Album Review

Score 9.4
Written by Chris McDonald
Published on 11/5/2009
Nile’s growth rate has been off the charts since the release of what was, in my view, their break through album in Annihilation of the Wicked. Between the long-awaited arrival of a stable drum presence in George Kollias and the superb production of Neil Kernon, Annihilation made for one of tech-death’s most powerful and memorable exercises. Ithyphallic, a top-tier album of its own, largely followed in the footsteps of its predecessor in approach and sound, and Those Whom The Gods Detest, the third outing of the Kollias era, does as well. But goddamn if Nile hasn’t stepped up every single aspect of their craft on this recording. From the band’s always-stunning musicianship to without a doubt the best production job they’ve had to date, the sheer technical marvel of Those Whom the Gods Detest is exceeded only by quite possibly the strongest batch of songs they’ve ever concocted.

Few would deny at this stage in the game that Nile have found their formula and are sticking to it. The band has proved in recent years an almost miraculous ability to meld head-spinning technicality and speed with monumental choruses and gang chants to produce songs both flooring in their velocity and catchy in their overall structure. We all remember the first time we heard the barbarous shouts of  “Cast Down the Heretic” or the gigantic conclusion of  “Eat of the Dead,” and its ability to hammer the fucking point home after blowing you away that has allowed Nile to achieve popularity with a sound that remains the complete opposite of accessible. While many of Nile’s riffs tend to go by in a blur on initial listens, they have a knack for making the overall tone and feel of each song stick, a trait that has made them the envy of many of their tech-death peers.

I’m ranting about this because Those Whom the Gods Detest is perhaps the band’s most triumphant outing in terms of channeling the technical/brutal death metal formula into memorable, distinctive songs. Nile’s ability to create a dark, empowering atmosphere through highly intricate death metal has never been realized more fully, and the reintroduction of Eqyptian atmospheric flourishes (“Kafir!”) adds a mystical feel to the core of the sound that has been absent since the band began toning these elements down from Annihilation onward. Much like the last two albums, the shorter tracks are merciless displays of face-ripping drumming and dexterous guitarwork that sync up so perfectly it's still hard to believe, while the longer songs allow the trio to open up the groovier aspects of their sound (“Utterances ofthe Crawling Dead”) as well as implement more varied tempos and more of those utterly brutal gang chants (the chorus to the title track is what metal is all about, folks).

It's been said many times, but it bears repeating; the addition of George Kollias on drums has opened up new dimensions to Nile’s compositions that weren’t possible before. The dude plays his kit like a man on fire, effortlessly stringing impossible speedy tom rolls with some of the most pummeling blast beats you’re going to hear (check out the roll/blast that opens the verse to “Hittite Dung Incantation”), while leading the songs forward with double-bass work so brutally fast it's sickening. Dallas Toller-Wade’s role as lead vocalist is equally important to Nile’s newly found focus and energy. I challenge anyone to find a vocalist in technical death that can bellow with as much clarity and personality as this skulleted fellow, and it allows for some awesomely sick vocal hooks. Above all, these are just amazingly intense and entertaining death metal songs, and while the core approach is largely unchanged since the last two albums, there’s something about Those Whom the Gods Detest that just screams “career-defining.”

With all the praise I’ve heaped on Nile’s approach to songwriting, I don’t feel that painstaking detail about each track is too necessary here. As previously stated, most of you reading this review have a good idea what to expect from a Nile disc, so I’ll just leave it at this; even from a band we’ve already recognized as leaders in their field, Those Whom the Gods Detest is almost startling in its all-around excellence. It somehow feels like the band’s most complex and accessible work all at once, and the amazing talent that spews from every pore of this album makes it a necessary venture for anyone with even a passing interest in death metal. I’d been fairly confident in recent months that Ulcerate’s Everything Is Fire would be taking the 2009 death metal crown with gusto, but this album has reminded me to never count the veterans out before they’ve had a chance to say their peace. Well done, guys.



