Album Review

Score 9.3
Written by Jim Brandon
Published on 2/15/2008
For nearly a decade Hate Eternal have been blasting us into utter oblivion, shamelessly pushing the most extreme velocities of death metal to their limits. I’ve been paying very close attention to this band every step of the way, but stop short of fanboyism because, honestly, I find Erik Rutan’s brainchild to be rather overwhelming in a sometimes not-so-pleasant fashion. Through three albums Rutan and his modestly revolving lineup of fellow bandmates have proven they are all highly capable musicians, and certainly know how to rev-up the speed to inhumane levels, but there has been a special something missing since the debut, Conquering The Throne. Now, with the unchaining of Fury And Flames, Erik and this new recording lineup not only continue to bombard listeners with a wholly intense blasting barrage, but also bring forth an element slightly lacking on both King Of All Kings, and I, Monarch: vital substance.

Yes, it is yet another totally merciless death metal assault from Hate Eternal, but there is also a very deep emotional vibe to this entire album. Inspired by the tragic passing of multitalented, and terribly missed former bassist Jared Anderson (creator of Internecine), there is a true heaviness to this disc which is apparent from the onset. This album exudes not only the grief, but the venomous anger and frustration of dealing with the loss, and as a result, Fury And Flames is a musical step forward on all fronts. Simplicity and complexity collide within these chaotic measures, and one of the first things I noticed is the drumming of newcomer Jade Simonetto. Unlike the clinical, machinelike coldness displayed by Derek Roddy on past albums, Jade adds nuance, subtle precision, and a very humanlike warmth to the events, and yeah, the fucker can also lay down rapid-fire beats to rival just about anyone else in the death metal business (as I glance toward George Kollias, and Kevin Talley among others). Seriously, where did Erik find this dude, and where has he been hiding?

Another thing I absolutely need to mention is there is no catharsis to be felt throughout this album, and the usual release of negative energy that accompanies albums such as this does not exist here. The riffs of “Fury Within”, “Para Bellum”, “Funerary March” and “Thus Salvation” slide like blades across skin, blending both sinuous speed and massive crunch with no sympathy. “Tombeau (Le Tombeau De La Fureur et Des Flames)” is a burly tune that lurches through different tempos with great success, showing a slower and more melodic side to the band with no lessening of power. The disc ends majestically with the operatic “Coronach”, an apt contrast to “Hell Envenom” which opens the album with nerve ratting, terse mid-range speed picking, while mammoth, dynamic tracks like “Bringer Of Storms”, ‘Proclamation Of The Damned”, and “Whom Gods May Destroy” collect many of the best riffs I’ve heard since the debut, along with some of Rutan’s most alkaline vocals to date. Even though the overall pace might be a tad bit slower as a whole from a blasting perspective, the title of this release could not be more accurate when it comes to total presentation.

If there is a weak point to be found, it may lie with the thickness of the guitars which dominate everything, including the drums. Normally, a rhythm guitar-heavy album doesn’t bother me, but with a bass virtuoso like Alex Webster (Cannibal Corpse) involved with the proceedings, I would have really liked to hear him a little clearer since the bass I could pin down sounded incredible. Adding second guitarist Shaune Kelley definitely helps with fleshing out the sounds, but some additional bottom-end thump and vibration could have pushed things to perfection.

In the end, this is not simply a new Hate Eternal record, it’s an absolutely monstrous display of heartfelt rage from Erik Rutan and his accomplices. Finally, the beast shows its soul, and not just its wrecking ability, but does so as ferociously as ever before. While not groundbreaking to the genre, Fury And Flames could truly set Hate Eternal firmly among the upper-tier in death metal today with some successful touring and proper promotion, and considering the muse for such a display of malice, I’d say gained respect and awe is aptly deserved. This album is not to be fucked with.



