completely. It's very fair. Won't be on my Top10. Why? Arsis, Ayreon, Borknagar, Finntroll, Morgion, Orphaned Land, Lunaris, Therion, Ensiferum, and Decapitated are better than this to name a few.
Unknown Metalhead
Ian | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
cross boundaries. They're probably the only band I've heard that can successfully incorporate three or more different styles into a single musical phrase and keep it entirely coherent and great to listen to. This is easily the best debut of the year and almost undoubtedly a top ten pick.
lee's Avatar
lee | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
likes to hear stuff that wanders on forever with 90 different styles. I think 666 should be reserved for an album that crosses all boundaries, not niche stuff that is incrediable for what it is, but doesn't have that totall perfection a score like that suggest.
Unknown Metalhead
Ian | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
I might have to write a review of this myself. It's a fucking 666 if ever I've heard one.
Unknown Metalhead
erik | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
my vote for album of the year so far.
Unknown Metalhead
Tim P. | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
Metal Blade has been doing a fine job of signing talent lately. I see great things in Disillusion's future.
Unknown Metalhead
Ty@MetalReview | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
An absolutly fantastic album. Some of the best of 2004,IMO!
Ryan's Avatar
Ryan | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
i want to hear it as well.
Unknown Metalhead
Paul | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
A Suidakra reference?? Must hear this!
Unknown Metalhead
MC | posted on 5/2004 | Reply
Nice review...I'm intrigued now.