Album Review

Score 8.8
Written by Doug Moore
Published on 7/14/2005
It’s gotta be tough to be Soilent Green. The band has encountered an almost unfair share of adversity over the past four or five years. The multiple automotive tragedies that the New Orleans boys have suffered would be plenty enough to spell doom for most bands, but take into account how shamefully and undeservedly Soilent Green has been overshadowed by some of their more commercially viable Relapse labelmates, and well, you’ve got one pressure cooker of a situation right there. It takes indescribable quantities of personal strength and dedication to keep one’s shit together through that kind of agony, and like most artists, these Southern fellows tend to channel the emotional byproducts of their lives into their work. What we have here is an accurate documentation of how a half-decade of getting the shit end of the stick feels. Confrontation is, as its name suggests, a metal album that simply drips with integrity, musicality, vigor, and intensity. Oh, and lets not forget howling, paint-peeling, and immolating rage. This album will put hair on the chest and whiskey in the guts of even the most pimple-faced metal dork. It’s that good.

A conventional song-based breakdown of this album would be more or less pointless. As with most grindcore (for this is certainly a grindcore album), the important thing to grasp is the total experience it imparts upon the listener. The short, simple version is the well-known one: Soilent Green play a hybrid of chaotic grind and bluesy, Sabbath-ian sludge metal. The long version is that the band has here concocted a churning, frothy-mouthed swamp monster of an album that punishes with sheer auditory weight as often as it does with Tommy Buckley’s spot-on staggered blastbeats. There is little conventional songcraft to be found here; instead, the band whips the listener’s ears up, down, side to side, and around in pinwheels and barrel rolls through their convoluted music in search of the perfect riff/rhythm combination. But for all their involved musicianship, this doesn’t come off like prog wanking or tech-metal obscurism. Soilent Green are governed by a snarling, inarguably punk rock brand of aggression; just listen to that Discharge power-chord raving that opens “12 oz. Prophet.” Nor are they too entrenched in their own hyper-angry visage to occasionally loosen up; the drumline antics of “Southern Spirit Suite” and the lazy twang of “Liquor & Cigarettes” imbue the proceedings with a sort of sneering humor that is very welcome in a genre of music in which hardly anyone ever seems to be having any fun. This said, the little instrumental breaks don’t take away from the gravity of the album, and some gravity it is, too. When the band slows it down, the guitars and bass strike with a suffocating thickness and mass that reminds very strongly of their spiritual, musical and geographic cousins Eyehategod. And, of course, there is the indomitable Ben Falgoust ranting and bellowing over the jagged instrumental structure. The man’s performance gives no hint to the fact that in 2002 he was so severely injured in a van crash that he had to relearn the use of his legs; his scathing voice and famously vitriolic lyrics are intact and just as powerful as ever. Congratulations are in order for producer Erik Rutan, who has become an extremely skilled knob twiddler over the years. He has captured the smoking-steel violence wreaked by Soilent Green with flawless clarity without abandoning the grittiness required to complete the band’s ugly persona.

While this is an extremely, extremely excellent album, a pair of minor complaints bar it from a perfect score. The first is actually the double edge of one of their strengths: all of the complex riffage and tempo wrangling packed onto this disk make it a fairly unrelenting and challenging listen, and unprepared or inexperienced fans may find themselves overwhelmed by the Byzantine song structures. It also must be noted that this is not a huge progression from A Deleted Symphony for the Beaten Down, other than perhaps more speed and a (somehow) amplified level of intensity. Fans who were looking for vast stylistic changes from the previous album may be disappointed, but somehow I don’t think many will mind. Confrontation sees Soilent Green continue their tradition of unheralded excellence, and the metal world should take note. You out there with the pizza-face acne and Pantera shirt: buy this album. You won’t regret it.



Mortalcoil's Avatar
Mortalcoil | posted on 2/2009 | Reply
total collapse!!
WBM's Avatar
WBM | posted on 10/2007 | Reply
The vocals are much more intense than the previous releases, definite growth there.
Steve P's Avatar
Steve P | posted on 8/2006 | Reply
I'm not a huge fan of grindcore but I love this album. Theres just something about the grind combined with sludgish moments of this cd that makes it a much more interesting listen. Just curious if anyone knows of any other grind bands that sound anything like this.
Unknown Metalhead
Isa | posted on 3/2006 | Reply
Good Album, Horrible Review...
Unknown Metalhead
windowlicker | posted on 12/2005 | Reply
If you like grind/sludge/doom, I can't see how you can go wrong. Props and support to these guys. Saw them live bout 5 yrs ago and they tore it up. I've been listening to this pretty consistantly for a few months. Its what I put on when i don't really know what to put on if you know what I mean.Just as good as their previous releases.
Unknown Metalhead
Devilcyst | posted on 11/2005 | Reply
This record is fuckin awesome.
Unknown Metalhead
sethifer | posted on 8/2005 | Reply
an overwhelming proportion of metalheads are unwilling to treat soilent green albums with sufficient patience. granted, their particular brand of metal is a conglomerate of arguably the two least accessible subgenres in the scene(grind and sludge), but i would implore all you naysayers to give it another chance or ten. i owned "a deleted symphony for the beaten down" for six months before i really "got it," and now i can't get enough of this shit. makes me want to microwave puppies.
Unknown Metalhead
Ryan ex-MR | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
excellent album. Makes me want to dig up A Deleted Symphony. They're coming my way soon and I can't wait to see them.
Patrick's Avatar
Patrick | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
I'm not on board. I think they got hit with one too many cars. Its just not the same anymore.
Luke's Avatar
Luke | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Without doubt imo one of extreme metal's most unique & brilliant bands. i thought deleted symphony... was their best effort a nearly flawless album but from what ive heard of this new one i really, really liked. the production is very impressive & even though Ben's vocal attack seems to have abandoned his higher pitched "blackened" delivery his vocals still sound very intense & powerful & his deeper vocals are deeper then they have been since Pussysoul & a string of lies. Great review.
Unknown Metalhead
duder | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
i think there name kinda kills it, thats why didnt check them out for a while, theres just some band names that turn me off.
Unknown Metalhead
Frank | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
A definate pick-up.
Unknown Metalhead
Speci | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
I gotta give them credit for being one of the most consistent, hard touring, hard working bands ever, but, unfortunately I find the music itself boring, and uninteresting.
Unknown Metalhead
xknifeintheback | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
This album is yet another consistant delivery from these guys. They never seem to let me down. I feel as though not enough people know of this band, which is a shame. Long live The Green.
Unknown Metalhead
Doug | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Yeah, they obviously aren't particularly easy to classify, but I felt the speed and anger on the album made it way more grindcore than anything else.
Unknown Metalhead
Nick | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
good album, a little different vocally, and music-wise for them but i still dig it. i would hesitate to call this grindcore though...but i guess thats as close to a definate "genre" to call Soilent Green
Jacksonlefteye's Avatar
Jacksonlefteye | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
good review though, ill check these guys out
Ryan's Avatar
Ryan | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
This album is really good. Ben's vocals on this one are a slight disappointment though - they just don't sound as good as they always have, as though he is straining. I hope not, I hope he's doing okay! Great album nonetheless. SOILENT GREEN FOREVER.
Unknown Metalhead
erik | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
doug
Unknown Metalhead
RilontskY | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
i'll believe it when i hear it..
Eminor's Avatar
Eminor  | posted on 7/2005 | Reply
Excellent review. Great band, look forward to getting this.