megalith's Avatar
megalith | posted on 9/2011 | Reply
A HUGE disappointment for me. Shaune Kelley plays on this and I can't even hear him. Awful production in my opinion. It is more suited to hip-hop.
ungzilla's Avatar
ungzilla | posted on 8/2010 | Reply
dunno what y'all are listening to but this is perhaps the loudest i've ever heard bass in the mix on a death metal album... you can hear virtually every note. and this album is generally pretty cool. tombeau is an epic tune.
shiekaleekmydeek's Avatar
shiekaleekmydeek | posted on 3/2010 | Reply
this band just sucks you wont listen to this ever again buy something else
zach's Avatar
zach  | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
Case and point: Dark Tranquillity, totally bland live, great records.
Iron Maiden's Avatar
Iron Maiden | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
There are great studio bands that are horrible live. To say you need to see a band live before reviewing a studio album is pretty fucking stupid.
shiekaleekmydeek's Avatar
shiekaleekmydeek | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
I can't help but wonder how good this band would be if they actually could write a decent tune
Randy's Avatar
Randy | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
We can only review them if we see them live? Fuck that. I can't help but wonder how good this band would be if they had cleaned up the production.
shiekaleekmydeek's Avatar
shiekaleekmydeek | posted on 12/2009 | Reply
It is said ,don't judge a man until you walk a mile in his shoes. The same can hold true to a band, don't review until you see them live.Not being a fan of this genre, I found it difficult to enjoy , but , after seeing them live ,I am certain that this band is just bad. I am not alone as the crowd did not respond. In saying this the sound quauity was poor until the final tune ,which was still bad.These guys should take a page from Unearth and write music and move around on stage.
rehtafsedaj777's Avatar
rehtafsedaj777 | posted on 9/2009 | Reply
Hi jim!I'm jades' dad and as you can imagine i'm very proud of his success.I must say i find your writing a cut above the rest!Man you should write a book :the history of metal!Keep up the eloquence and thanks for the wonderful words about my son....John.
vggls's Avatar
vggls | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
this album does not do much for me
Fecal Facial's Avatar
Fecal Facial | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
The drums are way too high in the mix on this album.
mortiis73's Avatar
mortiis73 | posted on 5/2008 | Reply
I'm still trying to let this one grow on me. Normally, I really enjoy Rutan's production style, but this one missed the mark with me. It's such an incredibly DENSE sounding record. Maybe one day the riffs will reveal themselves to me.
zuglo's Avatar
zuglo | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
Good review - I agree that what bass I could hear sounded fantastic. Overall, my favourite album by them. Still way down the list of essential death metal bands.
dogofchaos's Avatar
dogofchaos | posted on 3/2008 | Reply
hmmm, i think i bought HE albums more coz of the artwork then for appreciation for the music!! stupid me. but this album, like goatwhore, is something ill probably never digest. did someone mention morbid angel?
Unknown Metalhead
vocivus | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
The drummer on the record, Jade Simmonetto has always been a popular member of the Artisan Foundry, Derek Roddy's death metal forum for musician's and was previously known on the web as "ironcobraman". His drumming on the record crushes everything in its path with incredibly heavy and merciless blasts. One thing I think was a miss for me was the amount of focus of the bass drum in the mix which sounds to me to be second from Erik's vocals. Also as a result, as Jim mentioned, I would like to hear more of webster on the record which many times is consumed by the amount of bass focus in the drums. IMO this record is a 6 on songrwriting, 6 on Musicianship and a 4 n production.
jonathan's Avatar
jonathan | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
This band's music is incredibly fucking dense, much moreso than even standard death/brutal-death. It takes me a few songs to adjust for properly listening to what they have to offer. There is actually some pretty great songwriting buried underneath all of the chaos, you just have to know how to listen for it. At least, that's my experience with this band. Also, it is not all constant blasting. Just listen to "Fury Within."
Matt's Avatar
Matt  | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
@BEZOAR I agree.
BEZOAR's Avatar
BEZOAR | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Way overrated. As is all their material. Rutan needs to stick behind the boards. That's where he shines.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I love blastbeats as well, but there has to be substance to the riffs to put the speed and intensity in context; otherwise, its just hitting the fucking snare drum. You named some good examples; bands like Nile and Vader blast like living hell, but they have the riffs to make actual songs. I will say that, as much as I don't like Hate Eternal, Erik Rutan is a damn fine producer. I didn't like the newest Vital Remains or Cannibal Corpse albums that much, but the production was fucking immense. DOWN WTH CLICKY BASS-DRUMS!!!