The Devil Himself's Avatar
The Devil Himself | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
Most overhyped death metal album of 09.
jertanner's Avatar
jertanner | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
I absolutely second that opinion. Somehow Nile managed to make an album that is so technically complex that it nearly defies gravety and yet it's completely memorable. It almost becomes atmospheric given the speed that songs fly by but just when you've completely zoned out they throw in a little Egyptian-sounding interlude before throwing you right back into the mele. OUTSTANDING!
gap's Avatar
gap | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
This is the best Nile I have heard. I own all their albums and perhaps am not too familiar with there early work. Disclaimer OK. Compared to any other death metal this just reigns supreme. The drumming is amazing as is the demon vocals and the more "clear" ones. The arrangements are superb. No one can touch Nile for pure speed. But on this album we get hooks. What a memorable song from Nile. Well yes. Great stuff which shows the depth of metal musicianship. Am amazing piece of work.
demonik's Avatar
demonik | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
WOW! Had I known that you guys cared this much about what I write, then I would have checked back in sooner. ;) @trezevant Belive it or not, but that ("like Morbid Angel") was actually a piece left from a rant about other metal bands that sound too much like that use a drum machine. I thought I had deleted it all. I know that Morbid Angel has some slower parts as well. I bought their ABC back in the days but lost interest in them after that. I've only briefly listened to their last two cds and I think "plays fast all the time" sums them up pretty good. So to irritate you futher I'm gonna stick with that. And I think a lot of other ppl think that's the definition of MA these days. I've even seen reviwers write that a group sound like MA and they don't mean the slow parts. Fail me all you want, it won't change a damn thing. I've been a metal fan for over 30 years, so I've learned not to care what others think about my taste in music. @Chris First off, I did like you reveiw. It was well written and made me really look forward to this album. We'll just have to agree to disagree on Kollias' attribution to the band. :) I don't have any illusion on changing your mind but just to make my point clearer, I'll dissect a couple of tracks. Track #1 Starts out great and just before the 1 minute mark there's a slower part that's suddenly ruined by a fast double bass. Same thing happens to the slow part in the middle. And at 5:50 there's a fantastic chugga-chugga riff going and once again Kollias upps the tempo with his triggered double bass work. Aaaargh!!! Track #3. Come on!!! He uses the same annoying double bass beat almost the entire time!!! That track ruined the whole album for me. It wasn't untill I started to skip right to track #4 that I discovered how great the title track really is. Only a couple of seconds with irritating bass there. :) I know I'm outnumbered in my dislike of Kollias work and maybe I'm a bit worn out after two decades of death metal. Speed and tech seems to just bore me these days and I want more old school groove, like Entombed. The only death metal album (that I can think of right now) that has impressed me this year is FleshCut's "Gruesome and vile". Fantastic album. @DeathMetalJesus and Reason's Voice I care almost as little about what you think, as Nile cares about what I think.
leott's Avatar
leott | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
Can't say I was impressed by this one right off the bat, but it's grown on me - especially the second half, which is stellar IMO. I must say that I also kind of miss the slower, doomier tracks (I thought these were best emphasized on their older stuff). However, I wouldn't attribute their absence to Kollias' presence - rather, a shift of the band as a whole. I still love Kollias' work, myself.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
Demonik, did you just describe Morbid Angel as a band that "plays fast all the time"? Quit metal and never come back. You have failed.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
I think Kollias has a great sense of groove. There's a reason they didn't start really exploring slower stuff until he joined the band.
Reason's Voice's Avatar
Reason's Voice | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
I concur DMJ, I concur.
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
"Get a new drummer! One that has a sense of where to groove and when to blast." - You're an idiot.
demonik's Avatar
demonik | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
Man...I really wanted to like this album. Black Seeds is a shining star in my cd collection, but the latest albums from Nile have come and gone without leaving much of an impression. I wanted more vocal hooks, more chanting and more slow, doomy parts. To my supprise they added all that but I still hate it. And after playing it for days the judgement still stands. And I now know why... I HATE the drumming! There, I said it. Kollias is fast and technical as hell, no doubt about that. But I think his style is better suited in a band like Morbid Angel, that plays fast all the time. When Nile goes into those dark and groovy riffs he still plays fast. And what is it with those base drums. Yeah, they're trigg'ed up so you can play really fast, BUT YOU DON'T HAVE TO USE THEM ALL THE TIME!!! It's like what they do in those sucky power metal bands, where the double base drums make them sound heavier. Nile doesn't need that. Get a new drummer! One that has a sense of where to groove and when to blast. As it is now I would only give it 5 out of 10. With a better drum track this could have been a 10. I've bought all the Nile cd's, but next time I'm DL it for free first cuz this isn't what I want from them.
mst's Avatar
mst | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Wharwulf, you have to rethink your influence upon my way of thinking!
