Album Review

Score 8.3
Written by Doug Moore
Published on 10/18/2005
First things first with this review: see those three numbers just above this text? DISREGARD THOSE NUMBERS. Completely. This band, or collective, or whatever it is, can’t really be judged on the same criteria as the majority of the material reviewed here; Sunn0)))’s music is far too esoteric and amorphous to be accurately considered metal, and that fact will likely drive away many a metalhead.

Fact is, I’m not sure this shit can be rightly considered music, and at this point there ought not to be many people still reading at all. Those who still are probably have a standing familiarity with the breed of sludge/drone/ambient/avante-garde noise assault that Sunn0))) produces, and would likely be satisfied no matter what this bizarrely iconic Khanate side project produced. However, for the very few uninitiated still present, I’ll do what I can do elucidate this…I hesitate to call it a style. Philosophy seems more appropriate.

As far as I can tell, this shit is heaviness removed from the context of ‘heavy metal’ and taken to its logical extreme. The sonic weight captured on this disc is incalculable, and its delivery is about as palatable and user-friendly as an untranslated Hegel manuscript. The ‘songs’ are free of rhythm and often also devoid of identifiable instruments, and tend to run towards the lengthy side of things. The aesthetic effect has less in common with traditional music than it does with primitive stone obelisks and monuments; Sunn0)))’s output is virtually immobile and static, conveying a single idea with mind-blowing gravity.

The fact that this is likely Sunn0)))’s darkest album to date makes things that much more interesting, or that much more unlistenable, depending on your perspective. Black One opens with the uncharacteristically brief ambience of “Sin Nanna” before launching…erm…shifting into “It Took the Night to Believe.” The track features, believe it or not, somewhat recognizable guitar and bass and something approaching but not quite achieving rhythm. Whatever measure of comfort and confidence the listener can take from such a familiar setting won’t last long, though. “Cursed Realms (Of The Winterdemons)” begins the album in proper, annihilating all vestiges of musical tradition and leaving a blasted, desolate landscape over which massive bodies of static tumble in slow motion. The only remotely human aspects of the track are heavily distorted, howling vocals, but they’re far too bleak and distant to offer any sort of respite. The punishing drones and textures that make up the body of Black One are far too stark for extended listening without the aid of mind-altering drugs; all but the hardiest listeners will want to attack this monolith piece by piece. Even those can prove daunting, as the fifteen-minute running time of icy closer “Bathory Erzebet” will attest.

This is the sort of musical idiot-savantry that I can never decide if I love or despise. If nothing else, this band’s work should be credited as an extremely interesting experiment with the boundaries of music, straddling the line between the absolute extreme edge of doom metal inhabited by Earth and Buried At Sea and the sterile, unapproachable chaos of Masami Akita’s Merzbow project. It is utterly bleak, incredibly challenging, and maddeningly deliberate. Oh yeah, and it’s heavy as fuck. Listen at your own risk.