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I guess it is kinda funny to be complaining about blast beats on a death metal album. I love blast beats. Decrepit Birth's And Time Begins album is really just one long blast beat, and I love it. But at least there's some cool guitar shit going on. If it wasn't for Jade Simmoneto throwing in some cool shit around the blast beats, I'd be even more disappointed in this. All the reviews for this album say how more diverse this album is, and how they've taken a huge step forward. Ummm, not really. That being said, there's no denying the heart and hard work that Rutan put into this. He made the album he wanted to make. Through all the negative things to say about this album, there's an air of dignity and respect flowing through it. But I have to disagree with the reviewer saying this album will put HE into the upper-tier of the death metal ranks. I'd say middle-tier. When I think upper-tier I think of Cannibal Corpse, Cryptopsy, Suffocation, Decapitated, Vader. These bands write more interesting stuff than HE without sacrificing brutality (and yes, blast beats). Rutan's set to produce the new Cannibal Corpse record later this year. If I can't hear Alex Webster or the guitars I'll be extremely pissed. Keep the Kill sound and we'll be fine.
steve p's Avatar
steve p | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
On a side note now is Dim Mak coming out with anything anytime soon? I enjoyed the hell out of Knives of Ice.
deathgrindattacken's Avatar
deathgrindattacken | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I agree with this JB fellow, the biggest disappointment with this album has to be the fact that i just cant hear the fucking guitars, the production is cool, it has a lot of weight and atmosphere but, like he said, all you can really hear is the drums, which are and sound phenomenal, and the vocals. Eric Rutan and Shaune Kelley(listen to DIM MAK) are both amazing guitar players, the fact that i have to listen so hard to pick out the riffs is a god damn shame. While i do believe that this band would benefit greatly if they would let the music breathe instead of burring everything under constant blast beats and double bass, there is still some good song writing going on here. Initially i loved this album, but after repeat listens, i find it to be a bit of a let down, im still a big HE fan but mostly for what the band could be, so much potential for greatness. I think if Rutan would abandon his idea of trying to push the limits of brutality or whatever this bands mission statement is and tried something with a little more tact. The biggest problem in death metal to me is that nobody seems to recognize the benefits of being tasteful. HE for the most part is completely tasteless.
Chris McDonald's Avatar
Chris McDonald  | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Uggh. I truly loathe this band. "Brutality" and blastbeats are no substitute for real songwriting. HE is a testament to everything that is wrong with death metal today. ...That said, great review your Dekeness ;)
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Erik, you're a guitar player. Where are the riffs? The highlight of this album is Jade Simmoneto. Too bad you can't hear anything else. All I can hear are vocals and drums. I really wanted to hear Alex Webster. Too bad. That being said...I still respect Erik Rutan. The dude is brutal. Like Coma said, heavy as balls.
Unknown Metalhead
ComaFaction | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
heavy as balls. good stuff.
trezevant's Avatar
trezevant  | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
like most Hate Eternal albums, this would be great death metal if they would let the riffs breathe once in a while instead of burying 95% of the parts under blastbeats.
sandwiches's Avatar
sandwiches | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
@ yersinia um what town did you see them in? ha if it was lawrence ks then i had no idea that one of the reviewers lived near here
Bradination's Avatar
Bradination | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I might check this out. Although Hate Eternal is notorious to me as one of the most uninteresting death metal bands ever.
endless yeti's Avatar
endless yeti | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
this album is such a huge step forward from I, monarch. i just got it yesterday and listened to it straight through. i honestly wasnt expecting that much but it blew me out of the water. the production is perfect for the album and the addition of shaun kelley and alex webster was def a right move. the new drummer also exceeded my expectations, i thought he would be a roddy clone but he adds his own favour and really makes the album dynamic. the first time i listened to /i, monarch it was over my head but since then i have listened to it so much its just part of my trained ear for death metal, now that they came out with this i feel like i have to start over. i will have to listen to this much much more to fully realize what is going on, you cannot judge this album with only one or two listens or especially if you have only listened to a couple songs. erik rutan has def pushed the boudaries of death metal this time.