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
mst has to rethink things.
mst's Avatar
mst | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
As good as Ithyphalic was bad....
novairon's Avatar
novairon | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Can't stop listening to this
Wharwulf's Avatar
Wharwulf | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
This album slays...
Beak's Avatar
Beak | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
First Nile album I've listened to, but I fuckin love this. I'll have to check out their catalog.
vggls1's Avatar
vggls1 | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Nile are nile. An original band both lyrically and musically (judging by the genre they belong) with a very charachteristic sound in which they stay true. For clones, sellouts, trend followers, gore-satan worshipers look elsewhere.
The Devil Himself's Avatar
The Devil Himself | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I keep giving this a chance, and theres some decent stuff on here, but for the most part, it's just Nile by the numbers. Title track is annoying as fuck.
baagism's Avatar
baagism | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Annihilation of the Wicked a breakthrough album? What? In Their Darkened Shrines was far more impressive. I actually thought AotW was Nile going down hill.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Call me an asshole, but I refuse to believe that at this point in their career, Nile is going to release a cd that will grab me by the balls. Even their supposed best work(s) like "Black Seeds" or "Shrines" didn't make me think "WOW", so I just can't see that same style working so well when it's 3-4 cds removed.
CannibalDeath666's Avatar
CannibalDeath666 | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I listend to this album not to long ago the rapid drum beats are what got me hooked on it the album is fuckign amazing
evilsonic's Avatar
evilsonic | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
just great!! a must have.
Reignman35's Avatar
Reignman35 | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Absolutely punishing album... great stuff...
mak28's Avatar
mak28 | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
This album is in all manner, perfect. Songwriting, incredible production standards and mind-boggling technical proficiency. It's ridiculous. In the end this will probably be my favorite Nile but right now it stands as their best since In Their Darkened Shrines. Black Seeds of Vengeance remains the high water mark for me. BTW - it's Utterances of the Crawling Dead
YourMom's Avatar
YourMom | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Wow, this album was a surprise. The first death metal album I've enjoyed in a while, all the more surprising because I thought their last one was as bland and uninspired as they came. With the exception of "4th Arra of Dagon", which is shit, this album slays from beginning to end
hougie's Avatar
hougie | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Must hear.. soon.
lordperrin's Avatar
lordperrin | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
This is pretty good, better than Ith. I dont understand why it's been such a fad recently to badmouth Nile's earlier albums though. Their song writing skill on Black Seeds kicks the crap out of anything since and including Annihilation with only Darkened Shrines coming close. The only thing bad about Black Seeds was the muddy production.
captain's Avatar
captain  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I found Ithylbibblebillcosby to be dull, but this record is thoroughly kicking my ass. THOROUGHLY.
Wyrd's Avatar
Wyrd | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I have never really been a major fan of Immolation, CC or Grave. They're okay but that's about as excited as I can get about them. As for Bolt Thrower they're kind of special for me and can do no wrong..;-) I am not, nor have I ever really been interested in the lyrical content of metal bands. I don't read lyric sheets so don't normally know what you're average death metal band is prattling on about. With Nile it's the eastern influences that they interject into their music that I am now finding boring. As I am now entering my 20th year of listening to Death Metal I am finding that the majority of DM bands to be bland and retreading old ground. That's just me getting bored with standard DM and brutal DM. I am more interest in the proggy side of things with maybe the occasional tech DM thrown in.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
If you're bored with the Egyptian theme, are you likewise bored with Immolation's christian hatred, or Bolt Thrower's war fixation, or Cannibal Corpse's gore obsession or Grave's death worship? I think the Egyptian motif is far more interesting than the thousands of other death metal bands that are content to try and outgross and outshock everyone. And I stand by D&Q. These guys have crushed through five excellent LPs of Immolation by way of Cannibal Corpse death metal. One of the most sadly overlooked USDM bands.
Wyrd's Avatar
Wyrd | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I have close ties with Egypt and I still find it boring. Other than the pyramids what have the Egyptians ever done for us....or was that the Romans..;-)
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
The Egyptian theme is, and will continue to be awesome.