Zombie Creeping Flesh's Avatar
Zombie Creeping Flesh | posted on 6/2009 | Reply
Doug, interesting review but dude, this is NOT a Khanate side project. This was never a side project. Khanate was a collaboration between Stephen O'Malley and James Plotkin and could be described as a side project. Even with the huge number of projects O'Malley is involved in, most would consider Sunn O))) his 'main' band. This album fuckin' rules.
deathfreak's Avatar
deathfreak | posted on 3/2009 | Reply
this band owns. just put it on and space out
Unknown Metalhead
king of the damned | posted on 12/2007 | Reply
You dont get itIt might take 6 months of listening But sunn o))) are opening different dimensions with their music! Drugs help but are not necessary..an open mind is I love absolutly love all their cds!!!! except ALTAR wich is possible the easiest to get into And make no mistake Sunn knows how to play extreemly well One of the greatest live acts as well This black one s great..its the first I bought and yes it took ages before I loved it Now..I m really into Flight of the behemoth and both white cds!!!! Best band around no question about it!
Unknown Metalhead
Munger | posted on 10/2007 | Reply
What album art are people talking about? The covers great but theres only 2 other pictures with 4 or 5 blank pages. Anyway great for meditating...I think you have to be a certain kind of person to find this relaxing rather than terrifying.
Unknown Metalhead
josh | posted on 5/2007 | Reply
I brought this album threw curiosity and it was the first I had heard of sunn 0))). It first I found a lot of it hard to listen to and to be honest it was almost painful to get through some of the tracks (cursed realms and bathory erzebet). The tracks i liked where candlegoat and it took the night to believe. Its funny cos now I would say I love the album, my favourite track is still candlegoat but I would say it would be closely followed by bathory erzebet and I even get drawn into the dark ambience of cursed realms now. I guess what im trying to say is at first it was hard to listen to but now I love this album and listen to it the whole way through(without the aid of drugs). It is both creepy and relaxing to listen to at the same time. I suggest listening to it in a dark room and having it turned up very loud. Spot on review in most parts.(didnt mean to write so much...sorry)
Unknown Metalhead
lilah | posted on 11/2006 | Reply
I recently saw them as an opener for Celtic Frost. The rumours about how they suck as a live act are completely untrue. They had the entire audience in need of an earthquake retrofit by the end of their set. Absolutely amazing experience.
Chris's Avatar
Chris | posted on 11/2006 | Reply
I got Altar recently, and while it kicks ass, it DOES NOT compare to this album. I still love listening to Black One now, a year after it came out. I feel confident saying its the best drone record since Earth 2.
Unknown Metalhead
lilah | posted on 11/2006 | Reply
This album got me into SUNN O))) (!). I guess that would make me a doom drone fan, 'cause I really haven't found anything heavier. I love this album but would have to agree that this kind of thing is not for everyone. No fast riffing or blast beats anywhere. But if you crave low, slow and unbelievably creepy, here you go. Great review!
Irukandji's Avatar
Irukandji | posted on 9/2006 | Reply
This band is amazing live. Absolute power and drone. It's quite an experience. I listen to this cd late at night in the winter, driving through backwoods country. Solid review of a great and challenging sonic listen.
Johnston's Avatar
Johnston | posted on 9/2006 | Reply
I know, but I just wanna learn Orhtodox Caveman and I can't figure out what tuning their guitars are.
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/MR | posted on 9/2006 | Reply
...tuning? Are you serious? I don't think tuning really plays much of a factor in this music.
Johnston's Avatar
Johnston | posted on 9/2006 | Reply
Does any one know what tuning these guys use for this album?
Unknown Metalhead
Steve Local | posted on 9/2006 | Reply
Black One is one of the most impressive and single-minded musical statements I've heard in years. They may enjoy being daft with their credits - I particularly like the credit of "Drone Slut" who allegedly plays bass - but Sunn 0))) clearly aren't taking the piss. Bathory Erszebet, the closer, is incredibly powerful. If you don't have the patience for it, fair enough, but "anaturaldisaster" is absolutely right - they're not fucking around.
Unknown Metalhead
DeadRiverDoom | posted on 5/2006 | Reply
This album I don't even bother to check and remember song titles this is an album in it's purest sense. One complete body of work to encompase the artists ideals. And mind altering drugs do help. I put this on with a cd of gregorian chants layered over it and my god it is to much for my little acid burned brain.
Unknown Metalhead
Dom | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
This is metal for Four Tet fans. Massive!
Unknown Metalhead
Jorm | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
yeah i loved that intro (candlegoat) as well. outstanding Cd in all.
Unknown Metalhead
ChrisDawg88 | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
This is their best album since Flight Of The Behemoth. Much more variety than a lot of their contemporaries, this album is about as bleak and dark as you can get. The piano intro on "Candlegoat" is brilliant, as are the vocals on "It Took The Night To Believe" and "Bathory Erzebet". Great drone record.
Johnston's Avatar
Johnston | posted on 4/2006 | Reply
I absoutley love these guys, the sheer power of their music is amazing and song 4 is by far the coolest drone doom song written, the riffs are just amazing.
Unknown Metalhead
cliff | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
"favorite track-It took the night too believe" mine too. the vocals on it are amazing. and the art inside the booklet is even more disturbing than the cover art...
Unknown Metalhead
appleseed | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
Great album....best absorbed with a few good bong rips in your system. on a side note, it bears some of the absolute best album art I have ever seen. favorite track-It took the night too believe
Captain's Avatar
Captain  | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
Regarding Wrest: Not to take away from this fine review for Sunn o))), but as long as the forum section is down...you mean beyond his project, Lurker of Chalice, and his work in Twilight? Well, he's a prolific mother f'r. He's always got something in the works. Have you picked up his recent split w/Black Death? It's fucking great.
Unknown Metalhead
;aljds;fj; | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
Not really speaking of Leviathan, is Wrest coming out with anything in the perceivable future? Like the album art.
captain's Avatar
captain  | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
Black 1 has Malefic (Xasthur) on a couple songs, and Wrest (Leviathan) on one song, but it's hardly a Black Metal album...it's more like Sunn 0))) material w/their vocals. Apparently they had Malefic do part of his vocals from inside a coffin! It's a fucking good album...but I wouldn't get it if you're not into drone Doom.
Unknown Metalhead
Jamie | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
Does this album have any parts that sound black metal-ish? cos it has an Immortal cover and there are guest appearences by black metal musicians, such as the guy from Xasthur.
Unknown Metalhead
Pimp Daddy D | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
I don't understand the fascination with this band! Fuck, even I can play one chord for an hour straight!
Bernard's Avatar
Bernard | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
On 'Flight of the Behemoth' the song 'F.W.T.B.T.' was a cover of 'For Whom The Bell Tolls' by Metallica... already not recognizable at all...
Unknown Metalhead
Doug w/Metalreview | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
It might be an Immortal cover, but it's absolutely not recognizable as such.
Unknown Metalhead
Ashley | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
How are you supposed to tell one release from the other? Even if you love it...How can you say, "I like this one more than that one because in that song it sounds more like a very deep fart instead of a pretty deep fart." Or maybe, "That was a really long fart clocking in at 33 minutes with a guy talking over it telling a funny story about metal or something. That's why I like that song."
Unknown Metalhead
anaturaldisaster | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Cursed Realms Of The Winterdemons is an Immortal cover. In closing, Sunn 0))) are not fucking around, and I can't wait to get a copy of this one.
Unknown Metalhead
thomas | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
O mally and Co. are the most highly overated "metal" or "heavy" "music" purveyors of recent times. Listening to music that no one else likes does not make you cool. It just shows that you have poor taste in music.
Unknown Metalhead
andrew | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
grimrobe and white-1 are my favorites. i haven't picked this up yet. if anyone is a fan is it safe to say that they need to start of with grimrobe demos?
Unknown Metalhead
bleep | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
wha?confucktion, major.
Unknown Metalhead
Dr. M | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Parts of this blow me away, other parts bore me rigid. I found the infinitely repeated warm riffs of "Orthodox Caveman" to be incredibly relaxing whereas "Cursed Realms of the Winterdemons" is unlistenable. A paradoxical band, inhabiting their own unique sphere and therefore worthy for that reason.
Unknown Metalhead
Patrick w/ MetalReview | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
Grimrobe Demo will continue to be the only Sunn O album I can actually enjoy listening too.
Unknown Metalhead
agent graves | posted on 10/2005 | Reply
This is pretty bleak. I can't decide whether I like their other releases more yet. No doubt this is very intense listening made for a very specific frame of mind.