Album Review

Score 6.3
Written by Zach Duvall
Published on 8/2/2009
Sky Shadow Obelisk is an experimental doom project from the mind of Rhode Island multi-instrumentalist/vocalist/composer Peter Scartabello. On this self-titled EP and debut release, Scartabello applies his classical training to two tracks totaling over 26 minutes, mixing funeral doom, avant-garde, spoken word, and smatterings of other styles.

The song “Sky Shadow Obelisk” is a monster of minimalist and oppressively forceful funeral doom. Minimalist because it foregoes the keys and melancholic lead guitar that many bands within the style employ, stripping down to just the heavy percussion (the ride cymbal sounds like the ticking of winding-down oblivion) and very heavy, punctuated guitar riffs. Oppressively forceful because the song itself seems reluctant to keep going at times. Scartabello’s vocals are somewhat inconsistent, but luckily his deep death growls, which would be at home anywhere in the genre, are more common than the occasional ill-suited yells. However, this small flaw does little harm to this well written and very well produced song which simultaneously evokes atmosphere and claustrophobia.

Unfortunately, “Ex Oblivione” continues neither the title track’s style nor quality. Dedicated to H.P. Lovecraft, the song is an odd stylistic mix that fails to garner attention until very late, getting to the doom finally at the 12 minute mark. Starting with a strange dissonant rock intro, the song mostly consists of an overlong crescendo that includes long sections of spoken word poetry. While the artistic intent is undoubtedly honest, the results fail to urge repeated listens.

I am curious to see if Scartabello writes a full album under the Sky Shadow Obelisk moniker, and if he does, if it will take on the approach of the first or second song on this EP. A set of songs similar to the title track could potentially position him as a strong new voice within the order of extreme doom.



DeathMetalJesus's Avatar
DeathMetalJesus | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Hey Peter man, don't be bummed about anything, At the end of the day, regardless of what a few people down there have said, you've got your music exposed on here, and people are undoubtedly going to want to check it out. Though I feel you could have gone about that lash a little differently - it demonstrated your passion for what you do. I checked out your music and pretty much agree with the review.
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
This thread is bananas! There's more twists in these posts than...um...fuck it I don't have a joke. I'm goin to sleep.
SymX's Avatar
SymX | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
I wouldn't rape you if I didn't think you were sexy
eminor's Avatar
eminor  | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Everybody just needs to hang tight. We'll get a review posted and give an honest opinion on this album. Deep breaths, folks.
pscart's Avatar
pscart | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Hey Ellipsis, I'm so sorry dude if I came off as elitist. I just felt like I needed to defend myself and what I do. I am sorry I even joined this site. Please don't let this whole debacle turn you off from my music, I felt like I was coerced into this ridiculous debate, if you can even call it that. All I'm saying is, let the music speak for itself, because that is what is most important to me. The whole point of posting the review was to get people interested in what I do, and now I feel like it totally backfired and I am bummed about that, and your last comment makes me feel even worse about this whole thing. I wish I could erase this whole page. Ugghhhh.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Well the Decibel review had me interested, but after that last lash, I don't even know if I'm going to bother. Prickish elitism turns me off. Sorry dude.
pscart's Avatar
pscart | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Thanks eminor. Dudes need to get a life. I'm busting my ass writing, playing and recording music and your just voicing your goddamn opinions. I'm not going to go down this road with Bezoar and SymX because this childish internet ranting doesn't interest me, lets just say that you wouldn't say this stuff to my face. And if all you do is say how shitty things are, then I feel bad for your life. If you really understood what metal means, you would respect the brotherhood. I have been listening, playing and writing metal since 1982, wre you even born yet?!! I'm done, I hope you all give my album a shitty review!!!! Your opinions and your lives mean absolutely nothing to me!
eminor's Avatar
eminor  | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Relax, guys. Not that big of a deal. Guy's trying to promote his music.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Wow. You need to let us decide how shitty your music is. That's our job. It's what we do.
pscart's Avatar
pscart | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Sorry dudes. I didn't want to review my own album. hahaha. I just want people to listen to my music. I look forward to getting raped in my sleep.
WERKZEUG's Avatar
WERKZEUG | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Yeah, that was fairly obnoxious.
SymX's Avatar
SymX | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
pscart, I'm gonna rape you in your sleep, and I'm definitely NOT going to pull out.
PolarBear's Avatar
PolarBear | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Seriously guy, I like Decibel too, but that was ridiculously lame.
Reverend Campbell's Avatar
Reverend Campbell  | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
The marquee says "Metal Review." Not "Decibel." We encourage (and thrive on) reader comments, but original thoughts are preferred.
PizzaClaus's Avatar
PizzaClaus | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Thanks?
pscart's Avatar
pscart | posted on 8/2009 | Reply
Sky Shadow Obelisk is the one-man band of Peter Scartabello, a multi-instrumentalist and avant-garde composer, who, under his own name, releases diverse and way impressive avant-classical compositions, However, unlike the other kind-of-long-hair music he plays (the classical stuff), in SSO you won't be hearing much that invokes Messiaen. Here it's all about the doom, the artful doom plunked in a long two-song EP framework. "Ex Oblivione" really had this writer's ears standing up with its spinning kaleidoscope of dark sounds: raw, dissonant and very Voivod-ian heavy-assed riffs that get overcome by ambient guitar, distorted bass bellows, clicking hand percussion, Slint-like spoken word recitations, clean singing, interstellar fusion/jazz axe solos and death metal shout-sing. "Ex Oblivione" is a killer track indeed; however, the clean singing isn't delivered as confidently as the adroit guitar and massive death grunts- maybe more voice lessons before the clean vocals stand so nakedly? Surprisingly, after all the variations of "Ex Oblivione," the self-titled track is a classic very sloooow doom number throughout- sustaining, slowly shifting power chords and single notes, sandwiched by hellish grunt-sing. A solid, impressive debut and a perfect addition to all the extreme metal albums showing allegiance to H.P. Lovecraft- the EP is dedicated to the Great Old One's scribe. -Shawn Bosler of Decibel Magazine