Wyrd's Avatar
Wyrd | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
"Nile are still way above average in the death metal world, but their creative stagnation is starting to put me off." I tend to agree with is. I am so bored with the Egyptian theme. They have painted themselves into a corner. I gave this a spin and thought it was typical Nile, well produced and played well, but still typical Nile which I have grown bored with.
nev_ski's Avatar
nev_ski | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Personally, I have just downloaded it and giving it my first listen and I'm liking it
Haphazard's Avatar
Haphazard | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Even though this is probably their best production, & #5 (whatever ridiculously long Egyptian title it has that I'm too lazy to go look at and type)is an insanely heavy monster of a song, I think there's some truth to them getting a little stale in their songwriting. When they write a slow crusher, it seems to be one of the standout tracks. Otherwise, they tend to lack definition. AOTW struck a great balance with production and creative songwriting w/ both the slower and faster tracks, but since then it seems that only the lurchers reach out and grab me.
PF's Avatar
PF | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I'm really liking this album...every album I've purchased since Black Seeds I'm like...well I'd like to see them top that. And musically...imo...they've done it every time. Bricks were shat over the guitar/drum work at 1:20 of Iskander d'Hul Karnon and subsequently on the other sections of that song that are similar but not exactly the same. Love it. Can't wait to see them in Milwaukee on January 22nd!
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Drawn and Quartered's sound could use about 15 more albums worth of refining before being worthy of mention within that elite group.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
@ trezevant I think it's a bit disingenuous to call any death metal circa 2009 "retread," especially a band that has done it as well as Nile have for as long as they have. There hasn't been much new in death metal in the last ten years, and the best (longer running) bands still going, i.e. Immolation, Bolt Thrower, Drawn And Quartered, Krisiun do little but refine their sound with each album; if that makes them all retreads, well then I guess that's what I'm a fan of. I'll take a new Nile album-that sounds relatively the same-every couple of years over the entire catalog of bands like Bloodbath, Hail of Bullets, The Black Dahlia Murder, Behemoth, Kataklysm etc.
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Yeah that dude must have shit packed in his ears, cause this album is fucking excellent. Get rid of the Egyptgian theme? Then they'd just be another DM band dude, the theme makes them even more special. How the fuck could you not like this?
Reason's Voice's Avatar
Reason's Voice | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Just got it yesterday, so I've only given it a once over, and any Nile album requires multiple listens to digest, but I can at least say it has one of the best overall sounds I've ever heard. So, 11/10 for production. Could end up being one of their best... time will tell. ...Shrines will always be my favorite. And @ DepsendRecords... This album sucks?! You say they've just kept making the same album over and over, so aren't you saying that all Nile sucks then? Either way... ridiculous statement.
FollowChrist's Avatar
FollowChrist | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
This is the only technical metal I like so far out of the(so called tech death).
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I gotta disagree with you here, Chris. As I see it, the only way that this album could be considered an improvement on their past few releases is the increased emphasis on their admittedly-awesome slow parts. Otherwise, this disc is retread through and through. Nile are still way above average in the death metal world, but their creative stagnation is starting to put me off.
konradkantor's Avatar
konradkantor  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I like the new album and think it deserves it's rating, although I would have lessened up a bit on the "songwriting" rating...everything else is perfect. However, my argument is that their best works preceded Annihilation. First off, I would say that Amongst The Catacombs Of Nephren-Ka was one of their best albums. Although their first, they play a style of music that nobody has done before and do it very well. As for their break through Album, I really have to say "In their Darkened Shrines" owns. Although they don't quite display the musicianship of "Annihilation", they make up for it with their epics. Annihilation is a great slab of Brutal-Death, but it probably contains the LEAST amount of variation throughout. Regardless, all Nile albums are fucking incredible...but the newer fans NEED to hear the older stuff as well. I've put my favorite albums in order just for fun: 1. In Their Darkened Shrines 2. Amongst the Catacombs of Nephren-Ka 3. Annihilation of the Wicked 4. Black Seeds of Vengeance 5. Those Whom the Gods Detest 6. Ithyphallic
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Chris, I'm with ya, this'un floors me. It was the first time a Nile album hit me on the first listen, and kept getting better. I'm still little partial to Shrines, but its hard not to call this their best work.
scintilla's Avatar
scintilla | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Deepsend Records thinks these guys are tired?!? Have you listened to most of the bands on your roster??! Yikes.... This album is incredibly catchy and the production/mix is top notch.
