Album Review

Score 8.5
Written by Chris McDonald
Published on 3/20/2008
The EP is an interesting format. For most bands it's either a way to get rid of old material that‘s been sitting around for awhile, or a quick cash-grab (usually both). For others, the EP is their bread-and-butter method for releasing great new material, even more so than their full-lengths--see Jesu. Since their inception, Agalloch have used their EP releases as a way of supplementing their full-lengths with music somewhat more esoteric and experimental than what is found on the albums. I’m a big fan of all three of Agalloch’s full-lengths, but confess to only having ever heard one of their experimental EP’s, that being 2001’s Of Stone, Wind and Pillor. I enjoyed most of the material on that release, so my ears perked up when I heard that Agalloch were releasing an EP follow-up to the masterful Ashes Against The Grain. The White features seven acoustic folk/ambient tracks recorded at various points in the last several years, and I’m pleased to report that it does an admirable job of standing up to the rest of the group‘s esteemed catalog. I consider it a testament to a band’s talent when they can succeed in making music outside their established recognized style; The White offers a different musical take on Agalloch’s themes of nature and death that is no less compelling (and even more so in some ways) to me than their more metal-oriented material.

I admit that as a huge sucker for emotional acoustic and ambient music, Agalloch is scratching me right where I itch here. These songs simply drip with the kind of melancholic beauty that has come to symbolize the band since Pale Folklore. Despite the shorter length and instrumental minimalism (often just an acoustic guitar and/or keyboards), this EP left me with that same emotionally-drained feeling I get after finishing one of their full-lengths simply because of the power and conviction with which these guys deliver these tunes. The emotive “The Isle Of Summer” really tugs at the heartstrings with its moody and simple acoustic melodies, while “Birch Black” gives off a warmer, more folk-influenced vibe that is relaxing after the depressing opener. “Hollow Stone” is an incredibly powerful ambient piece, blanketing the listener with layers of beautiful synth-passages that sound even better than the ambient experiments heard on Ashes Against the Grain. Many people complain about ambient music being “unrewarding;” not so here.

The epic “Pantheist” follows with subdued, wordless vocalizations from John Haughm and a majestic blend of depressive acoustics and synth that create a full, richly detailed sonic picture. Agalloch aptly displays their talent here for layering the various aspects of their music into rich and detailed compositions, which is especially important when playing music without the immediacy of loud guitars or harsh vocals. “Birch White” features a poem recitation by Haughm laid over more uplifting strumming, while “Sowilo Rue” adds some beautiful piano tinkling to back the guitars. This song and sweeping closer “Summerisle Reprise” both feature effective sampling from the classic film The Wicker Man, and its use at the end of the latter makes for an especially haunting and memorable end to the work.

With excellent production and packed with about as much sincere feeling as one can ask for in this type of music, The White is (surprise) yet another strong success for Agalloch. While I can’t say for sure that everyone that’s a fan of Agalloch will be able to appreciate this work due to its deviation from their more recognized style, the musical strength of this material is undeniable. It's got all the atmosphere and emotional impact of the outfit’s flagship releases in a sound that is both grand in scope and subdued in context. From start to finish, a fine example of this band’s tremendous abilities.



Anonymous's Avatar
Anonymous | posted on 8/2011 | Reply
One of my favorite albums of all time. Dark and beautiful, elegant from start to finish. Seriously annoying to find where I live though.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 11/2010 | Reply
Had to re-visit this since the newest album dropped. Still a rewarding and laid back listen. Elegant, yet it feels so simple.
bamafan's Avatar
bamafan | posted on 10/2008 | Reply
I just got this and "The Mantle" at the same time. This is great, but I like The Mantle more at this point. Actually I like The Mantle better than Ashes I think. Man, I'm so glad I found this band on MR!
RationalGaze's Avatar
RationalGaze | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
this ep is so beautiful from start to finish, the perfect soundtrack to fall asleep to at night, it's WAY more than a mere cash grab music like this is hard to review/score but you did a great job and I totally agree with your numbers, cheers!
Mortem's Avatar
Mortem | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Picked up a copy of this at their show. Simply brilliant.
Devin's Avatar
Devin | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
@ YourMom - have you heard Ashes Against the Grain? I honestly think it's even a step above The Mantle. Absolutely brilliant music from a brilliant band. I can't wait to hear this EP -- I'm still waiting on my preorder from Vendlus.
ellipsis's Avatar
ellipsis | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Initially, I found this to be disappointing. After giving it some time and more listens, I've decided that it is quite good. Some of the little nuances such as accordions and gentle twinklings of the ivory are my favorite parts. Most likely Top 10.
Bradination's Avatar
Bradination | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
This is a STRONG release from them. Completely aping the neo-folk and wearing their influences on their sleeve. I like this a lot and it'll probably be in my top ten for the year.
The Metal Mallet's Avatar
The Metal Mallet | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
I'm looking forward to finally listening to this soon. Come Saturday, I'll finally have this sucker in my hands.
Mortem's Avatar
Mortem | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
You've just pumped me up for their live show. Can't wait to see these guys on Satarday! Awesome review!
YourMom's Avatar
YourMom | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Decent, like most of their stuff. "The Mantle" is pretty much a masterpiece but other than that this band hasn't done anything special.
vugelnox's Avatar
vugelnox | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
always a very cool band. Not too many metal acts hit this particular vibe, the last Negura Bunget album Om is the only one that comes immediately to mind. Hopefully I'll see these guys live one day
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
@Juho Yikes! Thanks for spotting that. Not sure what was in my head when I typed that. Fixed now.
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
This ep is very cool. Everything Agalloch does is very cool.
Juho's Avatar
Juho  | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
The other EP from 2001 you're talking about is 'Of Stone, Wind and Pillor'.