Zaibach's Avatar
Zaibach | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I can't stand constant blastbeat and double bassdrum throughout an entire album, especially with a drum sound that I don't dig. Definitely not my kind of Death Metal, and I definitely don't like Rutan's tone and production.
chud's Avatar
chud | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I thought the reviewer and all the lashers were being wusses- but this album might actually be a little too much for me. They're so percise and exacting I want to like it though! It's kind of like the most insane parts of Keep of Kallesin- the whole way through the album!
Haphazard's Avatar
Haphazard | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Man, Rutan has evolved into quite possibly the best death metal producer of modern time. His production jobs just get better and better, with a heavy thickness that death metal deserves, and a bass clarity that noone else seems to nail properly. He's come a long way since that Pessimist album...
JB's Avatar
JB | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Looking forward to this. While I admired I, Monarch, it was just too much to handle after awhile. I was puzzled with it because I can handle some brutal shit. But for some reason, it wore me out about halfway through. And yeah, it sounded like something was missing. Sounds like everything is in place on Fury and Flames though, and I'll be at the store on Tuesday to pick it up. Now where the FUCK are Morbid Angel?! Please get Rutan to produce the new one...PLEASE!
vortex's Avatar
vortex | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
This one took me some time to grow into. It's definitely not an album you can listen to any time of day. There is just so much going on at the same time. The first time I heard it I thought Erik just got together with a bunch of speed freaks and decided to go balls out with their respecitve instruments. After listening to it a few times you realise there is a lot going on underneath. I'm guessing a lot of people are not going to like it at first but give it a chance because this is some killer metal!
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Ummm...didn't the reviewer say that Alex was too low in the mix? And bobsundy...don't say that something is "too complex" for some one. I hate people get high and mighty about albums...makes you sound like a Tool fan. It's the same scenario...fanboys won't call shit when it's shit from their favorite band.
Unknown Metalhead
bobsundy | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
pfft....blow me RedSkull, this album is too complex for your underdeveloped brain. Fury and Flames rules, songwriting is top-notch. I'm glad Erik gave Alex Webster his due respect by turning up the bass!! Sounds too good to be true! 'Fury Within' is a phenomonal track. This is the most devestating album i've heard in 5 years.
SpiritCrusher's Avatar
SpiritCrusher | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
This is one of my most anticipated releases this year and I'll be picking it up on Tuesday. Thanks for the great reveiw. It's nice to read one where the reviewer seems to have actually listened to the album.
RedSkull's Avatar
RedSkull | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Gimme a break This record is a 4 out of 6 BIG MAXIMUM for the songwriting..,, it sound more confusing on the whole than anything else
tanknitrous's Avatar
tanknitrous | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Eh, more of the same from Hate Eternal. Blast, blast, blast. Yes, there is a place for it, but not constant like it is on EVERY Hate Eternal album. They can blast with the best of them, but for the last time...THERE ARE NO SONGS!!!!!!! It's just a constant blast! I realize that some enjoy this. Guess it's not for me, give me my Morbid Angel. I'm being an ass...I'll stop.
Yersinia Pestyler's Avatar
Yersinia Pestyler | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
although i will probably still check this out, so i might be eating my words soon enough.
Yersinia Pestyler's Avatar
Yersinia Pestyler | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
bleh. i've heard minimal Hate Eternal on record and wasn't impressed in the least. then i saw them play with Black Dahlia Murder last week and they were easily the most boring group of the night (including two local metalcore openers).
JW's Avatar
JW  | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
I've always thought they were a band who was better than their records. Maybe this is the record that will change that. I'll check it out.
jbo52988's Avatar
jbo52988 | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
Heard a couple of songs off this album on myspace, seems like the review is right on point
Dave's Avatar
Dave  | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
i'm not a huge HE fan, but I think they have definite place in the death metal world, and I respect the hell out of what Rutan is trying to do.
Dr. Neo Cortex's Avatar
Dr. Neo Cortex | posted on 2/2008 | Reply
agree with this review, although I haven't heard this cd yet there definitely was that certain "something" missing from other hate eternal cds.