Juho's Avatar
Juho  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I would like to get more information about why this album sucks, because I can't find a single reason to justify that claim. An outstanding release for the people, who enjoy this band and this kind of style.
DeepsendRecords's Avatar
DeepsendRecords | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
This album sucks. Gave it a few listens and it's nothing that they haven't already done before. These dude's need to change things up a bit, the whole Egyptian theme is tired. Can't believe critics and fans keep letting these guys get off the hook with releasing the same album over and over again.
Cantona's Avatar
Cantona | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Great album.Now one of THE great metal bands.
Deke''s Avatar
Deke' | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Yes, the chorus to the title track is ridiculously metal. This album has finally made me a full-on Nile fanboy. Fuck us all.
Anxiety Hangover's Avatar
Anxiety Hangover | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
@The Devil Himself Kafir! and the title track are two of the songs I really dig on this album. I love the clean sung chorus of the title track, it's nice to actually have a hook in a death metal song now and again. As for Kafir!, I like the chanting too, not for the mysticism or exoticism, but it provides an interesting counterpoint to the heaviness. Easily the best death metal album of '09. And probably my second favorite Nile record behind ITDS.
The Devil Himself's Avatar
The Devil Himself | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
I can't get into this as much as BSOV or ITDS. Kafir is so fucking annoying with those clean, weird vocals. The title track is equally as gay with the obligitory monk chanting the name of the song/album. Bash away. Is the album bad? No, but I'm not gonna feed the hype.
Juho's Avatar
Juho  | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Best death metal in 09, period.
vggls1's Avatar
vggls1 | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
Best death metal album of the year for me. Not as good as black seeds or In Their Darkened but their third best for sure. Best tracks imo 4th arra of dagon and iskander dhul kharnon.
zekes's Avatar
zekes | posted on 11/2009 | Reply
This album is totally amazing, it may be even better that Annihilation. In a year when Suffocation, Dying Fetus, Belphegor, Vader, and Behemoth all released albums I wouldn't be so rash to determine an album of the year so soon, but this album may just take the cake. Definitely one of my favorite Nile albums yet. . .
bongripper's Avatar
bongripper | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
But, you can relate to Belphegor lyrically???
rattleyourgodamnhead's Avatar
rattleyourgodamnhead | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
While Nile are amazing musicians, and the production of this album is outstanding, I just cannot relate to any of their music lyrically. I really don't give a shit about ancient egypt or whatever the hell it is their songs are about. I'll keep spinning the new Belphegor/Hypocrisy albums instead.
bongripper's Avatar
bongripper | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
The best death metal cd of '09 in a year that featured MANY excellent releases..
ex-inferis's Avatar
ex-inferis | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Dude he's probably like one of the best drummers. ever. Can't get enough of this one. Insane stuff.
rattlehe@d's Avatar
rattlehe@d | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Nile is one of those bands that i literally adore ALL (caps lock ffs!!!) of their albums. I so much like this band. I agree that there's not much progression to their style but who needs change if they play so friggin amazing and original? Anyway i think ithyplalic was as great album as Annihilation of the wicked and of their darkened shrines. This one, i can't wait till it's in my hands.. But i don't think it's possible that i won't like it. Regards to George Kollias which is from my country (along with gus g i think they are the best metal insrument players from Greece) and the rest of the band!
The Devil Himself's Avatar
The Devil Himself | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Good, but just like every other Nile album. Will this get hyped up to the point of insanity? I'm sure of it.
slaytanic1's Avatar
slaytanic1 | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
I`m surprised by how much I like this. I found the last one a bit of a bore and presumed they`d run out of steam but this is superb.
DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
I have a feeling that this will probably be one of my favorite albums.
dragos's Avatar
dragos | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
great fucking album
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
Amazing album complete with Egyptian gang chants. They sound reinvigorated somehow, and the production seems updated. They still sound like Nile though. Nile rules.
deathgrindattacken's Avatar
deathgrindattacken | posted on 10/2009 | Reply
YES